Ordered a last minute birthday cake for my son. The cheesecake was amazing. Also, the service was great. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erika Lindey
This is the only place I will go to for my baked goods! Caitlin and staff are always so kind and accomodating! Always great to see their smiles. And they can always hit my cravings with their awesome recommendations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Cheesecakes
imanotandkids
Dietary restrictions: Fabulous cheesecakes that accommodate dietary restrictions
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Cheesecakes
Allison Russell
We ordered cupcake cheesecakes for our backyard wedding. Caitlin was quick to respond and very accommodating for our various dietary needs. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed the various cheesecake flavours, and we will definitely be coming back to enjoy more cupcake cheesecakes in the future. Thank you, Mama Misfit's, for helping create our perfect wedding day!
Danielle Ulch
Caitlin is an absolute sweetheart. The cheesecakes are always delicious and I finally got to try the no bake cheesecake for my birthday! It was delicious and had a chocolate covered strawberry inside.
Wooseok Oh
The Red Velvet Cake is the best cake ever
Regina George
Cheesecakes are amazing.
The Angler Files
Great little cheescakes
Mitzy Katz
Was trying very hard to find a bakery that would do a small cheesecake to surprise relatives with for their 20th anniversary (their wedding cake, years ago, had been a cheesecake) and Mama Misfit's came through like a dream! Not only did they craft a beautiful 2-layer cake with flowers that like a modern-mini version of the original cake... they did so in two delicious flavours (butter tart and Oreo).The cake was a HUGE hit and was declared to be even more delicious than it was beautiful (not too dense, not too light, not too sweet - and very flavourful).Thank you, Mama Misfit's, for making a special day that much more special!(1st pic is close-up of cake; 2nd pic features hands for size comparison - perfect for a couple to share with some leftovers!)
Veronica Last
Cheesecakes in any size are perfection. Google has incorrect information re open hours, and the phone number doesn't connect anywhere
Had an exceptional experience when ordering for a friends birthday! And the taste will blow you away ?
tori davis
These are the absolute best cheese cakes I've ever had.
Allison Mondloch
We ordered cupcake cheesecakes for our backyard wedding. Caitlin was quick to respond and very accommodating for our various dietary needs. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed the various cheesecake flavours, and we will definitely be coming back to enjoy more cupcake cheesecakes in the future. Thank you, Mama Misfit's, for helping create our perfect wedding day!
Kendra Anton
I placed an order over Facebook as I do not live in welland but wanted to send my dad something he loves for Father’s Day!! She was quick to respond and so helpful! Thank you so much!
Ordered a last minute birthday cake for my son. The cheesecake was amazing. Also, the service was great. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the only place I will go to for my baked goods! Caitlin and staff are always so kind and accomodating! Always great to see their smiles. And they can always hit my cravings with their awesome recommendations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Cheesecakes
Dietary restrictions: Fabulous cheesecakes that accommodate dietary restrictions
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcake Cheesecakes
We ordered cupcake cheesecakes for our backyard wedding. Caitlin was quick to respond and very accommodating for our various dietary needs. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed the various cheesecake flavours, and we will definitely be coming back to enjoy more cupcake cheesecakes in the future. Thank you, Mama Misfit's, for helping create our perfect wedding day!
Caitlin is an absolute sweetheart. The cheesecakes are always delicious and I finally got to try the no bake cheesecake for my birthday! It was delicious and had a chocolate covered strawberry inside.
The Red Velvet Cake is the best cake ever
Cheesecakes are amazing.
Great little cheescakes
Was trying very hard to find a bakery that would do a small cheesecake to surprise relatives with for their 20th anniversary (their wedding cake, years ago, had been a cheesecake) and Mama Misfit's came through like a dream! Not only did they craft a beautiful 2-layer cake with flowers that like a modern-mini version of the original cake... they did so in two delicious flavours (butter tart and Oreo).The cake was a HUGE hit and was declared to be even more delicious than it was beautiful (not too dense, not too light, not too sweet - and very flavourful).Thank you, Mama Misfit's, for making a special day that much more special!(1st pic is close-up of cake; 2nd pic features hands for size comparison - perfect for a couple to share with some leftovers!)
Cheesecakes in any size are perfection. Google has incorrect information re open hours, and the phone number doesn't connect anywhere
Restaurantji Recommends
Had an exceptional experience when ordering for a friends birthday! And the taste will blow you away ?
These are the absolute best cheese cakes I've ever had.
We ordered cupcake cheesecakes for our backyard wedding. Caitlin was quick to respond and very accommodating for our various dietary needs. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed the various cheesecake flavours, and we will definitely be coming back to enjoy more cupcake cheesecakes in the future. Thank you, Mama Misfit's, for helping create our perfect wedding day!
I placed an order over Facebook as I do not live in welland but wanted to send my dad something he loves for Father’s Day!! She was quick to respond and so helpful! Thank you so much!
Always great service and delicious cheese cake.
Loading...