Soggy pizza 2times now barley can eat pizza second time I learned my lesson never going back. Watery tomato sauce too sweet no taste really.
Ron King
Great things about Maria Bella: their famous Brooklyn Pizza comes in only a large and is amazing to eat. The owner and staff were very friendly and engaging. Quaint and quiet atmosphere. Would recommend traveling any distance to eat there!! Listen...if you have to break a few traffic laws to get there it is worth the effort..You just gotta eat here.
John Kemler, Jr
Cute, clean inside sitting area. Looked very nice! Mot sticks were AH-MAZING! Pizza was good. Smelled garlic-y before I even opened the box. Don't let that deter you though if you don't like garlic. It was not overwhelming in the slightest. I definitely want to explore their other menu options.
Christopher Krause
I stumbled on the place by accident. I was trying to find a specific place to eat and got lost. I have never been so happy to have missed my turn. The staff at Bella Maria was an absolute delight. They were kind enough to guide me to a delicious lunch option for my picky child and gave me my first cheesesteak experience. They are also just enjoyable to have a conversation with. My cheesesteak was absolutely delicious with perfectly seasoned meat and a proportional amount of wiz. I actually ate the first half before I remembered to grab a picture for the review. My sons chicken tenders were different from the typical zaxbys style tender most are accustomed to. The very flavorful but light breading still managed to provide a delightful crisp with each bite. I have a feeling anything eaten from this restaurant will provide an equivalent experience. Try anything here, I bet you will be glad you did. For my son I got the tenders and fries kids meal, and for myself I got the steak with cheese. I am ready to try the tomato pie and pizza steak next time. I haven't reviewed a place in 2 years, and almost never fo anyways. This one deserved it.
Amanda McDonald
The BEST pizza in B-town and our go-to spot at least 2-3 times / month. And Ashley is the sweetest waitress / counter person / jack of all trades out there. She’s great with my kids and always has a smile on her face. If you haven’t tried them yet you are missing out!
Matthew Lyons
Bella Maria is awesome! I had a big order to pick up, and was a few minutes early. The manager told me the pizzas were still in the oven understandably. When the order was ready he told me to grab a soda on the house, and had one of his employees help me with getting the order out to my car. Everyone enjoyed the pizza, onion rings and fries as well! If I ever have an event in that area again, I will definitely order from here again!
Mike C
Tomato pie was very good. Place is a bit cold inside. No pasta due to supply chain issues. Seemed like they are short staffed. Will order take out next time. Everything on menu looks good. Service was excellent.
Timothy M.
If you don't fall in love immediately with any of their pizzas. You don't have the taste buds for judging pizza. I'm a connoisseur when it comes to this exact food group. Rest assured you will immediately fall in love from the first bite to the crispy last bite of the crust.
Doris Scott
I've been reading all the glowing reviews about Bella Maria - so decided to give it a try. The Brooklyn Pie was a delight - lots of flavorful tomato on a tasty crust. It reminded me so much of pies I enjoyed for years at a place in NJ's Columbus Market called Kate & Al's. The scent of Bella Marie's pie was enticing & the flavor delicious. So happy this treat is now available locally.
Kyle Mohney
My girlfriend says this pizza is so good it makes her wanna be a better person ?10/10 this place
Great customer service, friendly staff, and the best pizza all around
Bianca Crespo
The best pizza in the area. It reminds me of my stay in Italy years ago: the freshest ingredients (Brooklyn style Sicilian pan pictured here) with the most flavorful sauce, and perfect crust. With a kind, and diligent, owner who truly cares about his business: high quality that is unmatched. Look no further for your weekend pie!
Chip Mcbride
My woman thinks there's too much sugar in the sauce. So she has more credibility with pizza sauce that I do because she's more Italian than I am. But I thought it was okay.
Frankie Bauza
Has to be one of the best pizzas I ever tasted in my life it's worth every bite the best you want good pizza get tomato pie the best
Arielle Sarah
The dough is unbelievable! First time and my new favorite spot! If you want authentic Italian food please check this place out. You won’t be disappointed.
