You Had Me At Pizza
24 Olive St, Grimsby
(289) 235-7757
Customers' Favorites
Mac 'N Cheese Pizza Style
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Dill Pickle Pie 16
Magic Mushroom Pie
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pierogie Pie
Cesar Salad
Wine Bottle
Wings
Menu
Photos
+28 photos
+27 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We ordered a large pizza with mushrooms, black olives, onions and pepperoni. The onions were caramelized, the olives whole pitted and roasted, the sauce and cheese amazing. Mushrooms also sautéed and larger. This was the best pizza by far we have had possibly in our lives. It was worth every penny!! It could feed 3 people. This is fantastic!
the vegan capprese or however u spell it pizza legitimately changed my life. ITS SO GOD DAMN GOOD LIKE???? THE BALSAMIC OH MY GOD THE DRIZZLE WAS AMAZING 10/10 BETTER PIZZA THAN IVE HAD IN ITALY ON GOD ON EVERYTHING
You May Also Like
JJ's on the Docks Eatery Grimsby - 15 Lake St
![]()
Canadian, Comfort Food, Vegetarian
Rikochez Pub & Eatery - 54 Ontario St
![]()
Bar & Grill
Spuddy's Fry Truck - 36 Main St W
![]()
Food Trucks, Hot Dogs, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
detroit pizza was awesome and I would love to order again. I can agree with some other reviews that the prices feel inflated for an underwhelming portion size. Hopefully they reconsider the pricing, especially for toppings/ add ons.