Redd's Smokehouse BBQ

109 N Hanover St, Carlisle
(717) 254-6419

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kelvin Klemm

We visited here for the first time ever and decided to do the Tour of Redd's as you get a wide variety of meats and sides for an incredible price. A friendly waitress took care of us. Plenty of leftovers to take home and feast on. We paid to street park for 2 hours via a credit card at the parking kiosk which only cost $2.30. My only 'feedback' would be for the restaurant to be cleaner but overall a decent BBQ joint.

Ronald Roth, Jr

What a fantastic find! The meal was positively the best I've had in a very long time. Flavorful doesn't even begin to describe the caliber of quality. Certainly a heart and soul type of place. The staff was courteous and personable from beginning to end. Give this one a try!

Robert McBride

The food was great! The restaurant could have been cleaner and the waitress could have been more attentive. But over all it was good and I would recommend.

Michelle Cody

We recommemd the Brisket ! BBQ is all about the Meat after all .We 4 dined in , and enjoyed brisket and 1 pulled pork .2 in our group were 1st time being introduced to Brisket BBQ and were blown away with how good it was ( myself amazed they have never tried before) ...
Our waitress was wonderful & friendly , service quick & friendly , food served fresh and hot . Thankyou !!

Mable Smith

We came to town for the car show. We found this resturant and thought it would be so good to try. I read over the menu and really wanted a brisket potato. Been look forward to this for weeks. We went last night. My boys ordered the red's platter. Waiting for the food I was told they where out of brisket. I was so bummed. Changed it what I thiught was shredded chicked instead nope, giant chicken chunks. The cheese sauce was very salty. The potato was very dry. The ladies working couldn't get them to stop and get butter. I had to bbqit to make it not so dry. Also the potato needed more time in thr oven. I was so disappointed in my meal. My one time to try and I coukdn't get what I really wanted. I was tood I would get a $3 discount for the brisket but was still charged for bisket?? Very odd

Stephen cc

I got the 2 meat sampler with ribs and pull pork. The ribs came out hot and tender it was good however the pull pork was way too salty. The Mac&cheese had no taste at all I don’t even know if it had any cheese in it. I recommend the ribs

Bret Smith

Amazing food

Michelle Al

Wow, Food is Great and plentiful. Enjoyed the Brisket dinner tonight and it was Awesome!
Service was quick and Friendly ...
.will for sure eat/order here again

Nicholas Rickard

The food was absolutely delicious. We had a group of 14 not one person was disappointed. The staff was very friendly. Can't wait for Carlisle Import and Performance next year to go back. I recommend the make your own bowl.

Anthony Falcon

Today I bought two pounds of brisket to-go. I had to wait a few minutes for them to package it, but the staff were nice. The brisket was the star of the show. Amazing flavor. I recommend it. I got the KC-style BBQ sauce on the side. It was very good and tasted homemade. I will visit again The food calls me back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Aaron Barnett

The food was amazing and the portions were large. I am definitely coming back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Coleslaw

Alexander Kanard

Good bbq alot of meat and very cheap. The Tour of Reds was enough food for four people and only $50. Not good for diet restricted individuals. Sauces were good but needed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Sweet Potato Fries, Ribs, Smoked Wings, BBQ Sauce

Dennis Carbaugh

Good food and lots of it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kacey Miller Topper

I recently had redds bbq cater my wedding and they did an amazing job! I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for catering their special day at a good price! Brent was super personable and made the whole experience really easy. They cleaned up the food us and gave everyone good sized portions. There was definitely no one going home hungry. All of our guests raved about their food. I would definitely support this small business again.

Kemal Kurd

It's better than in other States. Pennsylvania isn't a Cowboy state, but it's a better place than Texas, Arkansas or Oklahoma. I'm a truck driver and I've seen a lot, this place is the best. The most delicious sausages, I haven’t even eaten these in Germany ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...