Excellent food choices on their buffet. The staff and ownership are very accommodating and helpful. The delivery service is efficient and attitude of driver is cheerful.
Jenny Honeycutt
The staff is super friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Service is quick and attentive. And the food? So good! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Definitely coming back—highly recommend! Can’t forget the Mazzios Ranch!!
Stephanie Ramsey
Wouldn’t suggest making any special requests here. They don’t know how to read when you want your toppings on top of your pizza to be delivered from the Yukon store. You will get them on the side. Personally if I wanted to make my own pizza I wouldn’t have ordered one. And they are super slow to not have much business.
Jake Doberenz
Mazzio’s Tuesday night buffet is a weekly tradition I genuinely enjoy. It’s a laid-back, affordable way to wind down the day with some comfort food, and the friendly staff always make the experience better. They recognize the regulars, greet everyone with a smile, and are typically quick to keep the buffet line clean and stocked.
The pizza is usually pretty solid—crispy crust, melty cheese, and a good balance of toppings. While I wouldn’t call it gourmet, it’s consistently tasty and satisfying, especially for a buffet setting. I always find something I like, and the cinnamon sticks are a sweet bonus to finish off the meal.
My one mild complaint is the variety—while I enjoy the options they have, I do wish they rotated in more unique or creative selections. Sometimes it feels like the same few pizzas every week. Still, for the price and convenience, it’s hard to beat.
If you’re looking for a casual, budget-friendly dinner with friendly service and dependable pizza, Mazzio’s Tuesday buffet hits the spot. It’s become a routine I look forward to, and I appreciate the relaxed atmosphere that keeps me coming back week after week.
Dwayne Caldwell
My sweetheart and I get pizza from here every so often. The pizza is hot, crust is crispy, and they don't skimp on the toppings. I've always been greeted with a smile, and the over all atmosphere is warm and inviting. Keep up the good work!
Leia Wheeler
Great food. Great customer service!!!!
Christy Etter
We were the only ones there on a Saturday night. But the pizza is a good as I remember it being. Salad bar was well stocked.
Chelsi Hudson
We ordered a pizza from this location, and were quoted a 30 minutes wait time. After an hour, I called customer service to ask where our order might be? I was quoted another 20 minutes, and was told to call if it hadn’t arrived. I then inquired if the order was x3 what I was quoted, if I’d be charged for it. Was told, ‘no mam, we’re giving you a discount’. The discount was $3. Over a hr and a half, rude, and a $3 discount. Won’t be ordering from here ever again.
Service: 1
Mike Ahlden
Nice to see it back to good again. Buffet was hot and fresh. Salad bar was clean and full also.
This place has done a 180 turnaround since Amy and Jimmy have owned it! They are so customer oriented! The food is always great and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill Turner
As a former GM of Mazzio's Pizza, I have exceptionally high expectations when it comes to the quality of the food and service. I recently had the pleasure of visiting this location again , and I must say that my experience exceeded all my expectations.
Our food was absolutely delicious and it is evident that the new owners takes pride in crafting a quality product.
The salad bar was equally impressive, featuring a wide variety of fresh ingredients that were very appealing. It's great to see such attention to detail in maintaining freshness and variety.
In addition to the food, the service was friendly and attentive.
Overall, I highly recommend Mazzio's Pizza in Yukon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone, 14 Cheese Dippers
Pam Shelton
Love the cinnamon bread treats!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jesse Q
No pizza during the Tuesday night buffet, salad bar poorly maintained and poorly managed store. There were several people waiting for pickup orders. 1 pizza came out and was gone in seconds. We sat next to a couple that ordered a specialty pizza that waited for over an hour or more we could not wait any longer. This is not our first bad experience. This store was better with someone like Robin. No need for a generic response we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Megan Watson
Came here for the new ownership and the manager from Mustang now helps out here after leaving the Mustang location. SOLID buffet and excellent service and CLEAN restaurant! Will start coming here over
Excellent food choices on their buffet. The staff and ownership are very accommodating and helpful. The delivery service is efficient and attitude of driver is cheerful.
The staff is super friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Service is quick and attentive. And the food? So good! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Definitely coming back—highly recommend! Can’t forget the Mazzios Ranch!!
Wouldn’t suggest making any special requests here. They don’t know how to read when you want your toppings on top of your pizza to be delivered from the Yukon store. You will get them on the side. Personally if I wanted to make my own pizza I wouldn’t have ordered one. And they are super slow to not have much business.
Mazzio’s Tuesday night buffet is a weekly tradition I genuinely enjoy. It’s a laid-back, affordable way to wind down the day with some comfort food, and the friendly staff always make the experience better. They recognize the regulars, greet everyone with a smile, and are typically quick to keep the buffet line clean and stocked.
The pizza is usually pretty solid—crispy crust, melty cheese, and a good balance of toppings. While I wouldn’t call it gourmet, it’s consistently tasty and satisfying, especially for a buffet setting. I always find something I like, and the cinnamon sticks are a sweet bonus to finish off the meal.
My one mild complaint is the variety—while I enjoy the options they have, I do wish they rotated in more unique or creative selections. Sometimes it feels like the same few pizzas every week. Still, for the price and convenience, it’s hard to beat.
If you’re looking for a casual, budget-friendly dinner with friendly service and dependable pizza, Mazzio’s Tuesday buffet hits the spot. It’s become a routine I look forward to, and I appreciate the relaxed atmosphere that keeps me coming back week after week.
My sweetheart and I get pizza from here every so often. The pizza is hot, crust is crispy, and they don't skimp on the toppings. I've always been greeted with a smile, and the over all atmosphere is warm and inviting. Keep up the good work!
Great food. Great customer service!!!!
We were the only ones there on a Saturday night. But the pizza is a good as I remember it being. Salad bar was well stocked.
We ordered a pizza from this location, and were quoted a 30 minutes wait time. After an hour, I called customer service to ask where our order might be? I was quoted another 20 minutes, and was told to call if it hadn’t arrived. I then inquired if the order was x3 what I was quoted, if I’d be charged for it. Was told, ‘no mam, we’re giving you a discount’. The discount was $3.
Over a hr and a half, rude, and a $3 discount. Won’t be ordering from here ever again.
Service: 1
Nice to see it back to good again. Buffet was hot and fresh. Salad bar was clean and full also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the manager
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place has done a 180 turnaround since Amy and Jimmy have owned it! They are so customer oriented! The food is always great and fresh.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a former GM of Mazzio's Pizza, I have exceptionally high expectations when it comes to the quality of the food and service. I recently had the pleasure of visiting this location again , and I must say that my experience exceeded all my expectations.
Our food was absolutely delicious and it is evident that the new owners takes pride in crafting a quality product.
The salad bar was equally impressive, featuring a wide variety of fresh ingredients that were very appealing. It's great to see such attention to detail in maintaining freshness and variety.
In addition to the food, the service was friendly and attentive.
Overall, I highly recommend Mazzio's Pizza in Yukon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone, 14 Cheese Dippers
Love the cinnamon bread treats!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
No pizza during the Tuesday night buffet, salad bar poorly maintained and poorly managed store. There were several people waiting for pickup orders. 1 pizza came out and was gone in seconds. We sat next to a couple that ordered a specialty pizza that waited for over an hour or more we could not wait any longer. This is not our first bad experience. This store was better with someone like Robin. No need for a generic response we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Came here for the new ownership and the manager from Mustang now helps out here after leaving the Mustang location. SOLID buffet and excellent service and CLEAN restaurant! Will start coming here over
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...