Owner/Operator Eddie believes the only way to do BBQ is the right way! He goes above and beyond for his customers. Normally, I recommend a specific meal, but at this location it is all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Baked Potato w Chopped Brisket, Smoked Turkey, Pull Pork Mac and Cheese Bowl, Pulled Pork Sandwich Baked Beans, Half Rack of Ribs, Smoked Chopped Brisket Sandwich, Coleslaw, Potato Salad, The Heisman, Smoked Polish Dinner, Shredded Pork, Barbecue Ribs with Potato Salad and Baked Beans with Toast and a Sweet Tea, Full Rack Platter, Smoked Sliced Brisket, Tailgater Pack
Kimberly Furrh
The gals behind the counter were so friendly. I feel valued as a customer. Of course, the brisket was "melt in my mouth" tender. Of all the stores in SW OK, this is my go to spot for BBQ.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coleslaw, Baked Potato Salad
Hannah
We went back. Thankfully it was better. We got brisket and a potato. The only issue was there's not enough meat on the potato.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ellwood Robinson
Ribs were Several days old everything else was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Mary Vandiest
Order was with door dash delivery. Unfortunately, Billy Sims did not provide napkins nor silverware.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Phillip N
Had a to go order today. Everything turned out excellent, I would suggest trying all of the BBQ sauces to find that perfect combination. 5 stars for this veteran owned store in Elgin.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Smogonovich
We've been to a few Billy Sims restaurants before, but none of them had the "down home" feel that we got from this one. Had a great experience and the food was amazing. Thank you for the hospitality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Baked Potato w Chopped Brisket, Smoked Turkey, Half Rack of Ribs, Shredded Pork, Smoked Pulled Pork
Stephen Gardner
Kids working there are exceptional. Thank you for bringing back pickles & peppers!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich, Half Rack of Ribs, Coleslaw, The Heisman, Smoked Sliced Brisket
Robert Roshell
Billy Sims BBQ catered my grandson’s wedding. Christy did an excellent job taking care of ensuring we had great food and plenty for our event. She was easy to work with and went out of her way to meet our needs. The amount of food for our 80 guests was enough for seconds and thirds. Never ran out of sides or meats. It was hot and set up nicely for us. I highly recommend Billy Sims for your catering needs.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori H.
Horrible, even with new owner/management, all the young girls and boys can't get anything rite, they don't listen, one girl kept rolling her eyes, even after telling them 3 times a very simple thing they still messed up, baked potatoes were not done as well, the one in Lawton on Gore is much better if you really wanna have Billy sims
Just had lunch take out. 2 meat combo, and a loaded chopped brisket baked potato. The chopped brisket and polish sausage was great.They have absolutely gotten better from a year ago. The dining area was clean, the prep area was clean. The staff was friendly, professional and helpful.If you stayed away because of the bad experience before the new owners, give them a try, you’ll enjoy the new experience.
Picked up 3 HARD as a brick, undercooked baked potatoes for dinner. They weren't even cut open, the toppings were placed on the top of the potatoes and melted off into the to go box. I keep making the mistake of giving this place chance after chance becuase supposedly its under new management. Never get my ranch, pickles or onions either.
Kimberly Duran
I will never go back to this location again. The air didn't work, the service was so slow, especially with 5+ people on the line, no brisket, burnt corn and food was cold. The biggest pet piev i have is when workers at a restaurant say, "we didnt expect to be busy or noone showed up". As a customer, you dont want to hear the problem and at 5pm, dinner time, brisket should be readily available. Worst experience at a Billy Sims ever!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Maria Z.
We had just relocated from Houston and we could not believe that this place served the best pork ribs I had ever tasted! It's self service and the place is small for dining in; some customers prefer to take out!
Jesse M.
DON'T ORDER FROM HERE!!! Horrible takeout experience. We ordered online which clearly provides the order to the cooks. Two salads with no onion and regular ranch and a side of turkey. Picked up the order and had to ask for the barbecue sauce for the turkey. Going out the door I only saw two boxes. Did you folks include the side of turkey? Yes we did sir. Got home, no side of turkey, onions in the salad, bque ranch, and the wrong salad with extra cheese. I called the manager to complain. Oh, turkey wasn't listed on the order but I was changed on the receipt and it's on the online order. Refund? Sure...I think I can do it or you can come down and pickup the turkey. If not, I'll have to go through a third party. Then as she's trying to process the missing turkey refund, I check the sliced brisket. It looks chopped. She says the brisket is overcooked and falls apart. Then why serve it? Chicken and brisket were bone dry. I told her to disregard the refund as they lost a customer. Omg...can they even read a clear online order? Just annoying. Again, don't go here folks!!!
