Blue Marsh Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Great food and friendly service.

Very overpriced for the food quality

Got a meat lovers Sicilian on June 6th 2025 for pickup. Pizza crust was supper burnt and rock hard. Looked like it was left in too long. I'm not a picky person but it was barely edible.

The reviews were pretty great. I guess my fault for ordering a cheesteak stromboli. Just awful.

We had our son's wedding rehearsal dinner here in their side room. The food and service were so excellent. It was a real pleasure working with them to make this evening an amazing start to our son and now daughter in laws special weekend. Thank you Blue Marsh Canteen for a wonderful evening! Your staff was excellent and the food got all rave reviews from our guests, many of whom were from out of our area. We are thankful you are so close and we can come again any time! Cheers!!
Jan and Keith

Very tasty food. Excellent service. Will return!

First time here, and the food was amazing. Our server was spot on, and we didn't have to wait on anything. I felt very comfortable and welcome there. Definitely will be going back.

AMAZING food and PHENOMENAL SERVICE! Whole baseball team and family came and we were treated so well and service was awesome for so many people. Great stromboli and loaded fries.

We had my daughters baby shower there in the side room .. Gino and his crew were top notch from the very beginning! Very friendly and accommodating to our every need ! And Macy was an amazing waitress! Definitely would recommend to have a small gathering there any day !

I came here for my 60th birthday before going to Koziar's Christmas Village. I had the Seafood Pasta with Alfredo sauce. This was one of the best meals I've had out in a very long time. Everyone's food was delicious. I highly recommend.

Have a friend visiting from out of town and chose this place because close to his hotel. The food was wonderful . Served quickly and hot. We enjoyed it so much went back the next night also. Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball

Stopped during a break at a big show tournament. Quick friendly service. I got a Chicken Parm sandwich which was great and above average for the area. Fries were good and I'd say average for the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I've eaten here one time, but I've gotten take-out numerous times. The food is always great and ready to go when they say it will be. The staff is always friendly. The pizza is always especially great, my personal favorite is their grandma's pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

I’m new to the area and am gluten free, (but not celiac). Let me tell you, they have the MOST amazing gluten free pizza I’ve had. I’ve had it several times now, so I know it’s a reliable go to. The rest of my family loves everything they’ve ever gotten from there. The portions are large, it’s always hot and fresh even when delivered. I can’t wait to try the other gf items, I’ve just been so excited to finally have good pizza after 8 years!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Piccata, Cheesesteak

It was a great lunch with a longtime friend visiting from

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5