Mazzio's Italian Eatery

1200 E Kenosha St, Broken Arrow
(918) 664-4444

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Karla

Sally was such a sweetheart taking our order over the phone. She took her time and didn't mind our baby crying in the background and told us that she used to actually Rock babies at the church nursery and it absolutely warmed my heart. I would definitely order from this place again 🫶

John Smith

45 minute wait for a drive thru order is bad business and management when we have a lot of other pizza place options in the area.

Jarrod Nicholson

We ordered on the app and it’s coming from this store and it’s been over an hour and a half and still don’t have any food. This has been the second time this has happened. Says it’s out for delivery over 40 min ago and still no food. Won’t be ordering from here anymore. Order food at 7:30pm to hope to eat by 8:30 and now it’s almost 9:30.

Sandra l Lancaster

Salad bar not clean and filled pizza for buffet not ready

Dana H

Dirty silverware, counter around buffet needed to be cleaned and restroom floor needed a good cleaning. Food however was very good, fresh and stocked. Simple attention to cleaning would get full points.

Phyllis Ekwempu

Best pizza place experience I have had in a while! I came in to pick up and was heartbroken to find out that I ordered from wrong location. Instead of having to cancel that order or even drive 20+ minutes, the employee helping me got another person (assume a manager) and immediately figured it out on their end. They even gave me a drink as I waited. This is great customer service and I will be a returning customer because of it!

Josh White

Waited 2hours and 15 mins for my delivery. I spent 17 mins on hold to be told well sir we have 2hrs and 12 mins before you can say we are late, so nothing we can do for you. How about saying your order will be 2hrs and 12 mins to deliver and not 60 mins like my email says. Horrible service for the high prices you pay. Not worth the money

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Jonathan Fisher

Love the food, especially the best ranch in the world. Pickup service was and always is slow. Currently, I've been waiting for 35 minutes after the website said my one single topping pizza would be ready.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Pepperoni Pizza

Amber Knecht

The last 2 times I have gone to this location the service and quality have been terrible. We started off the night waiting for someone to take our order. We were given dirty plates that had baked on grease all over the backs. I went to get silverware, something white had been splattered all over the silverware. I had to pick through them to find a moderately clean fork.

This place lacks proper management, especially during their buffet hours. I sat there for over an hour watching their staff on cellphones, laughing and playing around in the back while a lobby full of people waited for someone to stock the salad bar and to put pizza out. They brought out dessert pizza that was half cooked and half of it had raw pizza dough. I watched multiple times the staff walk by the empty salad bar without even thinking to restock it. I spoke to the manager (lady with short hair) and she just smirked when I told her they were serving people raw food. I also brought it to her attention that a lobby full of people were waiting for them to restock the pizza and salad bar, yet their pizza guy was back there playing on his cellphone, 4-5 of them were back there horsing around, and the waitress was just mindlessly walking around in circles not really doing anything productive. The manager said they were doing the best they could with what they had. What they had was plenty of staff with no oversight or direction coming from a lazy manager. Your buffet times are not a surprise and your staff should know their roles and make sure people are able to eat without the risk of food poisoning. You had plenty of staff tonight so there was no excuse for this. Do better Mazzios!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Willella Hammons

the trifecta is a great deal, we made a lot of meals out of it for $20

Food: 5

Ryan Williams

A classic. Always what you expect.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Fettuccine Alfredo Pizza Hand-Tossed Original Crust, Pepperoni Pizza

Kelley

They continually overcook our pizza and cheese dippers. They also keep forgetting to give us the extra sauces we order/pay for.

Food: 3

Service: 3

Michael Bolton

I saw

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Bergeron

My family and I love Mazzios, Yeah we eat at other pizza places but we go back because we enjoy the food, There Ranch…Soooo good. I particularly like the ham, cheese and bacon Calzone, my wife likes the thin crust, Sausage and mushroom on Ken’s Spicy sauce.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Calzone

Colleen Curtis

Good lunch buffet. Nice variety of pizza and salad bar.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Cheese Sticks, Pepperoni Pizza, Taco Pizza

Loading...