Central Smith Creamery

739 Lindsay Rd, Selwyn
(705) 742-5867

Recent Reviews

Roxanne M

Love this local gem! I am counting down the days until they open for the summer season so I am bring the whole family.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Teresa Crawford

The best Ice cream and great service. So many flavors. Way more nuts, strawberries etc then other brands. Delicious, creamy ice cream.

neil nsc

Great ice cream,lots of flavors to choose from.

Justine Dos Santos

I ordered the watermelon sherbert and lavender lemonade. So refreshing and not so sweet. The vibe of the place is so calm and relaxing. Can't wait to come back and try more flavours.

Tabbby M.

I mean, even bad ice cream is still pretty good. This ice cream is basically ice cream for kids - overly sweet, not very smooth, the flavours tastes like colours rather than the main ingredient. For example the strawberry ice cream tastes like "pink candy" but not like strawberries. Also obviously the pink is a good dye. So, basically ice cream for kids who have never really had or don't need anything high quality. It's a nice place to stop for a cone, the gals at the counter are super nice, there are a lot of flavor options, it's very nice and far my, and the ice cream is cold. But it's no gelato,m and it's no Kawartha Dairy. But it's. totally fine, I like it and am grateful it is here.

Lennie Sweeting

We picked up rum and raisin ice cream. There is no grocery store in Peterborough that sells it.

Robert Quinn

Might be the best ice cream I've ever tried. Went with 4 people and all raved about the flavour and creaminess. And so many options.

Colin Cummings

Great quality. Only downside is it is not easy to get in the winter months. This is a problem because it's far better than the other dairy in the area

Lisa Graham

Delicious, unique, and refreshing flavours. My favourites are watermelon sherbet and rainbow sherbet. Beautiful little spot with outdoor picnic seating.

Nikola Nikolovski

Attention all ice cream lovers: I've found the secret portal to flavor paradise, and it's disguised as an innocent-looking ice cream shop! My taste buds had a fiesta that even my wildest dreams couldn't predict. The chocolate fudge swirl was like a soothing hug from a cocoa bean, while the strawberry sensation tasted like a fruity fireworks show in my mouth. And don't even get me started on the caramel avalanche – it's like a caramel river doing the Macarena on my tongue. I'm pretty sure the waffle cones are made by wizards, because they're pure magic. If unicorns were edible, this place would serve them. Five scoops out of five – it's a scoop-tacular masterpiece!

Jordan G

Super good ice cream if you are in the area. A must stop if you’re craving a frozen treat. Lots of delicious flavour for every taste bud. It was so good we went twice.

Caren Huard

Drove by this place many times through the years. Seen a couple sitting on the rocks in front, eating ice cream. We turned around and went back. Great price, ice cream best that I have ever tasted, both my husband a d I will keep going back.

birkdale home

Nice creamy Icecream.....

Frank Hewitt

Great community minded folks with fantastic choices for ice cream.

Melinda Young

Delicious ice cream and a great spot to sit and enjoy on picnic tables on the lawn. My son loves our special trips out here! Lots of flavors to choose from. Just wish there were napkins at the sitting area. Veteran move is to bring a pack of baby wipes with you to the table ?

Load More