Had an awesome time at the pub — the food was spot on and the atmosphere just right. Caitlin and her team were incredible — friendly, fast, and made us feel right at home. You can tell they care, and it shows. Can’t wait to come back!
Sharon A
Went for a girls day out. We had reservations and were about to be seated when the waitress said that somebody requested a window seat. We were not asked if we minded but rather were just moved. Although, we did not mind, it would have been polite to be asked since we were already sitting. Our orders took a long time to arrive. We noted that others who arrived after us were served first. The food arrived and was really delicious. That was the last time we saw our server until it was time to pay; we were not asked if we wanted refills on our drinks, nor if we wanted coffee or dessert. The machine was dropped down on the table and the server took off. It timed out because I wanted to add a tip amount and not a percentage. When she finally returned, I asked how to add an amount- without a word she took the machine away and had it set to the tip amount. The others in our party were handed the machine in turn. We paid. She took the machine, did not ask if we enjoyed our meal not thanked us for coming. We were having a fun day so our sour puss waitress didn’t affect that but we all commented afterwards that not one would recommend the Old Mill Pub, nor return. By the way I did want a coffee so went elsewhere.
J S
3 of us for lunch. Food not really good. They desperately need a new cook! Please. The chicken was dry and rubbery. The fries are OK. The calamari was over cooked. Expect more for the $130.00. The staff were really nice.Great building.
Gilberto David
Wonderful service 🙌
Julia Sadler
Vegetarian options: Yes, there are options
Dietary restrictions: GF burger buns and sometimes GF pasta
Kid-friendliness: Always welcome
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Soup of the Day, Salad
Susan Rough
Absolutely fabulous restaurant. I had the special Thai chicken soup which was beyond delicious and everyone's meals were fantastic. The service was incredible and given we were there during the Christmas parade speaks to how efficient this place is run. A beautiful venue that we will absolutely trek to again. Worth the drive for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike McKean
I was very disappointed with this experience. IMO, prices are very high. $26 for 2 small pieces of fish and chips. The fries are good but the fish was mediocre, pretty much flavourless. $13 for a child's order of 2 small chicken fingers and fries, and we didn't realize until the bill came that a very small juice drink was an extra $2. There are a lot of 5 star reviews, which really surprises me. Many people mention that it is good pub fare. Overall, I think it is pretty ordinary and does not justify the prices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Wylam Stokoe
This is a pub style bar, with TV's. There is a sit down bar area as well as table seating. The food is amazing and so is the staff. 2 adults with mixed drinks and tip $110. If you are visiting Creemore definitely stop by for a taste
Kid-friendliness: Kids menu
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marina Pashin
Very disappointed. Waited for what seemed like an hour for food. But that wasn't the biggest issue. The prices were very high and I thought there would be something special about the food, but it was just run of the meal. I ordered a chicken club wrap ($20) and I got... well, chicken, some greens, bacon, and not enough mayo. Nothing special about the chicken, just plain boiled chicken. Could've made this at home for a few dollars. The burger was dry and very basic, nothing special. The service was good, but because of the plain food and wait time we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Christine Figueredo
Service was very very slow. Everything else was great, food, server
Stopped in on a Monday afternoon for a bite to eat. The place was busy and we were warned that it will take half an hour for our food to arrive since they were under staffed. And it did arrive in about that time, drinks came a little earlier. The wings were ok, fries great and the drinks were fine. Service was friendly. Overall a good but average experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Drew Willcock
Great food as always
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JosefandCrystal Pruellage
Great food, staff and very dog friendly patio ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug McCann
Great spot....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Wings and Sweet Potato Fries
Carey Grayson
Nice pub with good service and decent food. We shared a burger and a salad. I had a Creemore pilsner which was okay.
Had an awesome time at the pub — the food was spot on and the atmosphere just right. Caitlin and her team were incredible — friendly, fast, and made us feel right at home. You can tell they care, and it shows. Can’t wait to come back!
Went for a girls day out. We had reservations and were about to be seated when the waitress said that somebody requested a window seat. We were not asked if we minded but rather were just moved. Although, we did not mind, it would have been polite to be asked since we were already sitting.
Our orders took a long time to arrive. We noted that others who arrived after us were served first.
The food arrived and was really delicious. That was the last time we saw our server until it was time to pay; we were not asked if we wanted refills on our drinks, nor if we wanted coffee or dessert.
The machine was dropped down on the table and the server took off. It timed out because I wanted to add a tip amount and not a percentage. When she finally returned, I asked how to add an amount- without a word she took the machine away and had it set to the tip amount. The others in our party were handed the machine in turn. We paid. She took the machine, did not ask if we enjoyed our meal not thanked us for coming.
We were having a fun day so our sour puss waitress didn’t affect that but we all commented afterwards that not one would recommend the Old Mill Pub, nor return.
By the way I did want a coffee so went elsewhere.
3 of us for lunch. Food not really good. They desperately need a new cook! Please. The chicken was dry and rubbery. The fries are OK. The calamari was over cooked. Expect more for the $130.00. The staff were really nice.Great building.
Wonderful service 🙌
Vegetarian options: Yes, there are options
Dietary restrictions: GF burger buns and sometimes GF pasta
Kid-friendliness: Always welcome
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Soup of the Day, Salad
Absolutely fabulous restaurant. I had the special Thai chicken soup which was beyond delicious and everyone's meals were fantastic. The service was incredible and given we were there during the Christmas parade speaks to how efficient this place is run. A beautiful venue that we will absolutely trek to again. Worth the drive for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was very disappointed with this experience. IMO, prices are very high. $26 for 2 small pieces of fish and chips. The fries are good but the fish was mediocre, pretty much flavourless. $13 for a child's order of 2 small chicken fingers and fries, and we didn't realize until the bill came that a very small juice drink was an extra $2. There are a lot of 5 star reviews, which really surprises me. Many people mention that it is good pub fare. Overall, I think it is pretty ordinary and does not justify the prices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
This is a pub style bar, with TV's. There is a sit down bar area as well as table seating. The food is amazing and so is the staff. 2 adults with mixed drinks and tip $110.
If you are visiting Creemore definitely stop by for a taste
Kid-friendliness: Kids menu
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very disappointed. Waited for what seemed like an hour for food. But that wasn't the biggest issue. The prices were very high and I thought there would be something special about the food, but it was just run of the meal. I ordered a chicken club wrap ($20) and I got... well, chicken, some greens, bacon, and not enough mayo. Nothing special about the chicken, just plain boiled chicken. Could've made this at home for a few dollars. The burger was dry and very basic, nothing special. The service was good, but because of the plain food and wait time we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Service was very very slow. Everything else was great, food, server
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in on a Monday afternoon for a bite to eat. The place was busy and we were warned that it will take half an hour for our food to arrive since they were under staffed. And it did arrive in about that time, drinks came a little earlier. The wings were ok, fries great and the drinks were fine. Service was friendly. Overall a good but average experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Great food as always
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, staff and very dog friendly patio ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great spot....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Wings and Sweet Potato Fries
Nice pub with good service and decent food. We shared a burger and a salad. I had a Creemore pilsner which was okay.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Burger
Loading...