Miss Nelle's Antiques and Cafe
2 Bay St, Baysville
(705) 767-2181
Customers' Favorites
Cotton Candy Ice Cream Cone
Panini Grilled
Recent Reviews
We went to Bayville to get out for a bit and planned to go to Miss Nelle’s based on reviews and photos. I don’t know what’s happened, but it wasn’t worth the trip, it’s dark and super pricey, I know it’s a tourist area but $4 for a medium coffee was insane. We left without getting ice cream - a small was $7.25 and another $2.50 if you want a waffle cone. We ended up getting ice cream from the food truck at the gas station for 1/2 the price and bigger sizes.
The little shop is very cute. The butter tart was ok. Probably from a box from a grocery store. But the lemon tart was probably the worst one I've ever had unfortunately. The lemon was rubbery, almost like a marshmallow. The coffee was fine. And it's very expensive. Tourist pricing.
The main store was cute, but the prices were unbelievable - e.g. $6.50 for a takeout buttered bagel. Antique section upstairs was haphazard, but the paintings of local spots were lovely