Miss Nelle's Antiques and Cafe

2 Bay St, Baysville
(705) 767-2181

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The ice cream hut was incredibly cute and had Kawartha Dairy ice cream for the prices listed in the attached photo. Note that the portion sizes were quite large, so even the baby size was fine for an adult. There were outdoor chairs and patio tables you could use.

The main store was cute, but the prices were unbelievable - e.g. $6.50 for a takeout buttered bagel. Antique section upstairs was haphazard, but the paintings of local spots were lovely
We went to Bayville to get out for a bit and planned to go to Miss Nelle’s based on reviews and photos. I don’t know what’s happened, but it wasn’t worth the trip, it’s dark and super pricey, I know it’s a tourist area but $4 for a medium coffee was insane. We left without getting ice cream - a small was $7.25 and another $2.50 if you want a waffle cone. We ended up getting ice cream from the food truck at the gas station for 1/2 the price and bigger sizes.
The little shop is very cute. The butter tart was ok. Probably from a box from a grocery store. But the lemon tart was probably the worst one I've ever had unfortunately. The lemon was rubbery, almost like a marshmallow. The coffee was fine. And it's very expensive. Tourist pricing.

More Reviews

Miss Nelle's Antiques and Cafe

2 Bay St, Baysville, ON P0B 0A3
(705) 767-2181