St. Catharines Pizza Company

I do not order Pizza often. Almost never. I'm a heath food fanatic and prefer to make my own food to ensure the balance of my diet. But because of this recent heat wave here in St Catharines, I ordered a double cheese mushroom pizza today and was very very impressed. I could not give a rating on the atmosphere because I asked for delivery. The pizza was excellent! Very flavourful, not overcooked, and not salty (Which I find most of them to be) If you're looking for a fantastic pizza, this is the place! I will definitely be ordering again! ~Anthony on Pelham Rd.

This place is amazing, friendly staff and probably the best pizza I've had in St. catharines so far. I highly recommend the FBT special and chicken shawarma pizza 10/10.

Rude and incompetent service stay away. Called in and said I was having issues using the dine local site it kept giving me an error. Can I order with you and use the card. He said yes. Placed my order and when I got there he said that I have to use it online. Rudely as if I didn’t ask. Clearly he wasn’t listening to what I was asking on the phone. But the site says you can use in person or online. Left the pizza and wings went up the road to Pete’s. They were polite and accepted the card. Much better pizza and service!!!

My only go to place for pizza & wings. Friendly staff, order always ready on time. Pizza is not greasy, dough is done to perfection, nice & crispy, just like the wings. Don't look for another place - highly recommended!

I’m new to this part of the city so I’ve been trying every pizza place near my house, (8 different ones)
And this was my first time here. We got two large , wings, garlic bread.
Wings were done perfect with a great tangy sauce. A great garlic bread has you tasting it several hours later, and this one does. You can actually taste garlic! The test of a good pie is if it is as good or better when it’s cold next day. This one is excellent cold. The guy behind the counter was great and the place was fast and clean. The toppings were ample. And hey, they include carrots and blue cheese too.
My one small complaint is the dough was a bit flat and dense.
Let it rise a bit more with less working it and the pie would be perfect in my eyes. Food and price over all was great. I am a new customer.

Great family owned local pizza place, even though some of them dont think pineapple belongs on pizza. Salty and sweet is a winning combo

Great pizza for a great price!

There are so many awesome and unique pizza and pasta options. I tried the pepperoni a few weeks ago and the FBT Special last weekend. Both Delicious 😋

I tried this place on a whim the other week. Drove past many times, but never ordered here until then. I was really impressed with the quality and low prices. Customer service was top tier as well! The guy working there was so happy and friendly, I definitely found my new go-to pizza place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's our go-to pizza and wings place. Wings on sale on Sunday and Monday nights.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Wings

Very clean and quiet...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

We tried St. Catherine’s Pizza Company this past weekend as we were in the area. Service was great, pizza was ready on time. Prices were very good, large pizza for under $20, can’t really beat that. The pizza was ok, the toppings were a good amount as was the cheese. The sauce was also ok, didn’t seem very heavy on the sauce and tasted somewhat generic. The crust was not good, it was dry and unflavoured. Almost hard to chew. Overall it was a reasonably priced pizza and it did taste ok. Check them out if you’re in the area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

first time ordering from this place. I was really impressed the pizza and wing combo is a great price. The food tasted amazing along with the deep fried pickles and sweet potato fries that i ordered as well, they both had great size portions. Definitely will be ordering again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Take out only

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our go to place closed down. We were aware of the other pizza company location but no recent experience with this one. Got their tray special (3 toppings $27) along with the cheese balls and oh wow so good. The tray is thin not too doughy and good amount of toppings. The cheese balls are not like reg cheese balls but oh so good. Huge round balls with sauce. I think they are mixed with breading, don’t know, don’t care, so delicious. And you get a lot for $10. Try them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5