Rusty's at Blue

Very slow service. We were forgotten. Once they found us, we ordered and appetizers and mains brought together so no room left on the table and we had to eat everything together. Had to send back horrible bottle of red wine that tasted carbonated. Ordered another beer and a fresh glass of wine. After 20 mins had to beg for it. Manager kindly took off the charge for the appetizer but still $120 for ok food and terrible service. Yes it was World Series baseball night but not all tables were full. We don't eat out much so a disappointing experience.

I didn’t see any Beyond burgers or sausage on menu. Only main was a nice tofu bowl.

We were a Group of 5, from the moment we walked in the door and were met by the Manager, our experience was absolutely wonderful and especially given it was Game 1 of the World Series. Service was incredible, food came out quickly and Hot and everything was delicious. Considering the Restaurant was packed, the follow up service to the tables by all the servers, for such a Young staff they showed such incredible energy and interacted with each table. Highly Recommend, best Service in a Restaurant that I have been to in ages. Shout out to the Manager on duty, he was Fabulous.

We chose Rusty's for our party of 3 as part of the fall restaurant deal where the Agora - Path of Light tickets were included. The deal included appetizer, main course and dessert. The service was excellent, food came quickly and it was very tasty and fulsome. We were in at 6 pm an out by 7:15 pm, ahead of the 8 pm Blue Jays game. It was getting really busy by then and noise level was raised, of course! We'll go back to Rusty's for sure.

Rusty's was an excellent choice not only for the food, but the servers and how electric the atmosphere was for the Jays game on every tv.

We came here as a group for a weekend vacation from Toronto and Daryl was our server. He was super kind and helpful with the recommendations but where he excelled was in the small tall department. He had a lot of fun facts about the food and was a great conversationalist.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was physically assaulted by the bouncers for absolutely no reason.. not sure if there was a mix up or what but regardless the bruises I have to prove it have been documented and will be used against Rusty’s.

Bunch of over zealous college age kid security they have here that even the village security said are causing constant issues.

Food was amazing. We did have to ask for cutlery and a glass for my beer. But over a very good experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

We had a great experience here. We ordered the platter and the brisket and were definitely not disappointed! It was cooked to perfection and it fed the 4 of us with even a bit leftover. Our server was excellent and we left very pleased. Was our second time there and if we're ever back at the mountain, we will return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent service and food. We had the Prime Rib Beef dip, the Blackened Chicken sandwich with avocado which were very good and would recommend either. The chicken had a slight bit of spice.

The Mac and Cheese was ok, nothing amazing. Small macaroni noodles, cheese wasn’t your typical, tasted like Parmesan.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Popped in for lunch over the weekend after a hike up the hill. Great service from Jeff! Will return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Seated quickly for dinner. Barely saw our server. Ordered nachos and quesadillas for the table. Nachos were loaded with lots of meat but the cheese was crispy. No plates offered as we were sharing the food. Server didn't even check in after food arrived.

Seating here is only high top tables with the exception of the patio.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

Good place for food, drinks and good vibe, restaurant turn into more of a bar with dance floor after a certain time. Music they played was a nice variety

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

$37 for three shots of tequila. Cash only. Nuff said

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 1

Menu was different then what they had posted online so we seemed a little blind sided. The waitress let us know that it recently changed, but it was too bad when you are planning a vacation to know some of the stuff you specifically went to a restaurant was not on the menu. Food was sadly dry and didn't taste the best. We did let the restaurant waitress know. Her service was fantastic.