Captain C Cakes and Ice Cream

Creamy, delicious ice-cream!

Carrot cake cheesecake was great

Great ice cream got the coconut scoop, great location, and friendly staff! Highly recommend to coconut fans

I’ve been searching for a bakery with cakes that hit the spot like this!
I’ve had the chocolate parfait ( pictured below) 3 times this week alone after my discovery of this back.
Fluffy whipped cream, soft fresh flavoured cake it’s absolute perfection!!!
And the staff are so friendly and sweet!

Very disappointed. Everything was soggy and didn’t seem fresh. It tasted awful. Presentation was terrible. There is sooooo much better out there. No actual strawberry in tart either. No carrot on cake as advertised. Just cheap ingredients and lacking attention to detail and artistic flair and creativity. No baking skill whatsoever. Not the type of standard I’m used to.

My favourite place to get cupcakes. The staff is always super nice and the cupcakes are so yum. The icing tastes like cool whip and the cake is really decadent.The cake in a cup is also really good and a nice snack.The price is also very reasonable for the amount your getting, id say the cupcakes are larger than average. The ice cream is really good too. Support local!

They were amazing with a last minute birthday cake request. Most places would send whatever they had, probably something a little less fresh, because most great cakes need to be ordered ahead. I ordered from door dash, then called to ask if they could write on it for us, and I totally expected to hear no, especially when I heard that the dasher was already there. But they did it! The man on the phone was quick and kind, and when I received the cake, it was perfect! Moist, light, super chocolatey, and delicious. I could not believe how fresh and homemade-amazing it was for the price and the timing! When I told a few people from Scarborough, they were well aware of the place and had rave reviews. Plus they serve Kawartha ice cream! Support local!

The “C” stands for Cliff. Cliff knows what he’s doing. Mad selection on the icecream. My wife & I got the coffee flavour and enjoyed it happily while talking to the captain. He’s running a tight ship.

I've been seeing this cake shop on tiktok for quite some time and I was in the area and excited to spot it, as I walked in I was greeted by a young man , and made my choice of purchase , I purchased the breakfast of Jamaica Smoothie and red velvet slice of cake and it was amazing definitely enjoyed both and would recommend, RUN.dont walk , it's amazing

Quality not upto mark as expected. It tasted more like loads of sugar. We ordered Eggless Vanilla cake.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Vanilla cake box is amazing just like backhome and there butter pecan ice cream and blueberry ice cream is amazing ?and uncle make there cakes fresh

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Kawartha Ice Cream Selection

Have you ever felt that you walked into a place and it made you feel like you were a kid again? Well, this cake and ice cream shop has that nostalgic feel and the excellent pricing to match their fantastic selection of quality desserts. This place can't be beat for tasty treats in Scarborough or anywhere in the GTA.

Parking: Ample parking and accessibility friendly.

Kid-friendliness: More real high quality ice cream flavours than anywhere in the Greater Toronto area at a family friendly price

Wheelchair accessibility: Ample parking and accessibility friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lemon Cake Slice, Kawartha Ice Cream Selection

We had the Kawartha ice-cream. It was not the best I had. It seemed gritty a bit and maybe not as fresh. The kids still liked it and the lady was very friendly !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Amazing server and collection of Kawartha Ice creams with options for milkshakes ❤️
Must haves: blue buried treasure

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Kawartha Ice Cream Selection

Decent ice cream, especially the coconut ice cream. But a little expensive. Would be nice if they let you try a small sample like other ice cream stores, or have smaller cups to try at a reasonable price. I find the service to be ok, they don’t go above and beyond to be helpful or kind. I was also craving a carrot cake, but the slice was too small to pay $5. Let me say, I’m glad i didn’t because now i see the reviews about the cake being sour, having freezer burn, and even one review where a cake had mold.