Papa Johns Pizza

904 N Elm Pl, Broken Arrow
(918) 258-7272

Recent Reviews

Catherine Ramsey

#pizza was good!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Extra Cheese Pizza, Italian Sausage Pizza

Aaron Fox

This was supposed to half and half. Some pieces where half the pizza some where one bite, while some pieces were cut in two across the middle. The Oreo dessert we ordered was dry, hard, and inedible. The Roni bites looked nothing like what was advertised and the Kraft cheese stick they make them with wasn’t even melted. Papa John’s used to quality pizza not sure what happened but won’t be ordering again.

Food: 1

drummerspice

Greeted immediately by Cheyenne, customer service was great and so was the food!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 6 Cheese Cheesesticks, Pepperoni Pizza, Large Pizza, Garlic Knot

Donna DeVore

Their new crust is the bomb!

Giuliaa Pinamonti

I ordered my food online. I told them so many times my food is ready. I told my name how it spell like. One staffs act like can’t find my order when right there front of him and pick up section. Two staffs act like a pretend heard me. I need say it loud and clear. I show my phone about order. After I picked up. One staff pointed finger at me and called me Stupid. Learn manners talk to consumers like that. I don’t care loud in the back and don’t have scream at them to tell so many times it is ready for pick up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Mileena McFarland

Do NOT go to this one they suck and employees are very

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Breadstick, Large Pizza

nancy Lee

Amazing service! I will use them again. They offered me plates for the birthday party I was having at work. Gave me lots of parmesan and red pepper flakes, too. Birthday girl wanted the Hawaiian, and she loved it. Thank

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kerri Montgomery

I placed an order for 65.01 for 3 pizzas and a dessert and put that I would pay cash when I got there so I got there went in to pay and pick up my order and was told they don’t take 100 dollar bills but my order was 65.01 so I asked if I could talk to the manager and he said no they’re not in so I said well I guess then I can’t pay for my order, they said ok and walked off. This happened to my daughter at the 101st st location a year ago & they told her to leave and go get change at the liquor store next door and come back and she said uh you don’t have any cash they told her that they hadn’t gone to the bank that day. Both of the papa John’s have horrible service and the employees don’t care about you or your business. I also placed an order for delivery a few weeks ago and the msn that answered the phone said he didn’t know where are pizzas were and that they were gone but couldn’t figure out where the driver was that she might have gotten lost and then said he wasn’t sure if the order was even placed then hung up on me. So no more Papa John’s ever. Done.✔️ I complained to corporate.Kid-friendliness: Not friendly at all lol.?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Large Pizza

Vickie Dunlap

Ordered 4 medium pizzas one order of cheesy breadsticks and an order of brownies... The brownies and the breadsticks were fantastic... The pizzas were horrible!!! Crust was very tough...bare minimum toppings, you get more toppings on a frozen Red Baron pizza...$50 bucks for food not fit to eat! FYI pizzas look absolutely nothing like the picture!!

Food: 2

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brownie, Breadstick

Jesse RodrigueZ

Ive always been pleased with my pizzas from this location. Keep it up

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Aimee Robins

Their answering service is so annoying... it's frustrating.

Geri Watson

The worst pizza I've had in a long time very little toppings on the works. To much chewy

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Large Pizza

sabri husibi

One of my favorite pizza places. ? good pizza good service quick always on time

danielfP2687GA

Bad pizza and very dishonest! There was a problem with the order and they promised next time I would get free pizza. NOT! they would not honor their word. Papa John's is not a reputable company anymore.

Rhiana Sheely

Ordered the new garlic pizza not a bit of garlic anywhere on it!!! Frustrating?

Food: 1

Load More