Browse menus, reviews and photos of the best places to eat near Cayuga.
Cafe · $
5 Cayuga Street North, Cayuga
Customers’ favorites
“Today I discovered the Hagersville cafe location. I’m a panini girl or a Caesar wrap BUT I was converted today with the prince chicken salad wrap…. A beautiful freshness to welcome spring! Jammed packed with chicken and fresh greens and cucumber! Fantastic!!! Definitely recommend Chef kiss Whitney 💋”
Canadian · $
1192 Kohler Road, Cayuga
Customers’ favorites
“We love taking the kids there early on Saturday morning and letting them pick out a doughnut 🍩. Staff are always super friendly and kind. Worth the drive!”
Sports Bar · $$
7 Cayuga Street North, Cayuga
Customers’ favorites
“Great atmosphere and delicious food!!”
Sandwich Shop · $
2A Talbot Street West, Cayuga
Customers’ favorites
“Best Subway I’ve had in a long time!! The guys working made the sub perfectly, I haven’t seen a subway make subs this good in a decade!! Truly sandwich artists here!!”
Pizza · $
20 Talbot Street West, Cayuga
Customers’ favorites
“One of my new favorite pizza places. Went there after a track day in the city with a friend. The pizza was gourmet, we got chicken and mushrooms on our pizza, it was very good especially with the dipping sauce. Highly recommend it!”
Coffee Shops · $
51 Talbot Street West, Cayuga
Customers’ favorites
“Ive been going to Tim Hortons for years and while its not fancy,its consistent and sometimes that's exactly what you want. Their coffee is smooth and comforting especially the classic double double.Its not as strong or rich as some boutique coffee shops but it hits the spot on a cold morning.”
Breakfast · $
HN Plaza, 322 Argyle Street South Unit 5, Caledonia · 9.34 miles
Customers’ favorites
“First time to the McPhillips Street location. Great food, excellent service. Large portions and very reasonably priced. I highly recommend.”
Bakery
2004 Main Street South, Jarvis · 0.13 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The staff greeted customers with a warm hello and a smile, which I really appreciated. I ordered a roast beef sandwich on a bun and a coffee. The fresh cheese bun was lovely and soft, and the roast beef was tender and tasty. I also appreciated the horseradish and barbecue sauce. The coffee was just right.”
Mediterranean · $
127 Argyle Street South Unit 5, Caledonia · 9.6 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Omg. It was our first time going here. It was absolutely delicious. we had donairs. Made me feel like I was back home. Thank you so much”
Mexican · $
351 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.42 miles
Customers’ favorites
“BarBurrito in Caledonia is amazing! Just tried it tonight! Welcome to Caledonia 🌶”
Fast Food · $
233 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.52 miles
Customers’ favorites
“we have been going there for years for the fish and chips .they are delicious and great portions.”
Fast Food · $
3819 6th Line, Ohsweken · 10.27 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Very good food ! I got the hot dog my partner got the chicken parm sandwich we got a poutine to share. The food was very good ! And the man working there was very friendly we had a nice experience will be back to try more food !”
Family · $$
345 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.42 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We went in for dinner last night. Our server was named Kevin. Very friendly and efficient. Kevin recommended the Prime Rib special and it did not fail to please. Everything was delicious. Highly recommended the Prime Rib Saturday dinner special.”
Cafe · $$
Pizza · $
345 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.44 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Very friendly, great service and pizza is done to perfection. Thank you guys”
Health Food · $
345 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.43 miles
“100% quality from product to customer service! If you don't know....they do!”
Fast Food · $
22 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.66 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We had driven past this many times over the years and finally decided to stop by. We had a burger and fries. Very nostalgia, outside seating could use a little refurbish”
Fast Food · $
216 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.52 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Went to try the new flavours...the Soper and the Brown both were served with smiles and courtesy. Well worth the drive from St. Catharines”
Sandwich Shop · $
345 Argyle St S Ground Floor, Caledonia · 9.45 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We always have such a great experience at the local Caledonia Subway! The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, the service is quick, and our food is always fresh and made exactly how we like it. The restaurant is always clean and well kept too. It’s so nice having a local spot where you consistently receive great service. The team here does an amazing job, and it definitely doesn’t go unnoticed. Highly recommend! 😊”
Pizza · $
North, 172 Argyle Street North Unit 6, Caledonia · 9.96 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Customer service and food at this location are always above and beyond! They took extra care to cater to my two boys tonight and address the pizza to them! Thank you! Appreciate you!”
Sandwich Shop · $
307 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.47 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I stop at Pitapit Today,Good food and great customer service.”
Hamburger · $
351 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.39 miles
“we came from New York where we do not have A&W. we went out of our way to go to this restaurant and we were not dissapointed. Good food, friendly staff, and clean restaurant.”
Pizza · $$
322 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.34 miles
Customers’ favorites
“old school Pizza where they DO NOT skimp on toppings. the wings are also the best around!”
Barbecue · $$
43 Argyle Street North, Caledonia · 9.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Just went for dinner amazing food large portions, amazing server “Hanna” what are great local establishment. Highly recommend.”
Pizza · $
351 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.42 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Out for a Sunday drive. The kids were getting hungry. Little Caesars for the win. We were in and out in less than a minute. Big parking lot as well if you have a camper with you.”
Coffee Shops · $
172 Argyle Street North, Caledonia · 9.99 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I stop by here every morning on my way to work, the staff are super friendly and always welcoming. My order is always hot and fresh. The restaurant is always clean whenever I go in!”
Coffee Shops · $
360 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.32 miles
Customers’ favorites
“First time at this Tim Hortons. Cheerfull staff! Looks busy but everyone always had a polite and friendly response. I tried the new loaded steak wrap absolutely delicious! Restaurant was clean. Most places I visit the bathroom is blah! Here the bathroom was tidy and clean. I will recommend and I will come again!”
Fast Food · $
322 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.44 miles
Customers’ favorites
“GRUVINDER and TOBI gave a MASTERCLASS in amazing customer service. THIS IS WHY I COME TO CALENDONIA KFC ONLY! Even when they are low on product, they make sure the customer has a great time!”
Fast Food · $
282 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.41 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The most efficient mcdonalds ive ever been too. Everyone is so polite and efficient! I even scored a free flurry that I was t expecting! It was such a nice treat.”
Fast Food · $
289 Argyle Street South, Caledonia · 9.48 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We went for breakfast, ate inside. ...food was great, place clean.....friendly employees, quick service...feel sorry for employees, have to deal with customers cash register and machines not working properly, both pre order machines out of order - not their fault; franchisee should fix things immediately for them or change company that is to do it; have heard that this has been a recurring problem for many months from other customers....will return again for the food..again, should be the franchisee's problem not the employees..”