I made a reservation for 8 a week prior to our scheduled date. Upon arrival we were told the table wasn’t ready because other patrons hadn’t left yet. When we were given a table, it was at the front near the door. When I made the reservation, I specifically requested a table near the back to avoid the bar area and the cold air near the front door. I was told there was no note of that and that I should have called and not used the website. I told them I did call and the answer was “there’s nothing we can do.” The bottles of water were placed on the table, without glasses for 10 mins. Our drink order took about 20 mins. We could see the drinks for 10 mins sitting on the bar. The apps came before our drinks.
The server “Nick” was polite and very engaging. I don’t believe these issues were his fault. This restaurant was clearly lacking management on the floor. I thought the food was good and priced fairly.
A late table; seated where we did not want to be; told there was nothing they could do and that I needed to make my reservation differently (even though I did); 20 minute drink order. A manager should have came to our table and addressed these issues. I was very surprised they didn’t.
I would not recommend this establishment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Kimberly
Me and my best friend came for dinner last night for my birthday. The atmosphere was wonderful our server was pretty great. He did leave us alone for quite a while but can be overlooked since he was so kind and did do a good job. I had the cabanara. I have only had it in Italy so I was concerned that it wouldn't be cooked properly as I know it is a hard dish. I sadly found it was not cooked to the right consistency it looked and tasted a bit chunky as if the egg did not cook properly. And we also ordered a starter of faccia bread and I found it was not fresh, made that day.
Sara M
We enjoyed a wonderful evening at Capro Toro with friends, seated beside the beautifully rustic—and delightfully warm—wood-fired stone oven. From the moment we arrived, the hostess greeted us with genuine warmth and promptly guided us to our table. Within moments, our server welcomed us and took our drink orders from the menu accessed conveniently through the QR code.
Our cocktails arrived quickly and were absolutely delicious—highly recommend the Capra Mule. As we sipped our drinks, we had the pleasure of watching the pizza maker expertly work the dough from scratch and craft the most stunning pizzas beside the glowing oven.
Our meals were served promptly, and every dish exceeded our expectations. The owner even stopped by to ensure everything was to our satisfaction, and our server remained attentive without ever feeling intrusive.
Overall, we give Capro Toro a well-earned five-star review. A truly memorable dining experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fred
Deadly food and great service. I'm from out of town but if I lived in the area, this would be a go to forsure.
Blake Morrison
Always a great experience. Music was enjoyable and at a reasonable volume, server was very friendly and attentive, food & drink was amazing.
M MC
Such an incredible dinner. It was my time first time eating here and I'm officially hooked. Atmosphere is incredible, the positioning of walls and seating really helped with general crowed noise. Dinner was so delicious, and service was so excellent. When our server came over to our party of 8 the pizza chef said hello to our table and used this opportunity to listen in if there may be pizza orders so he could get started right away. Our server checked in with our table like 2 times maybe 3 times and it was perfect. In my opinion that's good enough, we were looked after while also not being harrassed.
$$$Lastly, the price of ALL menu items are shockingly well priced. Honestly we've spent more at Wild Wings lol.
You will not regret eating here!!!! Incredible I'll be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JonGuy008
I'd recommend this restaurant to anyone. It was great Italian food, the service was fantastic. The server and, who I'm guessing was the shift manager or owner, were engaging and personable without being annoying. They could do with cleaning the rafters and their big decor sign inside as they had cobwebs but aside from that it was well maintained and a great atmosphere. Can't wait to go back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlotte M
Manager there is extremely abusive towards staff I witnessed first hand, is very rude to customers. Would recommend he be removed from management before you lose all your regular customers,
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi
Jeff Marchen
Our first time on won’t be our last. Shout out to Nick, Paulie and staff for an amazing experience. Food was great, the pizza and pasta specials could be on the permanent menu. To the young lady who was four days new to working at Capra Toro, you rocked it. We will be back!!
Great experience, a little noisy there were three large parties. Had the pasta special and we shared a Caesar salad, amazing dressing. The pasta was a little under cooked. My MIL had the Alfredo she loved the sauce! Her pasta was a little under done. Pasta is definitely freaked just extra la dente. Desserts were excellent
Roberto Mancini
The new bartender is absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jasmine Denike
Went to Capra Toro on a date night with my husband. We shared two different delicious pizzas. The server was kind and funny and the atmosphere was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin Hagar
Visited on a work trip and very glad that we did! The food was excellent as was the service but the cherry on top was the owner taking time to come out and shoot the breeze with us. Great restaurant with a great Vibe and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Ingram
My sister in law recommended Capra Toro , what a perfect choice. The staff here were very helpful with meal choices. We met Pauly a knowledgeable guy kept things running smooth as the restaurant got busier. The pizza chef's took time to take a few photos for us.Thanks for making our birthday celebrations just perfect. We will be returning again.
