take out of large mushroom pepperoni pizza great pizza from crust to toppings very good
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mark
We ordered for delivery tonight. 3 small dried up burgers arrived and a pizza I can't comment on because they completely forgot it. We love supporting local businesses but this is one we'll never order from again. I heard it's under new ownership which probably explains all the good reviews from the past and the awful ones recently.
Food: 1
Tara Fairservice
First time eating here and it won’t be the last. Everything was homemade and tasted delicious. My partner couldn’t stop talking about the French onion soup. We had an order of garlic bread with cheese and it was humungous and so tasty. My four year-old had the kids burger and fries and she said it was the best burger she ever had. My partner had a pizza and said it was delicious. I had a chicken clubhouse and there was so much chicken and bacon on it. It was fabulous. The portions are huge. We all had some to take home. We had to try the butter tarts too, so we took them home and they are delicious as well. The service was exceptional. The owner was so friendly and attentive. Haven’t had better service! Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danielle Grace
After reading nothing but positive reviews about Michael Kelly's, today we decided to try it out!
We were greeted by a lovely family in a warm and welcoming environment. Our orders were taken promptly and our meals met all expectations we’ve been hearing about!
My boyfriend and I split a mini Farm Boy pizza and we each ordered a wrap with sweet potato fries. Our food was absolutely delicious and I have more than enough leftover for lunch tomorrow!
Excellent food, service and such a wonderful family who consistently catered to our needs during our visit. I would return for another pizza tomorrow, but unfortunately they’re closed on Mondays! 🤣🤣
If you haven’t tried, you are sadly missing out! We will be back very soon, thank you again for the amazing service!🤍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul O'Hagan
Fast, friendly and fresh. Amazing home cooked food.
Zubair Mohammed Iftekhar
We came across Michael Kelly’s after seeing it highly recommended in a local foodie Facebook group as one of the best pizza spots near Oshawa, located in Brooklyn. Naturally, we had to give it a try, we ordered delivery!
We ordered two build-your-own extra large pizzas, one plain cheese pizza and another topped with feta cheese. Both were absolutely excellent. The crust was perfectly baked, crisp yet soft, and the cheese had that rich, satisfying flavor that you expect from a high quality pizzeria. It definitely lived up to its reputation.
My wife and kids loved it too, it was one of those meals where everyone was happy, which says a lot!
I didn’t try any of the meat toppings because I wasn’t sure of they are halal, and I know many customers in the area would appreciate that clarification. It would be a big plus and make the menu more inclusive for everyone if they have halal food.
All in all, Michael Kelly’s truly delivers when it comes to authentic, flavorful pizza. It’s a great family friendly spot, and we’ll definitely be returning for more of their delicious, fresh made pies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
DARLENE WOODWARD
Had the Swiss Mushroom Burgers for take-out!! Cheesy, saucy perfection. A must try!! Service was exceptional- so friendly.
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Bigelstein
The best pizza I have ever eaten in my life . Steve the Pizza Chef is a brilliant CHEF The Greek Salad was fresh and exceptional fantastic . The Bruschetta was magnificent and better than the ones I ate in Italy .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anonymous
Our little one wanted to try their chicken nuggets for her birthday. Showed up at 5:25 PM on a Tuesday when they're supposedly open. Door was locked no one inside. Very unprofessional.
Dan Horton
Have been eating at this restaurant for years. New owners now... Had a very bad experience recently and I will not be going back. Too bad, as it was such a nice family restaurant before new ownership took over. Examples of concern: Was told my kids could have kid menu portions of regular menu meals, then being charged for the full adult menu price. Charged more for a meal than what was listed on menu. Topped up half full wine glasses and then charged for another full glass of wine. Side note, waiter on this occasion was overly handsy with my children, making us all feel very uncomfortable and wanting to leave asap. Can't see this place lasting long with these unprofessional business practices.
Had heard good things about this restaurant. Went for brunch i had the Greek omelet which was good but my toast had mold the owners did comp my meal. Washroom was dirty and tables were sticky. Disappointed
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
Brian Wonnacott
I am devastated to learn this place has been sold. I worked here as a teenager and even had the 'Farmboy' pizza named after me. Their pizza was the absolute best by far, simply amazing. This week I travelled from out of province to visit family here and ordered some pizzas to go. They were nothing like it used to be. Toppings were skimpy, barely any sauce and lacked taste. So disappointing, does not compare to original Michael Kelly's. Not that I have given much business since I've moved away, but I will not be back. To the former owners - your absence is wildly apparent.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Alex Monterrubio
Seems like a new owner, and not for the better. We stopped by while biking, looking for a quick refreshment. The place smelled like humidity, dark, not a nice place for me to stay, but the new owner (I assume) was overly eager, greeting us and inviting us in a bit too insistently for my taste.
He didn’t offer a menu, just listed three bottled beer brands when we asked. We each took one and stayed for a short while, but he kept pushing us to stay longer. Personally, I prefer a more laid-back atmosphere.
