Pueblo Viejo

5201 S Mill St, Pryor
(918) 373-8111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jeffrey Barnes

Camera light kept flashing on and off in my face. It was very bright. Margaritas were good. Food and service was mid

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

Norah Brakebill

Food was good

Brian Cross

This is one of our regular places to go.. great staff and good

Norman Jett

It's been a while since we were there, early January 2025. We are from out of town and didn't get done at a business down the road until most everything was closed. We got gas a Murphy gas station and figured we'd give this place a shot. Bad idea! My GF ended up with food poisoning and was sick as a dog. While we won't likely go there again simply due to where we actually live but I would definitely be VERY careful eating here.

Spike Speedwell

A solid authentic Mexican restaurant.

The food is good enough, that I would recommend the restaurant to a friend. Clean comfortable attractive interior. Very good service. Large menu. The salsas are decent; order the salsa picante. The Guacamole was delicious, but likely factory made. For me a relleno and a taco. The taco shell was a little over toasted. A minor complaint. My wife had a simple steak burrito, packed end to end with tender flavorful steak. No significant criticisms of either meal.

Of the Mexican restaurants I have tried in Pryor, Pueblo Viejo is at the top of my list.
Give Pueblo Viejo a try.

noe reyes

Wow!
Blown away by this hidden gem!
Pueblo Viejo has the best flavor in Pryor and its surroundings. Made an order by phone and everything was excellent and delicious.
I really enjoyed the Tilapia a la Diabla, cooked to perfection with a side of salad and great rice.
Keep up the good work.
Will come back and try more food for sure.

cassie horvath

Great food attentive service nice atmosphere! Wish we lived closer to try more menu items!

Cindy “Elite distaste 14” Thompson

I went for the margaritas lol but ended up ordering a delicious lunch, highly recommended for both food and drinks.

Angie Sawyer

Delicious

Andreanna Ward

Amazing food, service, and our waitress is amazing ♡

Baylee Bluejacket

Everything here is so delicious. I highly recommend the chile relleno, seafood soup, and the chimichangas

Garet Wyatt

Efrain was our server. He was very attentive and polite.

Melissa Purcell

Love this place 😋

Ashlee Munson

Fast service, great food, friendly staff. Real authentic Mexican food. Thank you Pueblo Viejo!!

Kristy Hansen

We used to like the food here, but it has gone downhill. Ordered fish tacos. Just plain fish on them. Nothing else. Supposed to have sauce and cabbage on them at least. About a tablespoon of fish on each. Tasted very bad fishy. But the thing that really grossed us out was the roach that was climbing up the wall right next to us. Nope never going there again!!!!

Loading...