Wow! This place is phenomenal. Some of the best Italian food I’ve ever had, and definitely want to come back ASAP. the restaurant is very cute inside, but can get a bit noisy! They have a BYOB policy, which was really nice. They put our bottles on ice and opened them for us! Wine glasses already set up on the table when we arrived. The food was incredible. We got the bruschetta and calamari as appetizers, both delicious. I got the saltimbocca veal for an entree, which was cooked to perfection and came out so hot! Was to die for! The dessert was also great, we got the tiramisu and chocolate cake. Definitely worth coming for a great dinner!
Drew Winkler
Ainsley was extremely attentive and kind. Top tier service and kindness. We will be back for the tortellini milano!
Adam Barber
I've been coming to this restaurant for a long time now, every time I come to PA to visit my grandparents we come here. It's one of my all-time favorite restaurants. Part of that is the tradition but the food and service are always just so good. I can't wait to be back again.
Eric Bazilian
A first rate family restaurant with a welcome as big and warm as the superlative Italian dishes they serve.
Brian Magrann
Fantastic old school Italian spot (BYOB). Love everything I’ve tried on their menu. Vegetable lasagna sneakily good.
Neal Fitzpatrick
You MUST go there! It is amazing food in a warm and cozy atmosphere. The owner, Donna, is on top of her business while Caitlin, the waitress, is the absolute best! Everything is fresh and delicious!
Michael Brennan
The food was very good and came quickly and hot. The waitress was pleasant and attentive.
Tim Burns
This BYO is always exceeding our expectations. Within walking distance from Fayette and Hector, this establishment is consistently offering a fantastic place to enjoy high quality Italian cuisine with a staff that is eager to please. Grab your best chianti classico and dig in!
Crammed too many people into front. room. Couldn’t hear ourselves talk. waited forever for our food, and then several dishes were actually burnt. I planned a 70th bday dinner and left so disappointed.
Consistently a great meal whatever you order. Don't forget the cannoli.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Gentile
10/10 byob Italian restaurant. We had a rehearsal dinner here, and the food and service far exceed expectations. Everything was taken care of. Appetizers included antipasto, breads, salad, cheeses and calamari. Multiple main courses to choose from and they were all spectacular. Smaller sizers of pasta dishes but that are actually good beats massive piles of pasta that are just okay. And the desserts! Again, spectacular. The ambience and quaintness of the place made you feel like you were in Italy. Could not have asked for a better night and service. The daughter of the owners who was running the show this night and was as good as they come in the restaurant business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Bolognese, Shrimp Della Campagnia
J T
Awesome outdoor dinner. Food was excellent. Service was outstanding. Nice unassuming place. But they come through every time. We had the Veal Pavoratti, chicken Gorgonzola, and pasta. Salad was fresh and tasty. BYOB and reasonable prices! we love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vicki Marino
Love Trattoria Totaro’s! Food is spectacular, perfectly prepared and served with love. Vince and Donna are the heart and soul of this fabulous Conshy restaurant. Missed seeing Ally…we’ll be back soon! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Philly2 anywhere
Best Italian food! Fresh pasta. The calamari was perfect (not pictured). Vegetable lasagna was scrumptious. Australian Striped bass was savored by our guest. The artichoke and red pepper pasta was extremely tasty. 10/10 would recommend. We continue to go back ourselves. Also, if you have the calories to spare get Grandma's cake, well worth it! We split 2 appetizers and 2 desserts between 4 of us. Fresh baked bread with homemade olive oil is in the house. The seating was a little tight, we were shifting plates on our small table frequently. It's a cozy place, dimly lit, and can be loud.
Excellent privately owned real deal Italian.
Wow! This place is phenomenal. Some of the best Italian food I’ve ever had, and definitely want to come back ASAP. the restaurant is very cute inside, but can get a bit noisy! They have a BYOB policy, which was really nice. They put our bottles on ice and opened them for us! Wine glasses already set up on the table when we arrived. The food was incredible. We got the bruschetta and calamari as appetizers, both delicious. I got the saltimbocca veal for an entree, which was cooked to perfection and came out so hot! Was to die for! The dessert was also great, we got the tiramisu and chocolate cake. Definitely worth coming for a great dinner!
Ainsley was extremely attentive and kind. Top tier service and kindness. We will be back for the tortellini milano!
I've been coming to this restaurant for a long time now, every time I come to PA to visit my grandparents we come here. It's one of my all-time favorite restaurants. Part of that is the tradition but the food and service are always just so good. I can't wait to be back again.
A first rate family restaurant with a welcome as big and warm as the superlative Italian dishes they serve.
Fantastic old school Italian spot (BYOB). Love everything I’ve tried on their menu. Vegetable lasagna sneakily good.
You MUST go there! It is amazing food in a warm and cozy atmosphere. The owner, Donna, is on top of her business while Caitlin, the waitress, is the absolute best! Everything is fresh and delicious!
The food was very good and came quickly and hot. The waitress was pleasant and attentive.
This BYO is always exceeding our expectations. Within walking distance from Fayette and Hector, this establishment is consistently offering a fantastic place to enjoy high quality Italian cuisine with a staff that is eager to please. Grab your best chianti classico and dig in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta, Dessert, Lobster Ravioli
Crammed too many people into front. room. Couldn’t hear ourselves talk. waited forever for our food, and then several dishes were actually burnt. I planned a 70th bday dinner and left so disappointed.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Consistently a great meal whatever you order. Don't forget the cannoli.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
10/10 byob Italian restaurant. We had a rehearsal dinner here, and the food and service far exceed expectations. Everything was taken care of. Appetizers included antipasto, breads, salad, cheeses and calamari. Multiple main courses to choose from and they were all spectacular. Smaller sizers of pasta dishes but that are actually good beats massive piles of pasta that are just okay. And the desserts! Again, spectacular. The ambience and quaintness of the place made you feel like you were in Italy. Could not have asked for a better night and service. The daughter of the owners who was running the show this night and was as good as they come in the restaurant business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Bolognese, Shrimp Della Campagnia
Awesome outdoor dinner. Food was excellent. Service was outstanding. Nice unassuming place. But they come through every time.
We had the Veal Pavoratti, chicken Gorgonzola, and pasta. Salad was fresh and tasty.
BYOB and reasonable prices! we love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love Trattoria Totaro’s! Food is spectacular, perfectly prepared and served with love. Vince and Donna are the heart and soul of this fabulous Conshy restaurant. Missed seeing Ally…we’ll be back soon! ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Italian food! Fresh pasta. The calamari was perfect (not pictured). Vegetable lasagna was scrumptious. Australian Striped bass was savored by our guest. The artichoke and red pepper pasta was extremely tasty. 10/10 would recommend. We continue to go back ourselves. Also, if you have the calories to spare get Grandma's cake, well worth it! We split 2 appetizers and 2 desserts between 4 of us. Fresh baked bread with homemade olive oil is in the house. The seating was a little tight, we were shifting plates on our small table frequently. It's a cozy place, dimly lit, and can be loud.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dessert with Gelato
Loading...