Godfathers Pizza - Walkerton

I ordered a panzerotti with peppers onions pineapple pepperoni the only thing they put on was pepperoni.. SO NOT IMPRESSED

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Had an awesome experience at Godfathera Pizza today. Marg was fantastic — her attention to detail really shows, and you can taste the care she puts into every pizza. Her attitude is warm, upbeat, and welcoming, and she made the whole visit feel genuinely personal. Truly made-with-love pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Marge makes a lovely pizza

Never coming back, pizza was cold also hair in my pizza and a lot of it……nasty!! Very rude customer service also, not very welcoming to say the least

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

A great slice. My wife thinks the pepperoni is too spicy, but I'm really tough, so it's no problem for someone like me. Also, they have Dr Pepper.

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Caesar Salad

Last night I stopped in for pizza while visiting family. I’m originally from Waterloo, and I just have to say the staff were absolutely wonderful. The two young women working were welcoming, attentive, and really made the experience enjoyable. On top of that, the pizza itself was excellent!

That said, I was very surprised and disappointed when I went to tip. I looked for the option on the payment machine, but when I asked, the staff explained that tips aren’t available through the terminal. In today’s world, very few people carry cash, which means those employees are likely missing out on well-deserved gratuities simply because of a system limitation.

As someone who owns a restaurant in Waterloo, I can say firsthand that tips are not just extra. They’re a vital part of supporting and motivating staff, especially younger workers. For many, it’s spending money that rewards their hard work and provides encouragement to deliver great service. Without an accessible option to tip digitally, you’re not only reducing the earning potential of your team, but also creating a less satisfying guest experience for customers who want to show their appreciation.

Adding a tipping feature on the payment machine would be a small change with a huge impact. It ensures staff are fairly rewarded, it encourages excellent service, and it shows that the business values both its employees and its customers’ experience. With such fantastic staff already in place, it seems only right that they should have the opportunity to benefit fully from the service they provide.

Awesome pizza. You want be disappointed

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

10 Years ago I probably would have given Godfathers 5 stars but now, what was once the best Pizza Shop in Walkerton has really gone down hill.

The quality of their slices is really disappointing. Almost every time I've gone in to grab a slice they have been sitting there for too long and the worst part is I got them at the time of day when they should be at the freshest.

Godfathers has been a staple of Downtown Walkerton for over 30 years so Its really disappointing to see (or taste) how bland it has become.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

We had an excellent experience here. The staff were extremely kind when they were running a couple minutes behind with our order and went above and beyond to ensure we had a good experience. And our panzerotti’s were delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Panzerotti Up To

I love seeing the twins when I come in they’re always so friendly and welcoming. Whenever I order pizzas, they somehow find me the best deal, and I really appreciate it, they also make the best pizza. They’re always smiling, laughing, and joking around, and it honestly makes my day every time I see them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cassie, Lauren and Shaelyn always professional, friendly service on a sweltering summer evening! Thanks for the great service and tasty pizza!

Great tasting pizza, great value
Staff is amazing, very friendly and helpful

It's always a nice experience to get a slice to go from godfathers

Just wanted to say how amazing the Lady that was working today at godfathers at 230 pm (sorry I didn't catch your name) But you did an amazing job holding it together after some rude person before me berated her for working alone and not having the type of pizza slice this lady wanted.

You are great at your job and I wanted you to know that. Don't take it personal when others are rude.
The pizza combo I ordered was hot and ready to go, not to mention you were very pleasant to chat with.