A great option for a unique wedding dessert! We ordered a variety of fruit pies which were delicious and much commented-upon by guests. We really appreciated the delivery and ordering in advance was a breeze!
Tyler Wardrop
Went in to get some desert for new years, everything was so good and the staff was super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake, Pie
Tom Stewart
Owner and service is so nice ! They have the best soups and meat pies and butter tarts Can’t wait to go back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fruit Pies, Pie
Jules Richardson
My mother-in-law ordered a vegan fruit pie for my birthday. We picked up a few savory pies while we were there because good vegan pies of any kind are rare. All I have to say is WOW! This place is fantastic, the pies are incredibly delicious, and the owner is the sweetest. Laurie was very kind and knowledgeable and was very patient with my very inquisitive nephew. If you're vegan and looking for a sweet or savory pie in Niagara, this is the place to go!
Dietary restrictions: Vegan
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco, Fruit Pies, Shepherds Chipotley Buffalo Cauliflower, Pie
Floyd Elzinga
Amazing Pies! Great owner. Lovely atmosphere. The mushroom pie is top tier. We love the our favourite pie is the mixed berry fruit (full-size) pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Osterhout
Buffalo chicken and Spinach and artichoke dips were amazing! Super quick and easy dinner. A great appetizer for our dozen mini pies 🤤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taylor Brooks
I can’t wait to come back here ! The pies we got were so delicious and unique! The ladies who served us were absolutely wonderful! This place will NOT disappoint! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Lynn Schroeder
Exceptional service! We called one minute to closing and the owner was very kind and stayed open for us. Can't wait to eat the pies we purchased, they look delicious! Thank you again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kitts Property Maintenance
Stopped by yesterday and Have nothing but good things to say about this place, the owners are very friendly to talk to and the pies are to die for! Everything I’ve tried so far has been incredible, highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ja La
A Slice of Heaven at Itty Bitty Pie! ?If you're on the hunt for pies that tantalize the taste buds and warm the heart, look no further than here. Each treat is a masterpiece, from the flawlessly flaky crusts to the rich, luscious fillings that promise an indulgent escape with every bite. Not too sweet, but just sweet enough! The selection of pies is nothing short of divine, so much so that they should come with a warning: dangerously addictive!What really sets itty Bitty Pie Company apart is not just their exceptional baked goods but also their outstanding customer service. My visit was met with a smile and I exited with a young man’s smile holding the door open for me -that's just as delightful as their pies. Whether you’re a first-timer curious to taste their apple pie or a regular craving your favourite coconut cream pie , the staff makes you feel right at home.I’ve had the pleasure of trying their offerings, and each one leaves me more impressed than the last. It’s clear that itty Bitty Pie pours passion and expert craft into every batch. For anyone looking for a five-star treat that’s both comforting and exciting, this place is a must-visit. Be warned, though: one bite and you might never want to leave!
Phenomenal apple pie, one of the best I’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carole Beaudoin
I contacted them through Facebook and they were very quick to respond. The person I dealt with was very kind and answered my questions. They were very accommodating as I had originally ordered for a Thursday and change it to the Saturday. I ordered 2 Banana Cream,2 Coconut Cream, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Lemon and 2 buttertarts. My husband was the person picking up the order and although the business was only opened until 3pm they allowed him to pick up at 3:30pm. Although I did appreciate them doing this for me I am left very disappointed. The order I received was not what I ordered. I ended up with 2 custard type, 2 chocolate which I am allergic to, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Cherry and 4 buttertarts. I contacted them through chat to let them know I think they gave us the wrong order. No reply. It said they weren't open until the Wednesday(this was Sat) so I thought maybe that was the delay in response even though I know they seen my message as I could see it in chat. No response. I messaged them again letting them know the order was all wrong. No response again. This is very poor customer service. I will never order from them again and will not recommend them to anyone.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Carole B
I contacted them through Facebook and they were very quick to respond. The person I dealt with was very kind and answered my questions. They were very accommodating as I had originally ordered for a Thursday and change it to the Saturday. I ordered 2 Banana Cream,2 Coconut Cream, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Lemon and 2 buttertarts. My husband was the person picking up the order and although the business was only opened until 3pm they allowed him to pick up at 3:30pm. Although I did appreciate them doing this for me I am left very disappointed. The order I received was not what I ordered. I ended up with 2 custard type, 2 chocolate which I am allergic to, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Cherry and 4 buttertarts. I contacted them through chat to let them know I think they gave us the wrong order. No reply. It said they weren't open until the Wednesday(this was Sat) so I thought maybe that was the delay in response even though I know they seen my message as I could see it in chat. No response. I messaged them again letting them know the order was all wrong. No response again. This is very poor customer service. I will never order from them again and will not recommend them to anyone.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Anthony Butera-Barros
I stumbled upon this pie shop in search of authentic, high-quality pies, and I am thrilled with my discovery! This place is a haven for pie enthusiasts, offering a delectable array of pies, soups, tarts, and cream pies that are truly exceptional. The expertise and dedication of the team shine through in every bite. I can confidently say that I won't be going anywhere else for my pie fix!I'm eagerly looking forward to trying out everything on their menu! If you’re a pie lover, this is the place to be!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda D
I ordered mini fruit pies for my bridal shower a few years ago and I still think about them! They were the cutest, most delicious little treat that fit perfectly with my “fall” themed bridal shower.
