Old Farm Inn

1656 Plank Rd, Carrolltown
(814) 344-5039

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lucas Dudek

The food was good no doubt. And plenty of it! No room on the table for anything lol. But our server.. was particularly stern and almost unhappy towards my family... while hospitable towards seemingly all else? It was our first time out as a family in geezz, almost a year.. n for us to drive n hour and 30 minutes to feel like outsiders was odd at the least.. especially with our kids.. Come on..

Timothy Rupert

It is a bar, so expect that atmosphere. The furniture is on the older side. Their white pizza is excellent. Servers are friendly. Their selection of drafts changed seasonally and is going to give you some decent choices to try something new.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Harkleroad

Great food, fast service only downfall is the booth bench seats are half dead but Great place

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kami Lynne

We love going to the Old Farm Inn! The food is great, but the value is second to none! There is nothing special about the building itself, but the fast, friendly service adds to the feel-good atmosphere. We've gotten the pizza, fish dinner, chicken tenders, hamburgers, and the HUGE Stromboli, and we have never left hungry or disappointed. It's worth the drive for us to head to the Old Farm Inn (about 1.5 hours round trip), and we make it a pretty regular date spot.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don Mulraney

Poor customer service and food was so so

Debbie Slovikosky

Great tasting food with excellent portion sizes for a good price.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Koblosky

The old farm inn is always a wonderful experience, the staff are wonderful, and the food is great! Absolutely my favorite local restaurant!

Eric Wysong

Excellent excellent food and draft selection!

Parking: Open lot.. Lots of space

Kid-friendliness: Staff very friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

tammy westover

Needs more on menu. Faster service when it comes to getting what we ordered. Was hardly anyone there when we went. Took almost a half hr to get our food.

James Williams

Not really that good. When you order something a certain way, and there is no attempt to even close, try to do it that way, it kind of ruins the experience. Asked the waitress for light sauce on the fries, and as you can tell by the photo, not even an attempt was made at that. The fries are decent, Ill say that, but its ruined by being drowned in the sauce we specifically asked to go light on. The chicken is ok, seemed a little overfried. Honestly, its an ok place for a beer, but the food is lackluster.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Darlene Warner

very good prices. burgers were good. huge quantity of home made French fries also good. good quick service however shrimp was over cooked

Tanya Williams

This is a very small and a little run-down place, but my husband and I loved it. We have only gone two times so far, but did not have a bad experience either time. The first time was just my husband and I. The waitress recommended the Buffalo chicken fries, so we got them. We each got a burger (which they get locally), and since they come Ala cart, we figured why not. These fries came out on a huge platter smothered in chicken, cheese, and so much gooey goodness. They were AWESOME! We could not finish since we also ordered breaded mushrooms and cheese curds as well. No idea there would be so many fries. They are very good reheated too...surprising for fries. The burgers were also excellent. Fresh made patties, not frozen. This place is definitely a hidden gem. We took my son this past weekend, and he loved it as well.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gina HidesOut

Food is fantastic, but the server is always rude.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Gina

Food is fantastic, but the server is always rude.

John Kerr

It's small but good food recommendations, wings, and pizza ?. This is a bar and bar food. Booze is good price

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Sub

Loading...