Tobies Pizzeria
2424 W New Orleans St, Broken Arrow
(918) 994-7733
Customers' Favorites
Hokey Pokey Hoagie Sub
Fettuccine Alfredo
Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Fries
American Pie
BYO Pizza
Meatballs
Menu
Photos
+8 photos
+7 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
All of their food is amazing. My personal favorite would be the fried mushrooms. They are so tender and juicy. I don’t know what they do different than every where else I’ve tried mushrooms at, but these stand above the crowd. It is a must try!
Tonight my daughter and I ate at this restaurant for the very first time. It was amazing. It was the best Italian bread with oil I have eaten anywhere including any of the fancy places around Broken Arrow or Tulsa. The food was great. The atmosphere was amazing. Our little waitress was very sweet. Oh and of course Toby the dog was one of our favorite parts. The owner came to talk to us and it was such an awesome conversation. I will go back again!
You May Also Like
Whiskey Dog Bar & Grill - 2408 W New Orleans St
![]()
Bar, Sports Bar, American
7 Brew Coffee - 1104 W New Orleans St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Pet Friendly, Coffee
I convinced my better half that we should try Tobies instead of our uncles place.
So we strolled over and we're taken by surprise.
1. You seat yourself.
2. It was game night.
3. How warm the staff was.
It was like a home away from home. Great vibes, freshly made food, and great options from the menu.
We didn't dive in like we normally do, but from the fresh loaf...