Beloved Cheesecakes

Have had a visit on my list for a while and finally made it in! Shared slices and coffee with family and everything was delicious. Nice place to visit with folks on a rainy fall afternoon.

Delicious flavors. I love the option to try a few flavors at the same time. Key lime was the best!

I love coming to beloved cheesecakes! The environment is so friendly and the cheesecake is top tier! I would recommend all the flavors but especially the chocolate and the seasonal pumpkin flavor!!! Definitely come check them out!

Wonderful service and cheesecake delicious. Great place to have a dessert.

Love the vibe! Great service and Vantastic cheesecake!

I ordered 4 of the mini's online and received them the other day....well packed and cold. I started off with the New York style because I've always felt if you can't do that right you have no business doing any others....well they hit it out of the park. Fluffy and creamy floating in my mouth making my taste buds very happy. The next day I had the chocolate flavored one, very tasty. Today was the Key Lime and from the first bite it's my favorite. Salted Carmel is tomorrow but I decided not to wait to sing my praise of this place.

In a way I'm glad I don't live near to either of their physical shops so I'm limited to ordering online and planning ahead...I don't have the best self-control for taste treats. I will be ordering from them again for special occasions...they're not cheap but good things are worth paying for...I'll always take quality over quantity.

I recently had the pleasure of indulging in a New York cheesecake from Beloved Cheesecake, and as native New Yorker, I can confidently say this is one of the best cheesecakes I’ve ever tasted. The texture was pure perfection—creamy, rich, and velvety smooth, with that signature dense yet melt-in-your-mouth quality that defines an authentic NY cheesecake. The graham cracker crust added just the right amount of buttery crunch, complementing the tangy-sweet filling that was nothing short of heavenly. Every bite felt like a love letter to classic New York dessert tradition, elevated to a whole new level.
What truly sets Beloved Cheesecake apart, though, is their outstanding customer service. From the moment I placed my order, the team was warm, attentive, and genuinely passionate about their craft. You can tell they pour their heart into every cheesecake they make, and their kindness made the experience even sweeter. Whether it was answering my questions or ensuring the delivery arrived perfectly, their care and authenticity shone through.
This cheesecake isn’t just dessert—it’s an out-of-this-world experience that I’ll be dreaming about until my next order. If you’re looking for a true NY cheesecake that hits all the right notes, Beloved Cheesecake is the place to go. Highly recommend!

The white chocolate raspberry slice was a standout—creamy, perfectly balanced, with a rich white chocolate flavor and a burst of tangy raspberry. Each bite was pure heaven! The assortment looks stunning, and we’re already excited to dive into the other flavors. The texture is spot-on, and the quality is top-notch. Can’t wait to try the rest—highly recommend this treat for any cheesecake lover!

We stopped in for a treat at the end of our date night and it was perfect! They had lots of flavors to chose from. The service was amazing, too! We also enjoyed the Christian music and the details of the vintage building.

I ordered the white chocolate raspberry cheesecake, and it was delicious. It's probably the best cheesecake that I've had. I know that I will be ordering again. I told my family, and friends about Beloved Cheesecakes. The customer service is excellent. I would highly recommend Beloved Cheesecakes, you will not be disappointed.

My sister and I came on a day out and decided to try them, I got a salted Carmel and my sister got a white chocolate raspberry, both tasted absolutely amazing, I only got a picture of mine cause my sister ate hers so fast

I ordered a four-selection sampler cheesecake (key lime, chocolate, salted caramel, and marionberry) to ship in-state. It arrived two days after the ship date, immaculately packaged, with great instructions and a sweet handwritten thank-you note. (We also got a personal thank-you call). We shared the cheesecake at a dinner gathering, and it was a HIT! The salted caramel was the favorite, but each one was delicious. Highly highly recommend!

Omg the best place!!! I love the vibe and the best customer service

I ordered the chocolate cheesecake with shipping to Wisconsin. First of all, the customer service was excellent. The cheesecake arrived in great condition and is rich and delicious. Highly recommend.

My first time having Beloved Cheesecake and it did not disappoint. Fantastic pumpkin cheesecake and breve latte!

Excellent customer service — everyone is very friendly and professional. And the cheesecake was absolutely delicious!

I also appreciate that this business operates with such strong ethics.

Thanks! I am on the other side of the U.S. but will order again. Highly recommend!