Island Barbeque and Catering

1646 Plank Rd, Carrolltown
(814) 533-1614

Recent Reviews

The Gitago

Driving by Island BBQ and the smell in the air made me turn around a half.mile down the road. They had just opened and hour before we got thereI got a brisket meal with coleslaw and smoked Mac and cheese and it came to $17 and some It was obscenely dry and tasteless.. zero smoke flavor and way overcooked.. no smoke ring no nothing.. it looked polar opposites of what they show on their website plus side it was a fair portion.Mac n . It was very cheesy and tastes good with a mild smoked paprika flavor. The noodles were overcooked and . The coleslaw was great.. not your typical slaw. Has a nice pepper bite but with a mild sweetness and zing...BBQ Sauce 5/5 The star of the show was the original BBQ sauce.. it was absolutely delicious and clearly homemade...Service and wait time was great, no issues there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Db C.

Driving by Island BBQ and the smell in the air made me turn around a half.mile down the road. They had just opened and hour before we got thereI got a brisket meal with coleslaw and smoked Mac and cheese and it came to $17 and some changeBrisket: 1/5 It was obscenely dry and tasteless.. zero smoke flavor and way overcooked.. no smoke ring no nothing.. it looked polar opposites of what they show on their website plus side it was a fair portion.Mac n cheese: 3/5. It was very cheesy and tastes good with a mild smoked paprika flavor. The noodles were overcooked and soggyColeslaw: 5/5. The coleslaw was great.. not your typical slaw. Has a nice pepper bite but with a mild sweetness and zing...BBQ Sauce 5/5 The star of the show was the original BBQ sauce.. it was absolutely delicious and clearly homemade...Service and wait time was great, no issues there

Wendy Rice

Wonderful food. Fast service. Very friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

George Masden

I was with a group of 10 motorcycle riders this past Sunday and stopped at the Island. Everybody had great food, the service was quick, and great outside seating. Well worth the nearly 2 hour ride!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pork Sandwich

Mick Krug

Friday evening, didn't realize it was 9:20 pm.The girls were cleaning up and still said they'd serve us ice cream which was deliciously creamy!❤

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis Pennington

Awesome pulled pork sandwich, fast, friendly service!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork

Tim Miller

I love going here. The food is always great, the service is superb, and the atmosphere is so nice and cozy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brisket Sandwich

Cindy Mullen

Great food, very friendly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Island BBQ

Dave Johnson

I heard so many people bragging how great the food was so I had to try it. I got a burger and frys, the frys were great the burger not so much it was a processed bubba burger from Walmart frozen foods and nothing more than a dry hockey puck. So I was very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Bun

M N

Island BBQ catered our wedding reception and both their service and food were amazing! They checked on our head table several times to make sure if anybody needed anything, even served one of the guys a beer! They were extremely accommodating throughout the whole planning process and priced very reasonable for the amount of food we got! Jess was awesome to work with and they packaged up all of our leftovers at the end of serving dinner. All of our guests raved about the food and still are!!! Would definitely recommend 10/10 and we will be using them for future events!!!

Travis Hilyer

the food was good but i am not a fan of the ice cream its very creamy almost like a whipped cream consistancy just not for my taste

Matt Martin

Very clean place with a driven ownership it’s nice to see people care about their business

Brittani Rankin

Brisket was not good super dry and the smoked Mac wasn't that great. The homemade brownies tasted burnt. But they're ice cream is good

James Hales

Food was EXCELLENT! Steak and cheese was very good. The best onion rings.

Liz Erving

There food is amazing I love it and the workers there are really nice and there ice cream is especially good I recommend anyone who loves food to go there

Load More