I’ve been a loyal customer of this location for over 20 years, and for most of that time I could confidently say it was the best pizza I’d ever had. The thin, crisp crust, the perfect sauce flavor, and just the right amount of cheese — everything always came together perfectly.
However, in the past 3–6 months, something seems to have changed. The sauce has become watery, and the crust feels heavier and more doughy than before. The slices don’t hold up the way they used to, making them harder to eat fresh and even tougher to reheat later. At first, I thought it might have been a one-time issue, but after about nine orders recently, it seems to be consistent.
I truly hope this is something that can be fixed, because this place has been a staple in my life for decades, and when it’s at its best, it really is the greatest pizza in the world. I’d love to see it return to the quality that made me a lifelong fan.
Bev Bull
Fantastic pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Nick Sobotor
The best in the area, by far.
Matty Bee
I arrived at 12:30. I was greated by a less then enthusiastic woman at the desk, I ordered my pizza and I was informed it would be 1/2 hour, which is OK. I wait for a soggy non cooked pizza. That was prepared by a women that didn't care. FYI have been going there for 25 yrs....let the inmates run the Asylum..see what you get. P.s. Best pizza in NEPA Just not when she is left in charge.....
Shane Hildebrand
Great pizza and they accommodate my special needs child very well!
Mark Williams
They only sell pizzas here. Not sure if it's by the slice or by the pie only. Taste like pizza from my childhood. I got half cheese and half pepperoni. It was greasy! It came out hot and fresh though.
Todd Mengel
I live out of the area and it was my first time visiting Stuccio’s. The pizza was amazing! Terrific crust and sauce! Definitely unique and I will gladly stop there any time I am in the area.
Peter D'Ambrosio
One of the best if not the best pizza in the area. Thick crust plus sausage is the way to go.
AaronSamson
Berwick has so many great pizzerias. I grew up on Tuzzis and Dalos but always keep coming back to Stuccios. Magnificent undercarriage. Anchovies 4 life!
Kelly Rebarchak
We always have to pay for extra sauce because there's not much on a regular pizza. Crust is tough, not like it used to be. Worst part is the service. Two girls working on Saturday afternoon were rude, like they didn't want to be there and not grateful for customers. Kept placing callers on hold, but not really busy.
I’ve been a loyal customer of this location for over 20 years, and for most of that time I could confidently say it was the best pizza I’d ever had. The thin, crisp crust, the perfect sauce flavor, and just the right amount of cheese — everything always came together perfectly.
However, in the past 3–6 months, something seems to have changed. The sauce has become watery, and the crust feels heavier and more doughy than before. The slices don’t hold up the way they used to, making them harder to eat fresh and even tougher to reheat later. At first, I thought it might have been a one-time issue, but after about nine orders recently, it seems to be consistent.
I truly hope this is something that can be fixed, because this place has been a staple in my life for decades, and when it’s at its best, it really is the greatest pizza in the world. I’d love to see it return to the quality that made me a lifelong fan.
Fantastic pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The best in the area, by far.
I arrived at 12:30. I was greated by a less then enthusiastic woman at the desk, I ordered my pizza and I was informed it would be 1/2 hour, which is OK. I wait for a soggy non cooked pizza. That was prepared by a women that didn't care.
FYI have been going there for 25 yrs....let the inmates run the Asylum..see what you get.
P.s. Best pizza in NEPA
Just not when she is left in charge.....
Great pizza and they accommodate my special needs child very well!
They only sell pizzas here. Not sure if it's by the slice or by the pie only. Taste like pizza from my childhood. I got half cheese and half pepperoni. It was greasy! It came out hot and fresh though.
I live out of the area and it was my first time visiting Stuccio’s. The pizza was amazing! Terrific crust and sauce! Definitely unique and I will gladly stop there any time I am in the area.
One of the best if not the best pizza in the area. Thick crust plus sausage is the way to go.
Berwick has so many great pizzerias.
I grew up on Tuzzis and Dalos but always keep coming back to Stuccios.
Magnificent undercarriage. Anchovies 4 life!
We always have to pay for extra sauce because there's not much on a regular pizza. Crust is tough, not like it used to be. Worst part is the service. Two girls working on Saturday afternoon were rude, like they didn't want to be there and not grateful for customers. Kept placing callers on hold, but not really busy.
Restaurantji Recommends
Tasty pizza, very happy two time in a row. We will be a regulator customers when visiting our son.
Some of the best pizza in town. I highly recommend onions and extra cheese.
It's a real pizza place not one of those imitation pizza places with a bunch of fake Italian chatchka and subpar food.
I stopped here on my way through town. Amazing pizza but also fantastic people. I will absolutely be back as soon as possible!!!
If you like grottos you will like stuccios
Loading...