Mazzio's Italian Eatery

Name: Mazzio's Italian Eatery
Address: 911 S Mill St, Pryor, Oklahoma, 74361, US
Telephone: (918) 825-0090
Price range: $
Rating: 2.9

$ • Italian, Pizza

Hours:
911 S Mill St, Pryor
(918) 825-0090

Menu Order Online

About Mazzio's

Mazzio's Italian Eatery provides a casual dining experience with an emphasis on pizza and Italian dishes. The restaurant's lunch buffet is seen as a good deal for the price, with a salad bar offering everything one could want. However, some customers have mentioned that the pizza hasn't always tasted fresh lately, as it seems pizzas are replaced when they run out rather than being checked for freshness, which can impact quality. The staff generally appear friendly, but service can be slow, particularly when the restaurant is not busy. Customers have reported delays between ordering and receiving items like wings, with some waiting longer than expected, even during quiet times. The food has received mixed reviews; while some enjoyed the thin crust pepperoni and jalapeno pizza, others felt the wings could be better, with flavors that didn’t appeal to everyone. The manager has been noted for accommodating preferences, making the pizza enjoyable. Despite some issues, the restaurant remains kid-friendly, offering a kids buffet, highchairs, crayons, and coloring sheets. However, there are concerns about the medium size pizza being small and the pricing on the menu not being clear. The restaurant’s performance varies across locations, with the Pryor, Oklahoma location facing more criticism, especially regarding cleanliness and food freshness.