Not too impressed. overpriced tiny meat pies.. refused to pay 8$ for one. Didn't buy anything. Only maybe 5 different options for cream pies. Stock was super low. Mikeys cream pies in Hamilton is the way to go.
Anthony Butera-Barros
I stumbled upon this pie shop in search of authentic, high-quality pies, and I am thrilled with my discovery! This place is a haven for pie enthusiasts, offering a delectable array of pies, soups, tarts, and cream pies that are truly exceptional. The expertise and dedication of the team shine through in every bite. I can confidently say that I won't be going anywhere else for my pie fix!I'm eagerly looking forward to trying out everything on their menu! If you’re a pie lover, this is the place to be!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda D
I ordered mini fruit pies for my bridal shower a few years ago and I still think about them! They were the cutest, most delicious little treat that fit perfectly with my “fall” themed bridal shower.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rhonda Holloway
We tried the coconut cream pie, and the Keylime pie along with some frozen meat pies and all were delicious. You can’t go wrong. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Leon
I am so happy to have found Itty Bitty Pie Company. I had the turkey pie with stuffing, potato and cranberries, so much tender turkey and gravy. Best thing I have ever eaten. All their pies are just brimming with fresh yummy fillings and the apple caramel pie is to die for. Laurie and her staff make sure to greet you with a big smile. My family will be making Itty Bitty Pie Company a weekly stop for a delicious easy week day dinner and a sweet weekend treat. ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Oancia
The customer service was really good! And if I went again, I would definitely get the coconut cream mini pie, which is absolutely delicious. The small lunch pies we go,t tourtiere and buffalo chicken, were also super tasty!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
G M
Long overdue on writing this review. This place is the ultimate desert destination. Simply the best pies and cookies in Southern Ontario. I always grab the mini pies to take to events. Hard critics have said their pumpkin pie cheesecake is better than any pumpkin pie they’ve had. And the coconut cream is legendary.My biggest problem is their cookies. Personally, the best cookies I’ve ever had, in any country. Ever.I now live for the Oreo chocolate chip cookie. I’m not exaggerating.The customer service is on point. And in an age where effort and sincerity is rare, they are genuinely happy, respectful and appreciate of every customer I’ve seen come in. It’s unreal.And don’t sleep on their dinner pies and other meal options. But I’m a desert fanatic, so I write what I know!
Barbara Chappell
Working with Itty Bitty for my daughter’s wedding was a wonderful experience. The mini pies were both delicious and beautiful. Laurie went above and beyond with top-notch customer service. I highly recommend Itty Bitty.
Food: 5
Service: 5
S Carmichael
Just discovered Itty-Bitty Pie Co. What a treat it is to try their treats. Everything is scrumptious. ? I'm looking forward trying other goodies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna Orth
The staff are friendly and wonderful and the food is fantastic. Soups are great on a cool fall day!
Stopped by for the first time after my husband got a craving for coconut cream pies. Laurie was wonderful! The mini pies weren’t ready yet but she got them out for me and even put in an extra one. He loved them! I also picked up a tourtiere pie and a Jamaican one. Both were excellent. Comfort food at its best!
Stacey Ely
Amazing!!! New owner was so lovely and remembered me from the day previous and said she’d have the Mac and pulled pork pie and she did. Thank you!!
Haley Mae Iudiciani
Love!!! We’ve tried both the sweet & savoury pies, mac and cheese as well. Did not disappoint!Love the flavours of the pies they put out! Especially the option for vegan versions of my fav dishes!Will definitely be back :)
Melanie Denholm-Leroux
The best Mini Pies. Absolutely delicious.
Kristina Dunn
I recently ordered two banana cream pies from Itty Bitty Pie Company for my husband's birthday, and they were fresh and absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly flaky, the banana filling was creamy and so yummy. The pies were beautifully presented, and were a huge hit at the party. Highly recommend!
Not too impressed. overpriced tiny meat pies.. refused to pay 8$ for one. Didn't buy anything. Only maybe 5 different options for cream pies. Stock was super low. Mikeys cream pies in Hamilton is the way to go.
I stumbled upon this pie shop in search of authentic, high-quality pies, and I am thrilled with my discovery! This place is a haven for pie enthusiasts, offering a delectable array of pies, soups, tarts, and cream pies that are truly exceptional. The expertise and dedication of the team shine through in every bite. I can confidently say that I won't be going anywhere else for my pie fix!I'm eagerly looking forward to trying out everything on their menu! If you’re a pie lover, this is the place to be!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered mini fruit pies for my bridal shower a few years ago and I still think about them! They were the cutest, most delicious little treat that fit perfectly with my “fall” themed bridal shower.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We tried the coconut cream pie, and the Keylime pie along with some frozen meat pies and all were delicious. You can’t go wrong. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am so happy to have found Itty Bitty Pie Company. I had the turkey pie with stuffing, potato and cranberries, so much tender turkey and gravy. Best thing I have ever eaten. All their pies are just brimming with fresh yummy fillings and the apple caramel pie is to die for. Laurie and her staff make sure to greet you with a big smile. My family will be making Itty Bitty Pie Company a weekly stop for a delicious easy week day dinner and a sweet weekend treat. ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The customer service was really good! And if I went again, I would definitely get the coconut cream mini pie, which is absolutely delicious. The small lunch pies we go,t tourtiere and buffalo chicken, were also super tasty!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Long overdue on writing this review. This place is the ultimate desert destination. Simply the best pies and cookies in Southern Ontario. I always grab the mini pies to take to events. Hard critics have said their pumpkin pie cheesecake is better than any pumpkin pie they’ve had. And the coconut cream is legendary.My biggest problem is their cookies. Personally, the best cookies I’ve ever had, in any country. Ever.I now live for the Oreo chocolate chip cookie. I’m not exaggerating.The customer service is on point. And in an age where effort and sincerity is rare, they are genuinely happy, respectful and appreciate of every customer I’ve seen come in. It’s unreal.And don’t sleep on their dinner pies and other meal options. But I’m a desert fanatic, so I write what I know!
Working with Itty Bitty for my daughter’s wedding was a wonderful experience. The mini pies were both delicious and beautiful. Laurie went above and beyond with top-notch customer service. I highly recommend Itty Bitty.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just discovered Itty-Bitty Pie Co. What a treat it is to try their treats. Everything is scrumptious. ? I'm looking forward trying other goodies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The staff are friendly and wonderful and the food is fantastic. Soups are great on a cool fall day!
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped by for the first time after my husband got a craving for coconut cream pies. Laurie was wonderful! The mini pies weren’t ready yet but she got them out for me and even put in an extra one. He loved them! I also picked up a tourtiere pie and a Jamaican one. Both were excellent. Comfort food at its best!
Amazing!!! New owner was so lovely and remembered me from the day previous and said she’d have the Mac and pulled pork pie and she did. Thank you!!
Love!!! We’ve tried both the sweet & savoury pies, mac and cheese as well. Did not disappoint!Love the flavours of the pies they put out! Especially the option for vegan versions of my fav dishes!Will definitely be back :)
The best Mini Pies. Absolutely delicious.
I recently ordered two banana cream pies from Itty Bitty Pie Company for my husband's birthday, and they were fresh and absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly flaky, the banana filling was creamy and so yummy. The pies were beautifully presented, and were a huge hit at the party. Highly recommend!