You Had Me At Pizza
24 Olive St, Grimsby
(289) 235-7757
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
first visit. takeout.
detroit pizza was awesome and I would love to order again. I can agree with some other reviews that the prices feel inflated for an underwhelming portion size. Hopefully they reconsider the pricing, especially for toppings/ add ons.
We ordered a large pizza with mushrooms, black olives, onions and pepperoni. The onions were caramelized, the olives whole pitted and roasted, the sauce and cheese amazing. Mushrooms also sautéed and larger. This was the best pizza by far we have had possibly in our lives. It was worth every penny!! It could feed 3 people. This is fantastic!
Went in with my two boys last Sunday night, ones 12 and the other is 3. Ordered 2 orders of wings and a pepperoni pizza. I had a coke and the little guy an orange juice. Bill with 15% tip is $83+!!!!!!! Are you kidding me? The pizza tasted like a Costco pizza, wayyy to much sauce and clumsy. There is no way we would ever come back here, it's not affordable for mediocre food. This pizza used to be great, what happened.
the vegan capprese or however u spell it pizza legitimately changed my life. ITS SO GOD DAMN GOOD LIKE???? THE BALSAMIC OH MY GOD THE DRIZZLE WAS AMAZING 10/10 BETTER PIZZA THAN IVE HAD IN ITALY ON GOD ON EVERYTHING
Such a cool little restaurant, but it looks like my favourite dish isn’t on the menu anymore, it’s not showing up online; hoping that’s just a glitch cuz I’d love to come back for their Alfredo Cannelloni again
Why are you not open at lunchtime because of poor hours i understand there is a quality but come on no pizza at lunchtime
This is one of my favorite local Pizza shop in town, service is quick and friendly. Pizza quality is very good with topping and i love its crispy. Price is very reasonable which is a plus. It seems that they really know what they doing.
Great experience here...the server was wonderful, food tasted great and the prices are very reasonable.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wine Bottle, Meat Lovers Pizza
Ordered pizza last night for the first time
Was excellent
Definitely will be ordering again!
I came all the way from Ecuador to try this pizza and it did not disappoint! The tragically Canadian is my fav.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I had some really delicious pizza and chicken wings. I believe I got their Detroit style pizza, and their chicken wings tossed in their BBQ sauce & honey garlic. Gosh, the food was so delicious. The folks there were also super friendly and helpful! I would definitely order from here again when I’m back in Grimsby next time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Good food, consistent, and quality.
Garlic bread is amazing.
All the speciality pizza are well paired and put together. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Magic Mushroom Pie
Having another incredible pizza experience dining in tonight! The signature pizzas are so unique, their fresh ingredients make the food extra tasty and the wings are still the best we've every had - not just in Grimsby but everywhere. My nephew just called this restaurant "You Had Me At the Best Place Ever!". THANK YOU for all the delicious memories :D
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped in at the restaurant for the first time, we were looking to sit down and have a pizza at some place new. I was not a fan of the regular crust that we got with our pizza, however my family did enjoy it. I found the crust to be to dense and doughy. I would ask for a thinner crust on a return visit. Overall, the customer service was ok, it seemed like a bunch of college students running the show, with no real attention to detail. The cup and char pepperoni were tiny and we did not get alot on our pizza. I do believe in supporting local, which is why I would try this place again, but they will have to hit a home run. I think I will try returning on a Tuesday and get the wing special with the purchase of a pizza. I was happy with the price of beer at $6 for a can of Steamwhistle. Over all my experience was just Ok. I will close by saying the bathroom was gross and it looked like it had not been really cleaned in weeks. This should be an easy fix.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Delicious, great specials, great prices, cute space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...