Fenwick Pie Co.

1410 Balfour St, Fenwick
(905) 892-1289

Recent Reviews

Robert Kuret

Great products and friendly staff. Their butter tarts are just as good as 13st winery.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauri Gill

The aroma inside makes you feel like your in grandma's

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edna Mae Coles

soup of the day is delicious and carrots cake

Yolanda Oconnell

Wow. Great wonderful food. It's probably the best breakfast we had in seriously in 10 years. If you want an absolute treat, this is the place!

Tammy Hodges

I ordered a Banana Cream Pie....it was very yummy. The pricing was good...the staff is helpful and friendly.

Angelo Iuliano

Staff was very polite and I would go back in a second with many many friends as well bravo ?

Ryan C

Just stopped by for their lunch special. Pork schnitzel parm on a fresh kaiser. $10 and it was the best sandwich I have had in a long time. Highly recommended their specials, pies and frozen entrees.

Karla Giusto

Loved the fact that you were able to accommodate us on making my BFF's bday special! Quality food & service very much appreciated! And Delicious pies :) A huge thank you from Montreal xox

Susan Whiteford

Today I visited The Fenwick Pie Company for the first time. Oh my goodness, am I ever glad that I chose to.I brought home three Butter Chicken pies and the one that I had was absolutely fantastic.The chicken and vegetables were so tender and along with just the right amount of Indian spices, as I was eating it, I was making sounds that I usually only make in bed.Also the pie crust was the most flavourful and flakiest that I have ever had.Thank you for a great meal. I will definitely be back.

j krick

A random drive by and decided to get some lunch. We had turkey on a croissant and ham on a croissant. We also grabbed 2 different types of flakey’s and 2 different types of long johns. Everything was excellent and prices were reasonable. If I was in the neighbourhood again I wouldn’t hesitate to go back.

Drew McIntyre

Great products, amazing prices!

Peter Walchuk

Wow surprised at the variety of choices and fresh products available. Will be back.

Diane Gin

Amazing desserts , the flakies are by far the best !

Michelle

After all the great reviews I had been reading on Facebook, I decided to visit over the weekend, and they did not disappoint! ? Everything was amazing! We will be back!

Sara Handrigan

My go to lunch spot whenever I'm in town. I always get the special whatever it happens to be. I also love their pies especially the blueberry.

Load More