The blue Belle pizza parlor & saloon

My husband had never been there so we went for some pizza after the Renaissance Festival. He had a Doc Holiday & I had the Calamity Jane, which were both awesome! It was disappointing we couldn't get a beer but we don't fault them for it. Just know before you go. The staff is super friendly & it's really clean! The history is not to be forgotten and makes the visit even better. It was such a nice visit.

Vegetarian options: They have a really cool variety!

We had been wanting to try this place and finally had the chance.We ordered the Poncho Villa and it was fabulous! They have a cute little salad bar that’s all you can eat. The interior is marvelously maintained and still has plenty of original woodwork and stained glass.I hope this local business flourishes!

Loved the pizza... Aydan knows exactly how to make a great pie... the service sucked and the tension in there could be cut with a knife. That's bad for business.the owner doesn't need to be wandering around with a ladder in front of customers. Do that before you open or after hours.It should never take a waitress 15 minutes to acknowledge a customer when there's only 2 tables with people sitting at them. Once she finally put our order in, then we had our pizza in about 10 minutes..and that's great.The salad bar wS very clean and tidy, however... it needs more choices.

It was a quite a bit of a wait for the pizza. But we were able to get a half one kind and half another. Wild bunch and Wyatt Earp. Delicious crust. A bit skimpy on hamburger. Not sure why we were charged for it since we simply asked to sub it not have sausages. Owner was nice to us and we will consider coming back. Love the decor. Our photo show two Wyatt Earp and one wild bunch piece.

We were excited to try the pizza and came in for the first time. They were slightly busy so we tried to be patient, but after we were seated we sat for close to 30 minutes and the waitress never came to our table. Not even for out drinks. She could see o had two hungry girls getting hungry and antsy, but she just ignored us. Then we saw her waiting in table that came in after us. After that we ended up walking out and leaving. I really wanted to like it, we live in town and are always looking for a good place to eat. They lost a potential long term customer.

Miss Jackie and her son strive to take great care of their customers. The old timey feel is really neat. Oh and let’s not forget about the pizza and the garlic knots!! Absolutely delicious!! To top it all off they have the best Pepsi in 9 counties. My 9 year old son had his birthday back in December and last night we had our 6 year old sons birthday because he wanted to be like his big brother. Miss Jackie made both birthdays very special. Please check out Blue Bell Pizza in Guthrie.

Pizza and wings were amazing! We ordered to go and while sitting there waiting for our order the staff checked on us multiple times even though we didn't wait long. I like the fact the place is family owned, everyone was friendly and had a smile, I definitely recommend giving it a try, love the pizza sauce too!

Really enjoyed our lunch at the Blue Belle Pizza Parlor. The staff were very friendly and the pizza was great....

The pizza was delicious and staff very personable. Felt like a close-knit, family establishment. Wings were an afterthought. The building and its historical nuances left intact were the stunning. I'm excited to see what they do with the bar. It's an awesome opportunity (and piece of real estate) to pay homage to the old saloon and downtown Guthrie.

i rate this place purely for ambiance. this place is supposedly haunted. it looks like a western saloon. there are interesting elements to this locale. the pizza is definitely homemade. it was not to my liking due to the fact that the crust wasnt strong enough to hold up the cheese; this required eating with a fork on a plate. the ambiance here is one of a kind however and definitely worth the experience. one medium calamity jane and two sodas was $26. the price is on the steeper end.

Probably the best pizza I've ever had. The night we were there they were short staffed so we had to wait a fairly long while but it was well worth the wait. The crust was excellent slightly buttery and a touch of garlic. The sauce was flavorful and it was loaded with toppings. If I didn't live three and a half hours away I would definitely be a regular.

Fresh pizza and garlic knots made to order. Both were very good as was service

This is a hidden treasure. It has a wonderful selection of recipes as well as build your own. The recipes we ordered were delicious and my little one's cheese was done to perfection. We will definitely be returning.

Went for lunch, carry out. Been to this location over the years for a variety of venues, restaurants, etc. got a small calamity Jane and a Dr Pepper which cost $10 plus tax. Not bad, good flavor but I will order extra toppings next time. I will go back to try something else.

Great place for a pizza for sure, employees are great, an so far We’ve got the sitting bull , Wyatt Earp, an the normal half pepperoni an cheese, for the kids. o ya an the cheesy bread was ??.Can’t wait till they get beer will be one of the best pizza places in the town of Guthrie. Witch is good for us not having to travel so far . An prices are reasonable