A great option for a unique wedding dessert! We ordered a variety of fruit pies which were delicious and much commented-upon by guests. We really appreciated the delivery and ordering in advance was a breeze!
Went in to get some desert for new years, everything was so good and the staff was super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake, Pie
Owner and service is so nice !
They have the best soups and meat pies and butter tarts
Can’t wait to go back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fruit Pies, Pie
My mother-in-law ordered a vegan fruit pie for my birthday. We picked up a few savory pies while we were there because good vegan pies of any kind are rare. All I have to say is WOW! This place is fantastic, the pies are incredibly delicious, and the owner is the sweetest. Laurie was very kind and knowledgeable and was very patient with my very inquisitive nephew.
If you're vegan and looking for a sweet or savory pie in Niagara, this is the place to go!
Dietary restrictions: Vegan
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco, Fruit Pies, Shepherds Chipotley Buffalo Cauliflower, Pie
Amazing Pies!
Great owner. Lovely atmosphere.
The mushroom pie is top tier. We love the our favourite pie is the mixed berry fruit (full-size) pie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Buffalo chicken and Spinach and artichoke dips were amazing! Super quick and easy dinner. A great appetizer for our dozen mini pies 🤤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can’t wait to come back here ! The pies we got were so delicious and unique! The ladies who served us were absolutely wonderful! This place will NOT disappoint! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Exceptional service! We called one minute to closing and the owner was very kind and stayed open for us. Can't wait to eat the pies we purchased, they look delicious! Thank you again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped by yesterday and Have nothing but good things to say about this place, the owners are very friendly to talk to and the pies are to die for! Everything I’ve tried so far has been incredible, highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Slice of Heaven at Itty Bitty Pie! ?If you're on the hunt for pies that tantalize the taste buds and warm the heart, look no further than here. Each treat is a masterpiece, from the flawlessly flaky crusts to the rich, luscious fillings that promise an indulgent escape with every bite. Not too sweet, but just sweet enough! The selection of pies is nothing short of divine, so much so that they should come with a warning: dangerously addictive!What really sets itty Bitty Pie Company apart is not just their exceptional baked goods but also their outstanding customer service. My visit was met with a smile and I exited with a young man’s smile holding the door open for me -that's just as delightful as their pies. Whether you’re a first-timer curious to taste their apple pie or a regular craving your favourite coconut cream pie , the staff makes you feel right at home.I’ve had the pleasure of trying their offerings, and each one leaves me more impressed than the last. It’s clear that itty Bitty Pie pours passion and expert craft into every batch. For anyone looking for a five-star treat that’s both comforting and exciting, this place is a must-visit. Be warned, though: one bite and you might never want to leave!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Restaurantji Recommends
Phenomenal apple pie, one of the best I’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I contacted them through Facebook and they were very quick to respond. The person I dealt with was very kind and answered my questions. They were very accommodating as I had originally ordered for a Thursday and change it to the Saturday. I ordered 2 Banana Cream,2 Coconut Cream, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Lemon and 2 buttertarts. My husband was the person picking up the order and although the business was only opened until 3pm they allowed him to pick up at 3:30pm. Although I did appreciate them doing this for me I am left very disappointed. The order I received was not what I ordered. I ended up with 2 custard type, 2 chocolate which I am allergic to, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Cherry and 4 buttertarts. I contacted them through chat to let them know I think they gave us the wrong order. No reply. It said they weren't open until the Wednesday(this was Sat) so I thought maybe that was the delay in response even though I know they seen my message as I could see it in chat. No response. I messaged them again letting them know the order was all wrong. No response again. This is very poor customer service. I will never order from them again and will not recommend them to anyone.
Food: 1
Service: 1
I contacted them through Facebook and they were very quick to respond. The person I dealt with was very kind and answered my questions. They were very accommodating as I had originally ordered for a Thursday and change it to the Saturday. I ordered 2 Banana Cream,2 Coconut Cream, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Lemon and 2 buttertarts. My husband was the person picking up the order and although the business was only opened until 3pm they allowed him to pick up at 3:30pm. Although I did appreciate them doing this for me I am left very disappointed. The order I received was not what I ordered. I ended up with 2 custard type, 2 chocolate which I am allergic to, 1 Cherry Cheesecake, 1 Cherry and 4 buttertarts. I contacted them through chat to let them know I think they gave us the wrong order. No reply. It said they weren't open until the Wednesday(this was Sat) so I thought maybe that was the delay in response even though I know they seen my message as I could see it in chat. No response. I messaged them again letting them know the order was all wrong. No response again. This is very poor customer service. I will never order from them again and will not recommend them to anyone.
Food: 1
Service: 1
I stumbled upon this pie shop in search of authentic, high-quality pies, and I am thrilled with my discovery! This place is a haven for pie enthusiasts, offering a delectable array of pies, soups, tarts, and cream pies that are truly exceptional. The expertise and dedication of the team shine through in every bite. I can confidently say that I won't be going anywhere else for my pie fix!I'm eagerly looking forward to trying out everything on their menu! If you’re a pie lover, this is the place to be!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered mini fruit pies for my bridal shower a few years ago and I still think about them! They were the cutest, most delicious little treat that fit perfectly with my “fall” themed bridal shower.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...