Amish Store
$ • Bakery
Hours:
901 Service Rd, Calera
(580) 889-3111
About Amish Store
Amish Store Reviews
Share your opinion about Amish Store
We were in town for a concert and decided to stop in since it’s next to our hotel. We were greeted with a variety of Amish goods, cheeses, canned food, and much more. We had a great conversation with the owner and were told of some more local things to do and see. Would definitely recommend!!!
Love the Calera Amish Store everything is fresh. If they don’t have it, they will get it to you soon. Went in for a Happy Birthday Big Chocolate Chip Cookie, for my Grandson within two hours, I picked it up. Everyone loved it, so fresh and was delicious!!💙
This is by far my favorite store! I love stopping in to buy a sandwich for lunch along with snagging a treat sometimes to satisfy my sweet tooth. They provide such a welcoming atmosphere, the jellies/jams are amazing with a piece of toast. I also highly recommend the cheese, I’ve yet to find something I didn’t like. Make sure to stop by, it’ll become your favorite too!
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 5:30PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 5:30PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 5:30PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 6PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
The Amish Store is a cozy, quaint village shop known for its excellent sandwiches and desserts. Popular choices include Cajun turkey, Chicken Salad, and turkey on jalapeno bread, while kids love the club sandwich. The cinnamon rolls are praised as the best in Oklahoma, and the strawberry pies are a must-try. The store offers an array of groceries, including jams, cheeses, fudge, chocolate, and nuts. Friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere make it a delightful stop. Customers enjoy the fresh, high-quality food and appreciate the helpful staff who often get items they don’t have in stock quickly. The store is a favorite place to buy a sandwich for lunch or a treat to satisfy a sweet tooth, with many praising the jalapeño bread, habanero cheddar, smoked turkey, and garlic mayo sandwich as one of the best ever. Visitors also love the apple butter, jalapeño bread, and butter pickles, making it a beloved spot in the little town.