Nice people! The best pizza I've had. Tastes as good as it smells. Not covered in overpowering pizza sauce. The only place we're buying pizza anymore.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme, House Salad
ActuallyWhatIMeant
The two star review shows that they actually did take care of him very well and that they lost money over his disgruntled personality. So I’m giving them five stars bc they deserve better. Very hard working family and a joy. Wherever this family goes, they bless the community.
Gabriella Nimsey
Love it the workers are amazing and got us seated fast. And got our food in a very good time. The workers were so kind to let us stay after closing time. And they were very kind to eachother and were very energetic.the food was 5 star and the cheese bread is amazing and was fresh. Eaten here a few times and has never failed to be good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza 10
Justin Chetelat
Don't waste your money at Ben & Jay's Pizzeria.We were greeted by the hostess and then left at the front. A server saw us, greeted us, and seated us only to have the hostess return and seat us in a diffrrent location.We ordered a 12" pizza with Brisket, jalapeno, and marinara sauce, and homemade pizza rolls with a jalapeno ranch dipping sauce. The pizza was delivered to out table as their BBQ Brisket specialty (BBQ sauce, not marinara, Brisket, and onion) with added jalapenos. And the pizza rolls were delivered with marinara sauce instead of jalapeno ranch. I pointed out the errors and the incorrect pizza was removed and replaced 15 minutes later. The hostess returned with regular ranch, not jalapeno ranch.The pizza rolls, though not what I expected, were very good. I never got to try the jalapeno ranch sauce.The pizza was okay. The crust while firm and crispy, was bland and heavy. It tasted like they might use a flour that is at least partially whole wheat. It probably would be better as 100% whole wheat. But it was not as light and fluffy as most pizza crust. The other ingredients were very good individually, but the pizza as a whole was only average.We were offered a free dessert at the end of the meal because of all the errors and confusion, but we weren't in the mood. Ultimately, I received my standard military discount for my service in the Marine Corps. But no other attempt to win our approval or return business. I would recommend against Ben & Jay's Pizzeria. It is very expensive for the the very average pizza they provide. The pizza rolls were good, but not good enough to overcome the disorganized staff and average pizza. Our meal cost me just north of $26 after tip. I could have gotten far better for cheaper at a dozen other locations. Don't waste your money at Ben & Jay's Pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Cecilia Walthall
Came today, found out it was their Grand Opening. I ordered a calzone, my husband ordered Spaghetti with meatballs. Both service and food were awesome! Will be coming back.
Shawn C.
Good food, excellent salads. Breadsticks with cheese is probably the best I've ever had.
Vickie Hilton Hale
I called in an order first time eating here and won't be the last. Best pizza and Calzone in town! we'll done we loved it!
Sandra W.
Delicious Pizza! Hot and generous toppings, The service is fast and friendly. Favorite place to get pizza.
Rusty S.
This place used to be awesome, but not only was the last pizza we got basically raw! It also was not what we ordered , had waaaay to much butter garlic , and the jerks didn't even bother to cut it, and we didn't have anything at work to cut it with. Shame such a great pizza joint went downhill so fast.. PS PIZZA TOPPINGS DO NOT BELONG UNDER THE CHEESE!!! Part of the reason the onion and peppers were completely raw! Places have started doing this trying to skimp on toppings without anyone noticing... i personally don't like a ton of toppings, and nobody likes it Under the cheese, especially stuff that puts off a lot of grease and soaks into the dough!! WHAT HAPPENED TO THIS PLACE???
Steven H.
This is actually some good pizza I tell ya what! I've had some decent pies come out that amazes me and the prices are fair so they are very affordable. Their tv needs to be replaced it's basically just blue and purple lol.
This location has been sold to a new owner. I ordered the same thing I always ordered. This pizza looked like a Totino's party pizza but not as good. I hope the new owner gets the old one to teach him how to make a pizza. This makes me sad as this used to be the best pizza ever.
Steph B.
