Rusty's at Blue

Great food great service considering it was super busy really enjoyed it Colleen was amazing

They updated their menu and only have vegan poutine for a vegan option. The poutine was great and we were happy with that. It was expensive. Would not recommend for vegans.

I came here for a girls weekend and the servers Maddy and Shawney were so fun. They made our experience much better we didn’t want to leave because of them. The village was boring but Rusty’s was such a fun time. We will be back to see our favourite servers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

EDITED - While the first time we visited was good, this most recent visit really tainted our opinion of the service. We were in for Game 7 of the World Series and told our server (Sam) that we would order apps first and then entrees later into the game. He checked in multiple times and got drink orders, but then when we were ready to put the dinner order in he simply said that the kitchen had closed a while ago. Frankly we were shocked and there wasn’t anything to be done at that point, but it was a big miss to have warned us on any number of interactions earlier in the night to ask for our order or let us know when they were closing and last call for food.

First Visit - Opted for the brisket plate given other reviews were talking about small portion sizes for the other options. It has to be their best value item on the menu because it says it feeds two but you could easily split that between four with an appetizer and be content. It’s not the best BBQ you’ll have but for the location at the mountain I would still recommend it

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Brisket Plate, Nachos

Food was excellent!! Amazing authentic BBQ ❤️. Incredible service from Sam! Thank you for a great evening 😊

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

5 stars for Jeff.! We visited from Niagara this weekend with the kids…popped into Rusty’s for drinks and snacks and Jeff was a Hoot:) so genuine with us and the kids. We went two days in a row because we had a great time chatting with Jeff. Rusty’s you’re fortunate to have this ace!

Very slow service. We were forgotten. Once they found us, we ordered and appetizers and mains brought together so no room left on the table and we had to eat everything together. Had to send back horrible bottle of red wine that tasted carbonated. Ordered another beer and a fresh glass of wine. After 20 mins had to beg for it. Manager kindly took off the charge for the appetizer but still $120 for ok food and terrible service. Yes it was World Series baseball night but not all tables were full. We don't eat out much so a disappointing experience.

First time at blue mountain, great place to go away too, but Rusty’s is beyond disappointing !!! Tried to charge 19.10 for a red bull vodka !! Are you out of your mind !!! GO TO K2 ! 10.00 before 10pm 6.75!!!! You think your better because you jacked the prices lol be humble and learn and thing or two from the bar next to you!!! Have a blessed day !!

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

I didn’t see any Beyond burgers or sausage on menu. Only main was a nice tofu bowl.

We were a Group of 5, from the moment we walked in the door and were met by the Manager, our experience was absolutely wonderful and especially given it was Game 1 of the World Series. Service was incredible, food came out quickly and Hot and everything was delicious. Considering the Restaurant was packed, the follow up service to the tables by all the servers, for such a Young staff they showed such incredible energy and interacted with each table. Highly Recommend, best Service in a Restaurant that I have been to in ages. Shout out to the Manager on duty, he was Fabulous.

We chose Rusty's for our party of 3 as part of the fall restaurant deal where the Agora - Path of Light tickets were included. The deal included appetizer, main course and dessert. The service was excellent, food came quickly and it was very tasty and fulsome. We were in at 6 pm an out by 7:15 pm, ahead of the 8 pm Blue Jays game. It was getting really busy by then and noise level was raised, of course! We'll go back to Rusty's for sure.

I witnessed an alarming incident at Rusty’s at Blue where the red-shirt security guards were not controlling a situation, but instead appeared to be provoking and physically engaging guests. This did not feel like security work. It felt aggressive and unsafe. I later heard from Blue Mountain resort security that this kind of behavior happens nearly every weekend, which is extremely concerning.

The atmosphere was tense and uncomfortable, and I did not feel safe staying there. Based on what I saw, I would strongly recommend avoiding this place until major changes are made in how guests are treated. A lawsuit is in their near future.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We went this past weekend for my birthday, and we had the best time! The food was delicious, our server was amazing. And we will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One server on a Friday night of a long weekend. Cool. Super over priced. Don't bother.

Great place to eat but…they started to ask a “minimum tip percentage”, and the host says: “ Is not optional, 18% minimum mandatory tip”. I love to tip but feels weird that now is mandatory…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1