Olde Stone Cottage Pub

Nice pub atmosphere and tasty food. Sarah who was our server was great.

Sarah is the best waitress, best personality, funny to talk to keeps the vibes at this place. Food was stellar and served hot! Which is not common in Scarborough these days. 10/10 food !!!

We ordered the souvlaki and fish and chips dinner, with a glass of white wine and a beer. The food was freshly made and of great quality. We asked for a hot sauce and they brought us a jalapeño-based home-made sauce which was delicious!
We were happily surprised of the high quality food at a pub. In our experience, pubs do not necessarily serve the best food. But in this place, YES!
Bathrooms were clean and the patio was welcoming with sunny and shade areas.
Service was very friendly. We were there in a Wednesday for lunch so no wait and quiet.

I called ahead to see what kind of accessibility is Pub had. They said they had a back gate that they could let me in but they were having trouble with the gate. They said to call once I was there. I watched down the back and noticed there were extreme potholes and it was a dark type of alley with garbage and such. A very humiliating place for a person with a disability or mobility issue to have to go to. I called and no one answered so I had to call a friend and ask them to come back to get me. The back entrance was full of uneven surfaces and tripping hazards. There were also no seats with arms so I could sit down safely. It became a big production number just to try and get seated and I was embarrassed in front of my friends by all of the fuss.

There was no accessible parking that I could identify. Thankfully I did not have to go to the bathroom because I found out later that it is in the basement with a lot of stairs.

I tried to settle in with my friends and I ordered the Souvlaki which was a mistake. It was bland and not the dish should be like.

This place has been around for many many years and I'm surprised that it has not taken steps to be more accessible.

It was a rather humiliating experience.

Outstanding service by Raj. He was incredibly polite, professional, and knowledgeable about the menu., made all 7 of us feel truly cared for—friendly, attentive, and genuinely committed to ensuring we had a great dining experience. Food was amazing as well and great ambience. We had a great time. Thank you.

It’s been there since Confederation (1867). It’s still a great place for food, beer and watching sports. Their wings are great!!! not the breaded type. Their fries are home cut and good. Staff is great!

The service was excellent. The food was delicious and reasonably priced, my total bill was just under $25 for a burger, salad and cheesecake. It's a rarity to get that much good food for that price. It is a bit tricky to find the entrance to the restaurant in the dark especially with the bus lanes. The only comment I have on atmosphere was I wish some of the original charm of the stone cottage was infused in the pub (instead of dry wall, faux stone finish would have been neat) some elements remain like the fireplace and the flooring but still is a bit too modern and bland on the inside rather than that English pub feel.

Vegetarian options: There are one to two vegetarian options in each part of the menu, not an extensive selection. There could be more as most vegetarians are tired of veggie burgers, salad and falafels as the only options.

Dietary restrictions: Caters a lot of gluten free dietary restrictions which is a pleasant change.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

I attended an event at this location everything seems to be good including the service and the food, try for yourself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great hidden gem. Good atmosphere with a great style. The food is good as well.

Vegetarian options: Burgers and such

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

The Stone Cottage is always a great place to stop for a quick drink and a quick nosh. I see thru have queued up Paul James in the near future. He always puts on a great show. The Stone Cottage is the perfect local venue for him. Takes me back several years. Our band played a fund raiser - we had a great time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lovely staff. Rather Plain seating. The stone house construction itself is lovely.
Incredibly noisy street, so being outside seems unpleasant.
But only one of us enjoyed our meal (parm sandwich was enjoyed). Sadly, the chicken breast BLT was… awful. The chicken seemed like frozen “seasoned” chicken breast, it had grill marks, but it was so dry and tough, it was inedible. Even with the steak knife supplied. The herby ciabatta bun was overly seasoned too, and Soggy, not crunchy. The goat cheese was liquidy.
The fries were good though.
The washroom has an over powering chemical odour of scented air fresheners. The stall I was in has a broken sanitary disposal box that stays open, and it’s right at nose height.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Potato Fries

Great place to enjoy a high quality meal with family or friends.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are several steps up to get to the restaurant. The washroom is on the main floor but not wheelchair accessible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wow-we ordered our family Thanksgiving dinner from this little gem. Everything was absolutely delicious and felt like it came straight from Grandma’s kitchen.

To top it off, the restaurant was quaint and the staff was so friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Outstanding place, amazing burgers and atmosphere. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Enjoyed a meal and a couple of beverages with friends here recently. Everything about the experience from the food to the speedy and friendly service, to the lively yet relaxed atmosphere was great! Highly recommend the chicken club with Greek salad. We will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wrap