I recently ordered a custom cake from Cake Your Way, and I have to say, I’m beyond impressed. Karen, the manager, really knocked it out of the park. From the first conversation to picking up the cake, she made sure everything was perfect. She listened to my ideas, made great suggestions, and was genuinely invested in getting it just right.
The cake itself was amazing – the flavor was spot-on, and the design was exactly what I wanted. It was clear that they put a lot of care into every detail. The cake not only looked awesome but tasted even better, with a great balance of sweetness and texture. Definitely a winner.
Huge thanks to Karen for making this such an easy and enjoyable experience. I’ll definitely be coming back for future events and highly recommend Cake Your Way to anyone who’s looking for something special!
Brianna Samuels
This is my second time going!!! Absolutely love it
FourtyFour DaDJ
Breanne was very respectful and pleasant Great smile and service
Conrad Afful-Quansah
Great service, attention to detail and most importantly, delicious cakes.
Samantha Drysdale
Amazing cakes, highly recommend them!!
Chad Jenkins
Fantastic Service!
Mansi S
Great experience to have at a baby shower! The cake and toppings were all really great and it was a cute aesthetic.
Ali Khan
Beautiful cake and it tastes so good !
Alycia Mcsween
I’ve ordered 2 cakes from here within the last month and both were amazing! The cakes were both beautiful and delicious. I’ll definitely be ordering again :)
Michelle Dar
I recently ordered a cake from Cake Your Way, and while this isn’t my first time ordering from them, it was my first issue. The cake I ordered was supposed to be light pink, but instead, it came out red. I even provided an inspiration picture, requesting it be made exactly the same. When I called to address the issue, the owner was unhelpful and responded rudely, insisting that I had selected hot pink on the website, implying it was my mistake.
While I understand that color discrepancies can happen, clear communication is key—especially for a business owner with a large following. A simple email confirmation from their end about color choices would have prevented this confusion. The owners dismissive attitude and refusal to offer any compensation, especially considering I live in Toronto and the business is in Vaughan so I have to come a long way, made the experience even more frustrating.
I won’t be returning, as her lack of professionalism and the arrogant tone ultimately cost her a loyal customer. If you plan to order a cake from here, I highly recommend specifying colours in detail and following up with an email, as the owner is not proactive in confirming details herself and communicating with her clients.
I attached pictures showing the original cake and what she gave me. Clearly these are 2 different colours.
I chose this bakery specifically because they made a beautiful Tiffany box-inspired cake for my baby shower a decade ago. I thought it would be a full-circle moment to use them for my son’s 10th birthday…
Original order included a gamer/Fortnite theme with written instructions and a few sample cake design images.
Bakery called to say I selected the wrong order type — added a $40 fee on top of the $315 I was already paying. I accepted without issue.
Five days before pickup, I emailed an updated design with an AI-generated reference and hand-picked Fortnite character cutouts my son chose himself. They confirmed the update and received everything.
None of the cutouts we provided were used. The gaming characters they included were not from Fortnite — my son noticed right away and didn’t even want them on the cake. The other cut outs were nice, but the main ones he was looking forward to were the players from Fortnite.
Each tier was supposed to be a different flavour. We cut into it and found both were red velvet. No heads-up or explanation. The cake itself was not very tasty and barely anyone ate their slice. I’m not sure if there was a sugar/syrup soak between layers but it seemed so.
Bottom tier with photos of the birthday boy was done very nicely — everyone loved that part of the design.
Pickup was scheduled for 2 PM Saturday. We arrived at 2:20 from Ajax, thinking we were late, only to be told to wait — cake wasn’t ready until 3 PM.
They weren’t rude, there was just no communication or updates about the order. Everything came as a surprise. I even called that morning to see what time it would be ready. If I had known, I could’ve arranged someone else to pick it up, especially since we had a backup cake ready. The wait caused us to arrive after guests to the party.
From the looks of it, there may have been an issue with the order details not being updated and caused them to rush to fix the design where they could.
No apology, no mention of the flavour or design mix-up, and just $10 off despite multiple issues.
As someone who used to make custom cakes, I understand the workload — but I always prioritized clear communication and doing what I could to make things right for customers on their special day.
I wasn’t planning to leave a review, but after hearing many similar stories from friends and family, I felt it was worth sharing.
Not trying to bash a small business, but the experience stung a bit. I hope this review encourages some changes.
romeika melbourne
The service here was great, the owner was super friendly and made sure that everything was good to go. I’ll give my experience a 10/10 and for the design of my cake it’s exactly how I wanted it look and taste, presentation was A+ ! Thank you guys!!
Makayla Miller
I would like to thank Desteni B for her exceptional service in accommodating me with this cake. Desteni was attentive and went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. She patiently addressed every question I had and made sure I had a seamless and enjoyable experience with this company. Not only was the service outstanding, but the cake itself tasted absolutely amazing! Thank you, Desteni, for making this such a positive and memorable experience!