Great price for a lot of food. Buffalo Wings could have been crispier, but the pizza and cheese sticks were good.
Nice people! The best pizza I've had. Tastes as good as it smells. Not covered in overpowering pizza sauce. The only place we're buying pizza anymore.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme, House Salad
The two star review shows that they actually did take care of him very well and that they lost money over his disgruntled personality. So I’m giving them five stars bc they deserve better. Very hard working family and a joy. Wherever this family goes, they bless the community.
Love it the workers are amazing and got us seated fast. And got our food in a very good time. The workers were so kind to let us stay after closing time. And they were very kind to eachother and were very energetic.the food was 5 star and the cheese bread is amazing and was fresh. Eaten here a few times and has never failed to be good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza 10
Don't waste your money at Ben & Jay's Pizzeria.We were greeted by the hostess and then left at the front. A server saw us, greeted us, and seated us only to have the hostess return and seat us in a diffrrent location.We ordered a 12" pizza with Brisket, jalapeno, and marinara sauce, and homemade pizza rolls with a jalapeno ranch dipping sauce. The pizza was delivered to out table as their BBQ Brisket specialty (BBQ sauce, not marinara, Brisket, and onion) with added jalapenos. And the pizza rolls were delivered with marinara sauce instead of jalapeno ranch. I pointed out the errors and the incorrect pizza was removed and replaced 15 minutes later. The hostess returned with regular ranch, not jalapeno ranch.The pizza rolls, though not what I expected, were very good. I never got to try the jalapeno ranch sauce.The pizza was okay. The crust while firm and crispy, was bland and heavy. It tasted like they might use a flour that is at least partially whole wheat. It probably would be better as 100% whole wheat. But it was not as light and fluffy as most pizza crust. The other ingredients were very good individually, but the pizza as a whole was only average.We were offered a free dessert at the end of the meal because of all the errors and confusion, but we weren't in the mood. Ultimately, I received my standard military discount for my service in the Marine Corps. But no other attempt to win our approval or return business. I would recommend against Ben & Jay's Pizzeria. It is very expensive for the the very average pizza they provide. The pizza rolls were good, but not good enough to overcome the disorganized staff and average pizza. Our meal cost me just north of $26 after tip. I could have gotten far better for cheaper at a dozen other locations. Don't waste your money at Ben & Jay's Pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Came today, found out it was their Grand Opening. I ordered a calzone, my husband ordered Spaghetti with meatballs. Both service and food were awesome! Will be coming back.
Good food, excellent salads. Breadsticks with cheese is probably the best I've ever had.
I called in an order first time eating here and won't be the last. Best pizza and Calzone in town! we'll done we loved it!
Delicious Pizza! Hot and generous toppings, The service is fast and friendly. Favorite place to get pizza.
This place used to be awesome, but not only was the last pizza we got basically raw! It also was not what we ordered , had waaaay to much butter garlic , and the jerks didn't even bother to cut it, and we didn't have anything at work to cut it with. Shame such a great pizza joint went downhill so fast.. PS PIZZA TOPPINGS DO NOT BELONG UNDER THE CHEESE!!! Part of the reason the onion and peppers were completely raw! Places have started doing this trying to skimp on toppings without anyone noticing... i personally don't like a ton of toppings, and nobody likes it Under the cheese, especially stuff that puts off a lot of grease and soaks into the dough!! WHAT HAPPENED TO THIS PLACE???
This is actually some good pizza I tell ya what! I've had some decent pies come out that amazes me and the prices are fair so they are very affordable. Their tv needs to be replaced it's basically just blue and purple lol.
Restaurantji Recommends
This location has been sold to a new owner. I ordered the same thing I always ordered. This pizza looked like a Totino's party pizza but not as good. I hope the new owner gets the old one to teach him how to make a pizza. This makes me sad as this used to be the best pizza ever.
Great price for a lot of food. Buffalo Wings could have been crispier, but the pizza and cheese sticks were good.