Restaurants near Cayuga

“Great little bakery, don’t frequent as often as we used to due to work hours conflicting with their hours, but for years the kiddos have called it their favourite bakery! Daughter and mother works there and they’re fantastic with the kids! Definitely recommend stopping in in you get the opportunity!”

“Yesterday I went to go to Tim Hortons, clearly I was out of the loop as it closed lol. Yes I know it’s being renovated 😂 which led me to this cute coffee shop called The Carolinian cafe and eatery. Upon walking in, I was truly amazed at how beautiful this little hidden gem is… (I’m new to Cayuga don’t judge me lol) I got the chance to meet the owner as she works there herself. As she took my order, she was very kind and spoke to me as if I was a friend telling me how her family owned this shop, she even went out of her way to complement my hair all with in the first 5 minutes of stepping foot into her cafe. It wasn’t long before my order was ready, I got two espresso shots with oat milk, my usual order. And I don’t mean to be dramatic, but I think it may have been the best double espresso with oat milk I’ve ever had. Thank you The Carolinian Cafe Cayuga, 10/10 will definitely be back ❤️”

“We love taking the kids there early on Saturday morning and letting them pick out a doughnut 🍩. Staff are always super friendly and kind. Worth the drive!”

“Best service from Tayler I’ve ever had. She’s amazing and this place has great vibes 😎”

“I was passing through Cayuga and stopped in for a pizza, I never had Godfathers pizza before, I was very impressed with the quality, the dough was fluffy. But crispy toppings loaded. i love pizza lol. The two ladies working had great customer service, Friendly and cooked my pizza perfectly. great employee's 5 Star...!!!”

“Ive been going to Tim Hortons for years and while its not fancy,its consistent and sometimes that's exactly what you want. Their coffee is smooth and comforting especially the classic double double.Its not as strong or rich as some boutique coffee shops but it hits the spot on a cold morning.”

“First time to the McPhillips Street location. Great food, excellent service. Large portions and very reasonably priced. I highly recommend.”

“just had my first donair. omg it was what I remembered back in the day. thank you so much. 💓 delicious”

“BarBurrito in Caledonia is amazing! Just tried it tonight! Welcome to Caledonia 🌶”

“Very friendly, great service and pizza is done to perfection. Thank you guys”

“We went in for dinner last night. Our server was named Kevin. Very friendly and efficient. Kevin recommended the Prime Rib special and it did not fail to please. Everything was delicious. Highly recommended the Prime Rib Saturday dinner special.”

“Delicious, large portions, great value! I had the Chicken Caesar wrap and small fries. Chicken caesar wrap - this is a meal unto itself; large, filling, FLAVOURFUL. Small fries would be a large anywhere else; with the salt and vinegar on them they are mouth watering. Great food!!”

“old school Pizza where they DO NOT skimp on toppings. the wings are also the best around!”

“100% quality from product to customer service! If you don't know....they do!”

“Went to try the new flavours...the Soper and the Brown both were served with smiles and courtesy. Well worth the drive from St. Catharines”

“we have been going there for years for the fish and chips .they are delicious and great portions.”

“Amazing. Gem of the. Town
Great spot. And location
Fresh cut fries /_ gravy Was orginal burgers were old fashion styled
Definitely. Will be back.

Server had a pretty smile. With awesome vibes”

“Great price and friendly staff”

“I stop at Pitapit Today,Good food and great customer service.”

“Five Stars — Fast and Clean

The Caledonia Subway runs like a well-oiled machine. I visited at 6:50 p.m. on a busy Thursday night, with a lineup nearly out the door and the staff handled it with impressive speed and efficiency. They worked seamlessly together. The restaurant was spotless, the ingredients fresh, and every sandwich was made with care. Big compliments to the team for balancing speed, quality, and excellent service. Highly recommend this location.”

“We really enjoyed the food over here, staff was really friendly and helpful with precise information. Specially Hersheys cookie is really delicious, it was already mouthwatering but after having it, it’s like heaven.

Vegetarian options: Yes They do have Vegetarian options.

Parking: There Are Ample of parking space.”

“The food was really really good I stopped in ordered a philly cheesesteak dog and it was so well done 9/10 it needed more cheese tho but definitely ill go back again 😃”

“Out for a Sunday drive. The kids were getting hungry. Little Caesars for the win. We were in and out in less than a minute. Big parking lot as well if you have a camper with you.”

“we came from New York where we do not have A&W. we went out of our way to go to this restaurant and we were not dissapointed. Good food, friendly staff, and clean restaurant.”

“I live in town and frequent this location as I have had nothing but poor experiences at the north side location.

I just wanted to share a positive shout out to the young lady working the cash at around 10am today. I enjoy the hot hazelnut lattes and more often then not they are made poorly (not specific to this location just in general) & I end up throwing most of it away.

This young lady made it with love. It was absolutely delicious and her customer service was wonderful.

Along with that the gentleman, whose name I believe to be Jim, that I suspect is either the owner or a manager constantly hustles and provides the best customer care. I have seen this man juggle several food orders at once and keeps his cool as best you can in that type of environment.

Just wanted to give you all a positive shout out that is well deserved. We notice you and your efforts and we appreciate you!”

“We went for breakfast, ate inside. ...food was great, place clean.....friendly employees, quick service...feel sorry for employees, have to deal with customers cash register and machines not working properly, both pre order machines out of order - not their fault; franchisee should fix things immediately for them or change company that is to do it; have heard that this has been a recurring problem for many months from other customers....will return again for the food..again, should be the franchisee's problem not the employees..”

“Usually order from the app here and never had any issues. It usually pretty busy and I'm alright with waiting the extra time. It has never taken too long. Quality of food has always been good.”