Brooke Barker
My cake is absolutely beautiful! I could not have asked for a better cake! The employees were so sweet and even mentioned how they were excited to do my cake! Worth a 40 minute drive!
I recently ordered a custom cake from Cake Your Way, and I have to say, I’m beyond impressed. Karen, the manager, really knocked it out of the park. From the first conversation to picking up the cake, she made sure everything was perfect. She listened to my ideas, made great suggestions, and was genuinely invested in getting it just right.
The cake itself was amazing – the flavor was spot-on, and the design was exactly what I wanted. It was clear that they put a lot of care into every detail. The cake not only looked awesome but tasted even better, with a great balance of sweetness and texture. Definitely a winner.
Huge thanks to Karen for making this such an easy and enjoyable experience. I’ll definitely be coming back for future events and highly recommend Cake Your Way to anyone who’s looking for something special!
This is my second time going!!! Absolutely love it
Breanne was very respectful and pleasant
Great smile and service
Great service, attention to detail and most importantly, delicious cakes.
Amazing cakes, highly recommend them!!
Fantastic Service!
Great experience to have at a baby shower! The cake and toppings were all really great and it was a cute aesthetic.
Beautiful cake and it tastes so good !
I’ve ordered 2 cakes from here within the last month and both were amazing! The cakes were both beautiful and delicious. I’ll definitely be ordering again :)
I recently ordered a cake from Cake Your Way, and while this isn’t my first time ordering from them, it was my first issue. The cake I ordered was supposed to be light pink, but instead, it came out red. I even provided an inspiration picture, requesting it be made exactly the same. When I called to address the issue, the owner was unhelpful and responded rudely, insisting that I had selected hot pink on the website, implying it was my mistake.
While I understand that color discrepancies can happen, clear communication is key—especially for a business owner with a large following. A simple email confirmation from their end about color choices would have prevented this confusion. The owners dismissive attitude and refusal to offer any compensation, especially considering I live in Toronto and the business is in Vaughan so I have to come a long way, made the experience even more frustrating.
I won’t be returning, as her lack of professionalism and the arrogant tone ultimately cost her a loyal customer. If you plan to order a cake from here, I highly recommend specifying colours in detail and following up with an email, as the owner is not proactive in confirming details herself and communicating with her clients.
I attached pictures showing the original cake and what she gave me. Clearly these are 2 different colours.
Restaurantji Recommends
I chose this bakery specifically because they made a beautiful Tiffany box-inspired cake for my baby shower a decade ago. I thought it would be a full-circle moment to use them for my son’s 10th birthday…
Original order included a gamer/Fortnite theme with written instructions and a few sample cake design images.
Bakery called to say I selected the wrong order type — added a $40 fee on top of the $315 I was already paying. I accepted without issue.
Five days before pickup, I emailed an updated design with an AI-generated reference and hand-picked Fortnite character cutouts my son chose himself. They confirmed the update and received everything.
None of the cutouts we provided were used. The gaming characters they included were not from Fortnite — my son noticed right away and didn’t even want them on the cake. The other cut outs were nice, but the main ones he was looking forward to were the players from Fortnite.
Each tier was supposed to be a different flavour. We cut into it and found both were red velvet. No heads-up or explanation. The cake itself was not very tasty and barely anyone ate their slice. I’m not sure if there was a sugar/syrup soak between layers but it seemed so.
Bottom tier with photos of the birthday boy was done very nicely — everyone loved that part of the design.
Pickup was scheduled for 2 PM Saturday. We arrived at 2:20 from Ajax, thinking we were late, only to be told to wait — cake wasn’t ready until 3 PM.
They weren’t rude, there was just no communication or updates about the order. Everything came as a surprise. I even called that morning to see what time it would be ready. If I had known, I could’ve arranged someone else to pick it up, especially since we had a backup cake ready. The wait caused us to arrive after guests to the party.
From the looks of it, there may have been an issue with the order details not being updated and caused them to rush to fix the design where they could.
No apology, no mention of the flavour or design mix-up, and just $10 off despite multiple issues.
As someone who used to make custom cakes, I understand the workload — but I always prioritized clear communication and doing what I could to make things right for customers on their special day.
I wasn’t planning to leave a review, but after hearing many similar stories from friends and family, I felt it was worth sharing.
Not trying to bash a small business, but the experience stung a bit. I hope this review encourages some changes.
The service here was great, the owner was super friendly and made sure that everything was good to go. I’ll give my experience a 10/10 and for the design of my cake it’s exactly how I wanted it look and taste, presentation was A+ ! Thank you guys!!
I would like to thank Desteni B for her exceptional service in accommodating me with this cake. Desteni was attentive and went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. She patiently addressed every question I had and made sure I had a seamless and enjoyable experience with this company. Not only was the service outstanding, but the cake itself tasted absolutely amazing! Thank you, Desteni, for making this such a positive and memorable experience!
My cake is absolutely beautiful! I could not have asked for a better cake! The employees were so sweet and even mentioned how they were excited to do my cake! Worth a 40 minute drive!
Best cake in the GTA.
Loading...