Smitty's Pizza
2 The Square, Bayfield
(519) 565-2030
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Veggie Delight
Meat Lovers
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
You hear about places to go for good pizza and you generally just passively agree because, who doesn’t like pizza? Well, we finally got Smitty’s pizza and they trumped our expectations. They by far have the best pizza I’ve had around here. New favorite for us and we will be returning regular customers no doubt. Thanks Smitty’s!!
Got a supreme and pepperoni. Both were excellent. Toppings were very fresh, sauce was great, and the price wasn't too bad for the quality. We'll definitely be grabbing another when we make our annual trip to Bayfield!
Had all dressed pizza and wings. Wings were great, pizza was amazing. Crust wasn't great but the sauce and toppings were amazing and more than made up for it. Lots of fresh toppings and not over done with cheese Will order again!
You May Also Like
Out of the Blue Seafood Market Inc. - 1A The Square
![]()
Seafood Markets, Fish & Chips
Subway - 2 Main St S
![]()
Fast Food, Sandwich Shop
Captain Harry's Bar and Grill - 9 Bayfield Main St N
![]()
Bar & Grill, Cocktail Bar