Aristotle's Steak & Seafood House

Great food, service and ambience. I recommend the stuffed shrimp. Would definitely go again.

I'm trying to be as graceful as possible but this was a severe disappointment. The only good things were the host and the wine. The server was outright rude and shouldn't be working at a fine dining establishment. The food was horrible, filet mignon was undercooked, supposed to be medium rare but was blue and cold in the middle. The lobster was literal rubber and the side dishes for both were cold and bland. I've never had such poorly cooked food that was so expensive and i've eaten everything from truck stop steaks to chris ruths (id rather eat an $8 steak on the side of a highway than try this place again). This was a $200 dinner that would've been better spent at costco buying a whole tenderloin and 2 lobsters to cook at home for an entire weekend of meals for 2. Avoid this place like plague unless you're ok with bad food being served to you with an attitude. Its very unfortunate that we didn't listen to previous reviews.

It took almost 45 minutes to arrive after ordering. The brocoli wasn't cut and it looked like they cut huge piece and put on the plate. The scalloped were barely cooked and bland. The shrimp were big but again no flavor. It was disappointing because it was Valentines as well. Not the best experience. I won't be returning.

The food was amazingly delicious. The service was very slow and very unprofessional. Waiting half and hour to take appetizer order Had to wait 15-20 for more bread. One of us got up to remind him for the third time. He said sorry....they burnt it....it will be out soon.That was prior to getting up to ask again. Had to ask waiter for dessert and coffee. Then He brought the coffee one at a time.....15 minutes after we ate our dessert. At the end.....one of the employee said our waiter was new. That is so not true:....I have seen this waiter there several time I. The past 2 years. I think that upset me even more than just saying........sorry we didn't do that well tonight. I would go back but would ask for a different server

Amazing food - service & experience rib eye steaks are melt in your mouth grilled to perfection- will definitely be back and recommend to all our friends-

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A previous reviewer said it best...fine dining prices for banquet hall food.

Be warned. They are not serving quality food here. Charging $70+ for a steak and lathering it with powdered bearnaise sauce is false advertising, in my view.

Suggesting to patrons that you are a high class establishment and serving cold, stale food is a terrible way to earn respect and repeat customers.

Forgetting reservations, avoiding responsibility for mistakes and doing nothing to turn a terrible experience around is a sure way to get a bad Google review.

I eat at a lot of restaurants around the GTA. This was easily one of the worst.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Wow!!! We were invited to dine at Aristotle's by friends who have been there before. Our friends let us down. They didn't come close to telling us how amazing the food, atmosphere etc truly was. The owner was attentive, funny, and more than accomodating. We will definitely be returning in the future.
Bravo, Aristotle's

Great place for a date night or group dinner. Super affordable wine, fireplace dinning and the whole family is a part of it all. Go check it out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you're a steak lover, Aristotle’s Steakhouse is a must-visit! The prime steaks are perfectly cooked and melt in your mouth with incredible flavor. The ribs are tender, juicy, and packed with smoky BBQ flavour.

The Caesar salad is fresh and crisp, calamari is super tasty and the garlic bread’s addictive.

From the atmosphere to the food, this place nails it. Highly recommend for anyone craving a top-notch steakhouse experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Peppercorn Steak, Rack of Lamb, Garlic Bread mmmmm, Lobster Tail Drenched in Butter, Prime Rib of Beef with Baked Potato Olives and Garlic Bread, Steak, Calamari Starter

The steak was huge - was a little too dry for my liking. The sides were okay - nothing spectacular.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Peppercorn Steak, Garlic Shrimp

We have been dining at Aristotles for over 35 years. A family run establishment that has endured the test of time due to the excellent service and quality of food. Thank you Peter and Nick, your Dad would be proud of the way you have carried on!

Okay, so here’s my honest review the staff here are amazing. Super Kind, and always on the ball seems like a great warm family owned restaurant. The food was great as well, for the price you pay you get huge servings and the food makes you feel great (not that gross feeling after some places). The food was not my favourite out of a steak and seafood house but with that being said the service made my meal 100x better and the breadsticks, pickles and Olivier’s I would come back here just from service alone. 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Broiled Lobster, Steak

I really loved the garlic bread!! The ambiance and service was great! My dish was lacking.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

First and most the service wasn't very good. I believe the main problem was that they were understaffed. We waited a long time before anyone came to get our drink order. In fact they asked for our food first. The salads were not very good. The lettuce wilted. The Greek Salad all you could taste was vinegar. When our main course came that's when our appetizer plates were taken. Most of my party were not happy with their main course. I thought mine the stuffed shrimp were good 1 out of 9. Not a good percentage. We all decided we would not go back. Sorry about that.

Good quiet place for a good value meal. The servers were wonderful and we got a nice piece of complimentary cake for our birthday celebrant. which was much appreciated. I would recommend this restaurant for a quite undisturbed place.