We stopped in to grab a pizza on our way through town. The manager, Rob, was super friendly & provided great recommendations (including some shops to kill time in while we waited). Pizza tastes great & the skullzone was a cute addition. Would come back anytime!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Skulls, Pizza Co
Jessica Gould
Pizza here is amazing, never lacking in generous toppings and you can taste that dough is made fresh. Take out and delivery only at this time. Don’t forget that garlic dipping sauce!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Your Choice of Toppings
Micaela
Pizza was excellent! Customer service was great, will be eating here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Co, Personal Pizzas
Dan
We ordered Pizza Skulls for my daughters Halloween themed 1st birthday, there was a small, small issue with how the skulls turned out, honestly they looked great to me, but the owner wasn’t happy with them, she went above and beyond to make it right.We had 60 of them at the birthday and every one got eaten, everyone absolutely loved them, and asked where we got them.Great service and even better food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mini Skull Calzones
Kendall Patterson
Randomly chose this place when we were cottaging and lucked out.This is really good pizza and even the BBQ sauce for the wings was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Pizzas
Pizzaknight
Well-made thinish crust pizza with good balance of toppings and sauce -cheese well browned. Did not care for the sausage.
Amber Durocher
cute cozy pizza shop with a bright, spacious patio. The skullzones are fantastic & Lori is simply the best! Stop in and grab a bite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tobias Jensen
What a cozy little pizza place, stop in for some great pizza and atmosphere. You will not be disappointed.
Peter F
Good pizza and dipping sauce. Nice patio. Will be back.
Mary Lynde
We ordered pizza for a lunch party and it was really good. I prefer a thinner crust and this was perfect. They recommended the right amount of pizza for the large group, pizza was super hot and fresh from the oven when we picked up. 10/10 good spot!
I stopped in while my partner was doing a bike race in town. Loved the skull calzones and the staff were super super friendly and kind to chat with. Fun interior and great patio to catch a breeze. FAB!!! Thanks Creemore Pizza Co ??
Warren Noronha
Hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve had! Made with so much love! Lori is the best!
Ralph Menezes
Was on a road trip to Creemore and stopped over at this local beauty for some insanely delicious pizza. Must say that this pizza exceeded my expectations and the owner (and also her doggo Charger) were the sweetest.Definitely stopping by again if I'm in the area.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Your Choice of Toppings
Lisa Cook
I had my first Creemore Pizza from the Stayner shop. It was very good! Cheesy, tons of toppings, nice dough and fabulous staff. You can certainly tell s love into his products! I can't wait to try a panzo and skullzone, and the caesar and Greek salads! I'm so glad you came to Stayner!
Jacey Sampson
Lori serves up the best pizza EVER! Not only does she make her own dough from scratch, and use high quality fresh ingredients (and local seasonal ones when available!), but she also practices sustainability (most recently with the lettuce shortage, taking salads off the menu). Vegan and gluten free options too! And the homemade garlic dip is to die for. Lori pours her heart and soul into her food and her business and you can really taste it. She is an absolute delight to deal with, the food is always consistent and pick up times are accurate. One of my favourite things is going to pick up and not having to get out of my car because she has a drive through pick up at the Creemore location! And she’s just opened up a second location in Stayner! All the love for Creemore Pizza Co, you’ll always have my business ??
We stopped in to grab a pizza on our way through town. The manager, Rob, was super friendly & provided great recommendations (including some shops to kill time in while we waited). Pizza tastes great & the skullzone was a cute addition. Would come back anytime!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Skulls, Pizza Co
Pizza here is amazing, never lacking in generous toppings and you can taste that dough is made fresh. Take out and delivery only at this time. Don’t forget that garlic dipping sauce!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Your Choice of Toppings
Pizza was excellent! Customer service was great, will be eating here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Co, Personal Pizzas
We ordered Pizza Skulls for my daughters Halloween themed 1st birthday, there was a small, small issue with how the skulls turned out, honestly they looked great to me, but the owner wasn’t happy with them, she went above and beyond to make it right.We had 60 of them at the birthday and every one got eaten, everyone absolutely loved them, and asked where we got them.Great service and even better food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mini Skull Calzones
Randomly chose this place when we were cottaging and lucked out.This is really good pizza and even the BBQ sauce for the wings was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Pizzas
Well-made thinish crust pizza with good balance of toppings and sauce -cheese well browned. Did not care for the sausage.
cute cozy pizza shop with a bright, spacious patio. The skullzones are fantastic & Lori is simply the best! Stop in and grab a bite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a cozy little pizza place, stop in for some great pizza and atmosphere. You will not be disappointed.
Good pizza and dipping sauce. Nice patio. Will be back.
We ordered pizza for a lunch party and it was really good. I prefer a thinner crust and this was perfect. They recommended the right amount of pizza for the large group, pizza was super hot and fresh from the oven when we picked up. 10/10 good spot!
Restaurantji Recommends
I stopped in while my partner was doing a bike race in town. Loved the skull calzones and the staff were super super friendly and kind to chat with. Fun interior and great patio to catch a breeze. FAB!!! Thanks Creemore Pizza Co ??
Hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve had! Made with so much love! Lori is the best!
Was on a road trip to Creemore and stopped over at this local beauty for some insanely delicious pizza. Must say that this pizza exceeded my expectations and the owner (and also her doggo Charger) were the sweetest.Definitely stopping by again if I'm in the area.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Your Choice of Toppings
I had my first Creemore Pizza from the Stayner shop. It was very good! Cheesy, tons of toppings, nice dough and fabulous staff. You can certainly tell s love into his products! I can't wait to try a panzo and skullzone, and the caesar and Greek salads! I'm so glad you came to Stayner!
Lori serves up the best pizza EVER! Not only does she make her own dough from scratch, and use high quality fresh ingredients (and local seasonal ones when available!), but she also practices sustainability (most recently with the lettuce shortage, taking salads off the menu). Vegan and gluten free options too! And the homemade garlic dip is to die for. Lori pours her heart and soul into her food and her business and you can really taste it. She is an absolute delight to deal with, the food is always consistent and pick up times are accurate. One of my favourite things is going to pick up and not having to get out of my car because she has a drive through pick up at the Creemore location! And she’s just opened up a second location in Stayner! All the love for Creemore Pizza Co, you’ll always have my business ??