Potbelly's Pub & Grill

3724 S Elm Pl, Broken Arrow
(918) 455-7682

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Darren Lerch

Man if you're wanting a really good hamburger highly recommend the black and blue

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimmie M.

I go more but it's way too smoky! It's 2025. I don't need or want to second hand smoke. Everything else is great! Bartenders are awesome!

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 5

Ricardo Pacheco

Great food and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

timothy blair

Bacon cheese burger was amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracy hall

Love it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natasha Meyer

This is where it's at.... such an amazing time with great food, friendly helpful staff, absolutely no complaints. Most definitely will return and recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Josh Wallace

the food is so dang good. the only thing g that sucks is the kitchen closing at the 10 lol

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

K9588NZrachelw

Casey ran circles around everyone. She is the best bartender at potbellys! She is kind, attentive, efficient and makes sure all tables are taken care of seemingly by herself. She is a joy to interact with and makes going to the bar a place to feel personally important. She is why we go on atuesdays for tacos.

Fred Smith

This place was a ton of fun. We have a fun place like this back in Oakdale, called H-B. Potbelly's has an atmosphere that gives you that warm and welcome feeling. It makes you want to forget about time and just enjoy good company and conversation. I will definitely go back next time I'm in the area. They have an old-school Iron Maiden pinball machine and a pool table. I highly recommend this place.

David Boley

The food was delicious, and beer was ice cold.

Beau Brown

Not as fun as it used to be back in the day. Daytime waitstaff looks a little rough. But the food is really good for bar food.

Peter Tamura

It was a Monday and a poker game going on and 75 cent wings. The bartenders were very welcoming to strangers (us) and encouraged us to try wings with all the different flavors. It was smoky but otherwise we had a fun time!

Brandon Game

Loved the staff, the bartenders were awesome

Dawn Osborne

First off, I need to say I have no idea how this place stays open with its price point. This was an absolutely shocking experience. I got the chicken nachos for $3.50. I'm not lying when I say these were the best nachos I have ever had. He got the Pat's Burger and fries for around $10.00 and the beer was 22 oz for $2.00. We went on a Sunday. The atmosphere is of a dive bar, no problem with that. I like it grungy or first class. The smoke was the only reason I gave the atmosphere a little lower. Just a personal preference. It will not keep me from going back. Kudos to the owners and the price point! 👏 to the kitchen crew and waitress staff.

Valecia Grube

Don't waste your time. This place is ghetto. The waitresses suck. They are rude. They add to your ticket things you didn't even order. The food is horrible. Went to Taco Tuesday every week for a month. Service was bad every time. We are a party of 10 that never will be returning to this establishment.

Loading...