You Had Me At Pizza

24 Olive St, Grimsby
(289) 235-7757

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cheryl \u0026 Jay

We had garlic pull apart bread, wings, Detroit style pizza (classic), and a signature meat lovers pizza. The wings and the classic were excellent. The Detroit style was good, but not great, a bit doughy. The pull apart was a disappointment, cold in the middle and the bread was dry (we did send it back and a new one came back warmer but still not heated fully through). Great service and a comfortable atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rebekah Roy

Staff was amazing and the pizza was delicious! Definitely made our New Years Eve!! We will most definitely be going back! 😊

Rachel O

We have had Take-out from You Had Me at Pizza a few times when we are in the area and it never disappoints. This time we ordered the Dill Pickle Pie, Detroit Classic, All About the Meat and the Garlic Bread/Knots with Cheese. The pizza was ready upon arrival and service was friendly. There are tables to dine in with dim lighting to set a cozy atmosphere. We will absolutely be ordering from here again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dre’s Auto Detailing Inc

I have been here numerous times, the food is top-notch, the pizza is literally the best in town reminds me of Europe. Quality ingredients and they are not shy on the toppings. I will add the lack for the three stars in the service in atmosphere is due to Not answering their phone calls, they literally ignore their phone calls a young staff, which is great however may need some leadership all else can’t complain.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Joni smith

Great food great service . Lots of goodness here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J S

Great food great service . Lots of goodness here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

char salvekia andruchiw

They my kitchen always makes a Italian food with homemade meats and the dough is perfect . Get the do nuts boys it's my favorite . Ciao

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gerry Asmus

I think this might be the best pizza I have ever had!

Christopher Wills

Don't pass it up!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Jones

first visit. takeout.
detroit pizza was awesome and I would love to order again. I can agree with some other reviews that the prices feel inflated for an underwhelming portion size. Hopefully they reconsider the pricing, especially for toppings/ add ons.

Patti Roberts

We ordered a large pizza with mushrooms, black olives, onions and pepperoni. The onions were caramelized, the olives whole pitted and roasted, the sauce and cheese amazing. Mushrooms also sautéed and larger. This was the best pizza by far we have had possibly in our lives. It was worth every penny!! It could feed 3 people. This is fantastic!

E M

Went in with my two boys last Sunday night, ones 12 and the other is 3. Ordered 2 orders of wings and a pepperoni pizza. I had a coke and the little guy an orange juice. Bill with 15% tip is $83+!!!!!!! Are you kidding me? The pizza tasted like a Costco pizza, wayyy to much sauce and clumsy. There is no way we would ever come back here, it's not affordable for mediocre food. This pizza used to be great, what happened.

Amanda Xue

the vegan capprese or however u spell it pizza legitimately changed my life. ITS SO GOD DAMN GOOD LIKE???? THE BALSAMIC OH MY GOD THE DRIZZLE WAS AMAZING 10/10 BETTER PIZZA THAN IVE HAD IN ITALY ON GOD ON EVERYTHING

Janessa Turco

Such a cool little restaurant, but it looks like my favourite dish isn’t on the menu anymore, it’s not showing up online; hoping that’s just a glitch cuz I’d love to come back for their Alfredo Cannelloni again

Plumknight 62252

Why are you not open at lunchtime because of poor hours i understand there is a quality but come on no pizza at lunchtime

Loading...