Owner/Operator Eddie believes the only way to do BBQ is the right way! He goes above and beyond for his customers. Normally, I recommend a specific meal, but at this location it is all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Baked Potato w Chopped Brisket, Smoked Turkey, Pull Pork Mac and Cheese Bowl, Pulled Pork Sandwich Baked Beans, Half Rack of Ribs, Smoked Chopped Brisket Sandwich, Coleslaw, Potato Salad, The Heisman, Smoked Polish Dinner, Shredded Pork, Barbecue Ribs with Potato Salad and Baked Beans with Toast and a Sweet Tea, Full Rack Platter, Smoked Sliced Brisket, Tailgater Pack
The gals behind the counter were so friendly. I feel valued as a customer. Of course, the brisket was "melt in my mouth" tender. Of all the stores in SW OK, this is my go to spot for BBQ.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coleslaw, Baked Potato Salad
We went back. Thankfully it was better. We got brisket and a potato. The only issue was there's not enough meat on the potato.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ribs were Several days old everything else was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Order was with door dash delivery. Unfortunately, Billy Sims did not provide napkins nor silverware.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Had a to go order today. Everything turned out excellent, I would suggest trying all of the BBQ sauces to find that perfect combination. 5 stars for this veteran owned store in Elgin.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've been to a few Billy Sims restaurants before, but none of them had the "down home" feel that we got from this one. Had a great experience and the food was amazing. Thank you for the hospitality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Baked Potato w Chopped Brisket, Smoked Turkey, Half Rack of Ribs, Shredded Pork, Smoked Pulled Pork
Kids working there are exceptional. Thank you for bringing back pickles & peppers!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich, Half Rack of Ribs, Coleslaw, The Heisman, Smoked Sliced Brisket
Billy Sims BBQ catered my grandson’s wedding. Christy did an excellent job taking care of ensuring we had great food and plenty for our event. She was easy to work with and went out of her way to meet our needs. The amount of food for our 80 guests was enough for seconds and thirds. Never ran out of sides or meats. It was hot and set up nicely for us. I highly recommend Billy Sims for your catering needs.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible, even with new owner/management, all the young girls and boys can't get anything rite, they don't listen, one girl kept rolling her eyes, even after telling them 3 times a very simple thing they still messed up, baked potatoes were not done as well, the one in Lawton on Gore is much better if you really wanna have Billy sims
Restaurantji Recommends
Just had lunch take out. 2 meat combo, and a loaded chopped brisket baked potato. The chopped brisket and polish sausage was great.They have absolutely gotten better from a year ago. The dining area was clean, the prep area was clean. The staff was friendly, professional and helpful.If you stayed away because of the bad experience before the new owners, give them a try, you’ll enjoy the new experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Baked Potato w Chopped Brisket, Baked Potato Salad, Smoked Polish Dinner
Picked up 3 HARD as a brick, undercooked baked potatoes for dinner. They weren't even cut open, the toppings were placed on the top of the potatoes and melted off into the to go box. I keep making the mistake of giving this place chance after chance becuase supposedly its under new management. Never get my ranch, pickles or onions either.
I will never go back to this location again. The air didn't work, the service was so slow, especially with 5+ people on the line, no brisket, burnt corn and food was cold. The biggest pet piev i have is when workers at a restaurant say, "we didnt expect to be busy or noone showed up". As a customer, you dont want to hear the problem and at 5pm, dinner time, brisket should be readily available. Worst experience at a Billy Sims ever!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
We had just relocated from Houston and we could not believe that this place served the best pork ribs I had ever tasted! It's self service and the place is small for dining in; some customers prefer to take out!
DON'T ORDER FROM HERE!!! Horrible takeout experience. We ordered online which clearly provides the order to the cooks. Two salads with no onion and regular ranch and a side of turkey. Picked up the order and had to ask for the barbecue sauce for the turkey. Going out the door I only saw two boxes. Did you folks include the side of turkey? Yes we did sir. Got home, no side of turkey, onions in the salad, bque ranch, and the wrong salad with extra cheese. I called the manager to complain. Oh, turkey wasn't listed on the order but I was changed on the receipt and it's on the online order. Refund? Sure...I think I can do it or you can come down and pickup the turkey. If not, I'll have to go through a third party. Then as she's trying to process the missing turkey refund, I check the sliced brisket. It looks chopped. She says the brisket is overcooked and falls apart. Then why serve it? Chicken and brisket were bone dry. I told her to disregard the refund as they lost a customer. Omg...can they even read a clear online order? Just annoying. Again, don't go here folks!!!