Coney I-Lander

901 N 9th St, Broken Arrow
(918) 251-1242

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ally Norton

Not sure how this place acquired good reviews, very disappointing and waste of money.

Antpar

Fast service, very friendly staff, store and tables were clean, tables stocked with everything. Been doing it right for years and years. Keep up the good work

Will Penuel

Goodness with c&c, and a touch of mustard.

Kristofer Blu Duncan

They are the best. They need to do free weiner for the dogs tho. Haha j.s pup bites maybe. Idk.

Marissa Ramirez

The Coney’s were great and the customer service was very friendly.

Jimmy Robertson

Great cheese coneys!

Eric Jones

We went to Coney Islander with high expectations from past memories. It had been several years since we had been, and I was looking forward to chili cheese coneys like I remembered from back before I retired.

Unfortunately, they didn’t measure up to my expectations. Perhaps I expected more than I should have, but the taste was simply not what I remembered. The service was. Good, but, it was a Saturday afternoon and we were one of three tables of customers there. The restaurant was clean, considering the age of the building. Everything else was fine, except for the taste, and that was a letdown.

Joey Secrist

Best coneys around!

Grant Stephenson

I have about had it with this location. I have been going to this location at least 2 times per month for the last 2-3 years and each time I order the $35 (12 Coney family meal). The last 4 times I have been there they seem put out with the order by either rolling their eyes and or a deep sigh and have gone on to ultimately mess up the order. I typically use the drive through but this last time I decided to go inside so I could watch them make the order. Once again, when I made the order the lady rolled her eyes. I asked for the manager and explained the situation while the lady that took my orders was still making my Coney's. I also noticed that the same lady that took and was making my order was apologizing over and over to those behind me for the wait. It was without question a passive aggressive comment also meant for my ears. So not only was she put out by having to make 12 Coneys all at once, she couldn't apologize enough to the people that had to wait in line just like I did. Not sure I want to spend over $1,000/yr at a place that doesn't appreciate my business.

Michelle Mills

DO NOT EAT at the CONEY ISLAND IN B.A. they will rob you they will give you an order that is not yours and CHARGE YOU FOR IT. Then refused to give you the money back that they overcharged you on your credit card 38.36 for 5 coneys 2 tamales and then refuses to give the difference back. You cant get your money back they over charged you. But you can get free food why would you want to go back to people that rob you this place is pathetic

Steven Farless

Chili was a little Spicer than usual
Other than that it's was great!

Dale Forbus

Always great conies

Marie P

I have been craving coneys for months but haven’t been able to make it out that way due to work. Today, 11/02/24 I was going to have time, if the storm didn’t force them to close, until I stumbled across a review and the owners response. Yikes- that was enough for me. I had never tried this location either and disappointed in your response to a paying customer’s review. And the way the food looked he had a right to leave a negative review.

Molly LaRive

The guys where sweet and Patient and was great at conversation ??????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Regular Coney

Gene-Garrett Sears

Went in today with my father and they aren't allowed to give law enforcement discounts he is a veteran too and they don't do that either I guess the employees widh they were allowed but they were told they can't so food is wonderful but not the price wr have to pay for dinner it gets high for us

Sorry but I strongly disagree with not allowing the discounts for veterans an law enforcement emergency this is my opinion I know others agree I also know others don't but that's fine with me I just disagree with that one choice other then that food is great employees are nice service is wonderful and dine in is actually recommended also the owner is said to have done this choice management is not bad but the one I hope reads this is the one that stopped it if it wasn't for everything else being great I I'd gave 1 star but yeah one star for yeah and the other two are for food and employees
Thank you for reading this and have a Blessed life!!!!!!! Take care safe travels and have Fun!!!

Parking: Not sure on disability slots can't really remember but I do know plenty parking choices at most times

Kid-friendliness: In my opinion best spot for a good life long memory!!! I met a lady said she been coming since she was 11 and now she's well up in the age group I would never say nothing bad about age so I mean it in a good way have fun!!! Making memories!!!!!!!

Wheelchair accessibility: I strongly believe it had good accessibility might be off on that don't take it to heart for this one

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: 2 Chili Cheese Coney Dog and Small Frito Pie, Regular Coney, Pint of Chili, Fritos

Loading...