We paid $18.99 for two bottles of beer, which sealed the deal for us. Last time visiting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Julio Villavicencio
The pizza here is absolutely incredible—it brings back memories of the authentic Chicago-style pizza I enjoyed while living in the U.S. I highly recommend giving it a try! We went again and we met the owner, Amin, who was very chatty and a very nice person, especially with the kids. We will definitely keep going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charan Singh
Had a lovely first visit at the restaurant with my family
take out of large mushroom pepperoni pizza great pizza from crust to toppings very good
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
We ordered for delivery tonight. 3 small dried up burgers arrived and a pizza I can't comment on because they completely forgot it. We love supporting local businesses but this is one we'll never order from again. I heard it's under new ownership which probably explains all the good reviews from the past and the awful ones recently.
Food: 1
First time eating here and it won’t be the last. Everything was homemade and tasted delicious. My partner couldn’t stop talking about the French onion soup. We had an order of garlic bread with cheese and it was humungous and so tasty. My four year-old had the kids burger and fries and she said it was the best burger she ever had. My partner had a pizza and said it was delicious. I had a chicken clubhouse and there was so much chicken and bacon on it. It was fabulous. The portions are huge. We all had some to take home. We had to try the butter tarts too, so we took them home and they are delicious as well. The service was exceptional. The owner was so friendly and attentive. Haven’t had better service! Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After reading nothing but positive reviews about Michael Kelly's, today we decided to try it out!
We were greeted by a lovely family in a warm and welcoming environment. Our orders were taken promptly and our meals met all expectations we’ve been hearing about!
My boyfriend and I split a mini Farm Boy pizza and we each ordered a wrap with sweet potato fries. Our food was absolutely delicious and I have more than enough leftover for lunch tomorrow!
Excellent food, service and such a wonderful family who consistently catered to our needs during our visit. I would return for another pizza tomorrow, but unfortunately they’re closed on Mondays! 🤣🤣
If you haven’t tried, you are sadly missing out! We will be back very soon, thank you again for the amazing service!🤍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fast, friendly and fresh. Amazing home cooked food.
We came across Michael Kelly’s after seeing it highly recommended in a local foodie Facebook group as one of the best pizza spots near Oshawa, located in Brooklyn. Naturally, we had to give it a try, we ordered delivery!
We ordered two build-your-own extra large pizzas, one plain cheese pizza and another topped with feta cheese. Both were absolutely excellent. The crust was perfectly baked, crisp yet soft, and the cheese had that rich, satisfying flavor that you expect from a high quality pizzeria. It definitely lived up to its reputation.
My wife and kids loved it too, it was one of those meals where everyone was happy, which says a lot!
I didn’t try any of the meat toppings because I wasn’t sure of they are halal, and I know many customers in the area would appreciate that clarification. It would be a big plus and make the menu more inclusive for everyone if they have halal food.
All in all, Michael Kelly’s truly delivers when it comes to authentic, flavorful pizza. It’s a great family friendly spot, and we’ll definitely be returning for more of their delicious, fresh made pies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Had the Swiss Mushroom Burgers for take-out!! Cheesy, saucy perfection. A must try!! Service was exceptional- so friendly.
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza I have ever eaten in my life .
Steve the Pizza Chef is a brilliant CHEF
The Greek Salad was fresh and exceptional fantastic . The Bruschetta was magnificent and better than the ones I ate in Italy .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our little one wanted to try their chicken nuggets for her birthday. Showed up at 5:25 PM on a Tuesday when they're supposedly open. Door was locked no one inside. Very unprofessional.
Have been eating at this restaurant for years. New owners now... Had a very bad experience recently and I will not be going back. Too bad, as it was such a nice family restaurant before new ownership took over. Examples of concern: Was told my kids could have kid menu portions of regular menu meals, then being charged for the full adult menu price. Charged more for a meal than what was listed on menu. Topped up half full wine glasses and then charged for another full glass of wine. Side note, waiter on this occasion was overly handsy with my children, making us all feel very uncomfortable and wanting to leave asap. Can't see this place lasting long with these unprofessional business practices.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Had heard good things about this restaurant. Went for brunch i had the Greek omelet which was good but my toast had mold the owners did comp my meal. Washroom was dirty and tables were sticky. Disappointed
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4
I am devastated to learn this place has been sold. I worked here as a teenager and even had the 'Farmboy' pizza named after me.
Their pizza was the absolute best by far, simply amazing.
This week I travelled from out of province to visit family here and ordered some pizzas to go. They were nothing like it used to be. Toppings were skimpy, barely any sauce and lacked taste. So disappointing, does not compare to original Michael Kelly's.
Not that I have given much business since I've moved away, but I will not be back.
To the former owners - your absence is wildly apparent.
Food: 1
Service: 4
Seems like a new owner, and not for the better.
We stopped by while biking, looking for a quick refreshment. The place smelled like humidity, dark, not a nice place for me to stay, but the new owner (I assume) was overly eager, greeting us and inviting us in a bit too insistently for my taste.
He didn’t offer a menu, just listed three bottled beer brands when we asked. We each took one and stayed for a short while, but he kept pushing us to stay longer. Personally, I prefer a more laid-back atmosphere.
We paid $18.99 for two bottles of beer, which sealed the deal for us. Last time visiting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
The pizza here is absolutely incredible—it brings back memories of the authentic Chicago-style pizza I enjoyed while living in the U.S. I highly recommend giving it a try!
We went again and we met the owner, Amin, who was very chatty and a very nice person, especially with the kids. We will definitely keep going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a lovely first visit at the restaurant with my family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...