Michael Kelly's
$ • American
Hours:
93 Winchester Rd E, Whitby
(905) 655-5525
About Michael Kelly's
Customers' Favorites
Michael Kelly's Reviews
Share your opinion about Michael Kelly's
Our new go-to spot!
This place is absolutely fantastic! The farmboy pizza and chicken tenders were a hit with the whole family—our toddlers loved them. The pizza tasted fresh and homemade, and my husband couldn’t stop raving about the butter tarts. Great food, friendly service, and perfect for families. We’ll definitely be coming back!
Tonight we ordered the bruschetta bread and a large farmboy pizza and I can honestly say it was the best bruschetta and pizza I’ve ever had in my life well worth the visit!!!!!
Home cooked food. One of the last “greasy spoons” around. They should be on “You gotta eat here!” Love this place!
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 8PM |
Michael Kelly's is a highly recommended restaurant that has maintained its quality over the years. The service is friendly and fast, with prices considered decent in today's market. The food is delicious and nostalgic, with recipes remaining largely unchanged. The restaurant offers a variety of dishes for all meals, including breakfast, and is a popular spot for families and regular customers. Recent reviews highlight the farmboy pizza and chicken tenders, which are favorites among families and toddlers. The pizza is noted for being hot, fresh, and with a delicious crust, bringing back memories of authentic Chicago-style pizza. The crust is thin and perfectly cooked, not doughy, with hand-cut veggies, real pepperoni, and bacon. The butter tarts are tasty and not too sweet, and the pecan tarts are baked to perfection with a rich, buttery filling. The ‘house combo’ pizza is also praised for its crispy crust and great taste. Although the dining room appears a bit dated, the warm and friendly service, along with the genuine care from the owner, makes for a pleasant experience. The restaurant continues to be a go-to place for good food and a friendly atmosphere, with many customers planning to return and try other menu items.