Soggy pizza 2times now barley can eat pizza second time I learned my lesson never going back. Watery tomato sauce too sweet no taste really.
Great things about Maria Bella: their famous Brooklyn Pizza comes in only a large and is amazing to eat. The owner and staff were very friendly and engaging. Quaint and quiet atmosphere. Would recommend traveling any distance to eat there!! Listen...if you have to break a few traffic laws to get there it is worth the effort..You just gotta eat here.
Cute, clean inside sitting area. Looked very nice! Mot sticks were AH-MAZING! Pizza was good. Smelled garlic-y before I even opened the box. Don't let that deter you though if you don't like garlic. It was not overwhelming in the slightest. I definitely want to explore their other menu options.
I stumbled on the place by accident. I was trying to find a specific place to eat and got lost. I have never been so happy to have missed my turn. The staff at Bella Maria was an absolute delight. They were kind enough to guide me to a delicious lunch option for my picky child and gave me my first cheesesteak experience. They are also just enjoyable to have a conversation with. My cheesesteak was absolutely delicious with perfectly seasoned meat and a proportional amount of wiz. I actually ate the first half before I remembered to grab a picture for the review. My sons chicken tenders were different from the typical zaxbys style tender most are accustomed to. The very flavorful but light breading still managed to provide a delightful crisp with each bite. I have a feeling anything eaten from this restaurant will provide an equivalent experience. Try anything here, I bet you will be glad you did. For my son I got the tenders and fries kids meal, and for myself I got the steak with cheese. I am ready to try the tomato pie and pizza steak next time. I haven't reviewed a place in 2 years, and almost never fo anyways. This one deserved it.
The BEST pizza in B-town and our go-to spot at least 2-3 times / month. And Ashley is the sweetest waitress / counter person / jack of all trades out there. She’s great with my kids and always has a smile on her face. If you haven’t tried them yet you are missing out!
Bella Maria is awesome! I had a big order to pick up, and was a few minutes early. The manager told me the pizzas were still in the oven understandably. When the order was ready he told me to grab a soda on the house, and had one of his employees help me with getting the order out to my car. Everyone enjoyed the pizza, onion rings and fries as well! If I ever have an event in that area again, I will definitely order from here again!
Tomato pie was very good. Place is a bit cold inside. No pasta due to supply chain issues. Seemed like they are short staffed. Will order take out next time. Everything on menu looks good. Service was excellent.
If you don't fall in love immediately with any of their pizzas. You don't have the taste buds for judging pizza. I'm a connoisseur when it comes to this exact food group. Rest assured you will immediately fall in love from the first bite to the crispy last bite of the crust.
I've been reading all the glowing reviews about Bella Maria - so decided to give it a try. The Brooklyn Pie was a delight - lots of flavorful tomato on a tasty crust. It reminded me so much of pies I enjoyed for years at a place in NJ's Columbus Market called Kate & Al's. The scent of Bella Marie's pie was enticing & the flavor delicious. So happy this treat is now available locally.
My girlfriend says this pizza is so good it makes her wanna be a better person ?10/10 this place
Restaurantji Recommends
Great customer service, friendly staff, and the best pizza all around
The best pizza in the area. It reminds me of my stay in Italy years ago: the freshest ingredients (Brooklyn style Sicilian pan pictured here) with the most flavorful sauce, and perfect crust. With a kind, and diligent, owner who truly cares about his business: high quality that is unmatched. Look no further for your weekend pie!
My woman thinks there's too much sugar in the sauce. So she has more credibility with pizza sauce that I do because she's more Italian than I am. But I thought it was okay.
Has to be one of the best pizzas I ever tasted in my life it's worth every bite the best you want good pizza get tomato pie the best
The dough is unbelievable! First time and my new favorite spot! If you want authentic Italian food please check this place out. You won’t be disappointed.