My favourite place in Peterborough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I made a reservation for 8 a week prior to our scheduled date. Upon arrival we were told the table wasn’t ready because other patrons hadn’t left yet. When we were given a table, it was at the front near the door. When I made the reservation, I specifically requested a table near the back to avoid the bar area and the cold air near the front door. I was told there was no note of that and that I should have called and not used the website. I told them I did call and the answer was “there’s nothing we can do.” The bottles of water were placed on the table, without glasses for 10 mins. Our drink order took about 20 mins. We could see the drinks for 10 mins sitting on the bar. The apps came before our drinks.
The server “Nick” was polite and very engaging. I don’t believe these issues were his fault. This restaurant was clearly lacking management on the floor.
I thought the food was good and priced fairly.
A late table; seated where we did not want to be; told there was nothing they could do and that I needed to make my reservation differently (even though I did); 20 minute drink order. A manager should have came to our table and addressed these issues. I was very surprised they didn’t.
I would not recommend this establishment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Me and my best friend came for dinner last night for my birthday. The atmosphere was wonderful our server was pretty great. He did leave us alone for quite a while but can be overlooked since he was so kind and did do a good job. I had the cabanara. I have only had it in Italy so I was concerned that it wouldn't be cooked properly as I know it is a hard dish. I sadly found it was not cooked to the right consistency it looked and tasted a bit chunky as if the egg did not cook properly. And we also ordered a starter of faccia bread and I found it was not fresh, made that day.
We enjoyed a wonderful evening at Capro Toro with friends, seated beside the beautifully rustic—and delightfully warm—wood-fired stone oven. From the moment we arrived, the hostess greeted us with genuine warmth and promptly guided us to our table. Within moments, our server welcomed us and took our drink orders from the menu accessed conveniently through the QR code.
Our cocktails arrived quickly and were absolutely delicious—highly recommend the Capra Mule. As we sipped our drinks, we had the pleasure of watching the pizza maker expertly work the dough from scratch and craft the most stunning pizzas beside the glowing oven.
Our meals were served promptly, and every dish exceeded our expectations. The owner even stopped by to ensure everything was to our satisfaction, and our server remained attentive without ever feeling intrusive.
Overall, we give Capro Toro a well-earned five-star review. A truly memorable dining experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deadly food and great service. I'm from out of town but if I lived in the area, this would be a go to forsure.
Always a great experience. Music was enjoyable and at a reasonable volume, server was very friendly and attentive, food & drink was amazing.
Such an incredible dinner. It was my time first time eating here and I'm officially hooked. Atmosphere is incredible, the positioning of walls and seating really helped with general crowed noise. Dinner was so delicious, and service was so excellent. When our server came over to our party of 8 the pizza chef said hello to our table and used this opportunity to listen in if there may be pizza orders so he could get started right away. Our server checked in with our table like 2 times maybe 3 times and it was perfect. In my opinion that's good enough, we were looked after while also not being harrassed.
$$$Lastly, the price of ALL menu items are shockingly well priced. Honestly we've spent more at Wild Wings lol.
You will not regret eating here!!!! Incredible I'll be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'd recommend this restaurant to anyone. It was great Italian food, the service was fantastic. The server and, who I'm guessing was the shift manager or owner, were engaging and personable without being annoying. They could do with cleaning the rafters and their big decor sign inside as they had cobwebs but aside from that it was well maintained and a great atmosphere. Can't wait to go back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Manager there is extremely abusive towards staff I witnessed first hand, is very rude to customers. Would recommend he be removed from management before you lose all your regular customers,
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi
Our first time on won’t be our last. Shout out to Nick, Paulie and staff for an amazing experience. Food was great, the pizza and pasta specials could be on the permanent menu. To the young lady who was four days new to working at Capra Toro, you rocked it.
We will be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great experience, a little noisy there were three large parties. Had the pasta special and we shared a Caesar salad, amazing dressing. The pasta was a little under cooked. My MIL had the Alfredo she loved the sauce! Her pasta was a little under done. Pasta is definitely freaked just extra la dente. Desserts were excellent
The new bartender is absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went to Capra Toro on a date night with my husband. We shared two different delicious pizzas. The server was kind and funny and the atmosphere was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visited on a work trip and very glad that we did! The food was excellent as was the service but the cherry on top was the owner taking time to come out and shoot the breeze with us. Great restaurant with a great Vibe and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My sister in law recommended Capra Toro , what a perfect choice. The staff here were very helpful with meal choices. We met Pauly a knowledgeable guy kept things running smooth as the restaurant got busier. The pizza chef's took time to take a few photos for us.Thanks for making our birthday celebrations just perfect. We will be returning again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...