Massey's Frozen Custard

600 W High St, Carlisle
(717) 636-0244

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Soft Serve Chocolate and Vanilla Frozen Custard
Soft Serve Chocolate with Chocolate Sprinkles
Soft Serve Custard Flavors Weekly
Vanilla Chocolate Waffle Cone
Hand Dip Custard Flavors
1 Topping Sundae
Banana Split
Artic Mount

Menu

Frozen Custard
Soft Serve Custard Flavor
Traditional soft served custard is served in a dish.
Soft Serve Custard Flavors Weekly
This is our weekly soft serve flavor served in a dish.
Hand Dip Custard Flavors
This custard is hand scooped and served in a dish.

Milk Shake
Medium Milk Shake
Milk shakes are made to order.
Large Milk Shake
Large milk shake made to order.

Artic Mount
Artic Mount
Soft serve custard with up to three toppings blended into it.

Sundae
1 Topping Sundae
Frozen soft served custard served in a dish with 1 topping and comes with whip cream and a cherry unless you specify you do not want them.
2 Topping Sundae
Frozen soft served custard served in a dish with 2 topping and comes with whip cream and a cherry unless you specify you do not want them.
3 Topping Sundae
Frozen soft served custard served in a dish with 3 toppings and comes with whip cream and a cherry unless you specify you do not want them.
Banana Split
Traditional banana split with vanilla custard, whole banana, strawberry, pineapple, whip cream, chocolate syrup, peanuts and a cherry on top.

Extras
Chocolate Covered Banana
Frozen banana covered with a hard coating of chocolate.
Wafer Sandwich
Our spin on an ice cream sandwich you can have your choice of chocolate or vanilla soft serve between 2 chocolate wafers.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
+75 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+74 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Some people like to divide us Carlisle folks into The Massey's and into The Leo's when it comes to ice cream. However, I'm here to declare that we should stand together United as one, lovers of local ice cream joints. The Lovers of LICJ support both because they are each awesome in their own unique ways. Sometimes I'm in the mood for a delicious twist or hand dipped custard ice cream at Massey's and sometimes I'm in the mood for a strawberry sundae...
November 2025
My wife and I stumbled upon this little gem about 5 years ago on a road trip down South. We had never had frozen custard before having theirs. From the first spoonful we were hooked! Since our first visit, we always make it a point to ensure our route takes us through Carlisle PA so that we can partake of some of the best soft serve frozen custard around. The staff are very friendly and helpful, and the portions are ample. Be sure to pay Massey’s a visit when you are in the...
February 2025
MASSEYS has been around for a long time, and that's because they do frozen custard better than anyone else. SO many choices! great prices and generous servings. please remember to tip your servers.
November 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Miseno II Pizzeria & Italian - 598 W High St
Italian, Pizza
MISENO'S RISTRO PUB - 598 W High St
Pubs, Italian, Pizza
Quick Stop Deli - 601 W Louther St
Deli

Massey's Frozen Custard

600 W High St, Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 636-0244