I’ve eaten there for a long time. My wife and I go twice while we are there for the two days and never have been disappointed. Yes one night we had to wait a bit because we both ordered chicken parmigiana and were told it would be a wait. That was because the chicken was made fresh and was super!! I think they do there best!! Vincent Scarpino
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anand hughes
Impressed with the new upgrades with the restaurant, especially now being able to order online without having to call in. The new online website is very easy to use and quite expansive on the variety of food this restaurant has to offer.The food is always good and well prepared, over the yrs ordering food from this place. The quality of the food has always stayed consistent and delicious. Never faltering from those traditional Italian dishes we all know and love! An one thing which always caught my taste buds: is that the food always tastes FRESH!!! Like most other restaurants you can tell if the food is fresh or not. You can always tell the difference between frozen processed food to well cooked fresh food.The pricing for their dishes: in my humble opinion is pretty fair considering the taste, freshness, how it's prepared and packaged for you an your delivery service needs!I'd give this restaurant 8 out 10.
I picked up a order for myself and another person one order was 2 large pizzas one Supreme one cheese there's were perfect OURS on the other hand was a simple half pepperoni half sausage with sinaknots excluding the already crazy price and weird atmosphere I'm astounded how they absolutely burned our pizza on the bottom but managed to make our other parties perfectly on top of the sinaknots not having much of any cinnamon I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
scoobs life
The other reviews and the responses from this establishment should explain everything...wish I checked before I went. Won't be going back money better spent else where.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jas Hehnly
Menu says one price and get charged 3.00 more per
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Hannah Buchsenschutz
If I could give 0 stars I would. We came in and seated ourselves as the sign says and waited 15-20 minutes for someone to come out to take our order. I ordered a small pizza for my son and a pizza sub for myself and our 2 drinks. I watched her pour our drinks and set them on the counter and walk away, by time we got them they were so watered down from the ice melting. But we didn’t say anything. After what seemed like forever we finally got our food, when I asked for a plate for my 3 year old son she rolled her eyes and said we just use this as the plate (referring to the piping hot pizza tray she just set in front of my 3 year old. The pizza was alright but the pizza sub I ordered was awful, most definitely wasn’t a sub wasn’t even on a sub roll or anything. Overall terrible experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jamie Moose
We stayed at a local air BNB and ordered an XL pizza and breaded mushrooms. Our bill was $54.52 for these 2 items. I would not recommend or give them my business again. Pizza was mediocre at best.The so called out of town delivery fee should definitely be mentioned when ordering so this is not a SURPRISE. We definitely would have driven the 5 miles to get our food.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Brian Brubaker
It's good pizza if they let you order it. They can be hostile to takeout orders. For what reason? Heaven only knows.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Dave W
Ate here today for the first time. Got carry out. I was a little late picking up pizza but we thought it was still very good. We would get pizza / something else here again. Desert portions are pretty small so probably wouldn’t do deserts again, however I will say that I did enjoy the Tiramisu.Read a good bit of reviews that said the lady was not friendly. Not sure which lady the reviews are referring to. The lady that helped tonight didn’t seem all that friendly but everyone has a different personality. An establishment like this, you are going to for the food. You are not going to a $500 a plate dinner for the “experience”.People need to have thicker skin and stop being so soft.Have purchased quite a few pies from here and am still very happy with the food!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
s p
Another great place hidden in this county of Potter. I ordered the Stromboli (small) and absolutely HUGE! Also got the jalapeño poppers! I was very satisfied, a delicious PA Stromboli. Sadly, it’s hard to find one outside of PA! Bummer. The waitress was very kind as well, establishment was clean too. Great downtown spot to dine in!
Great pizza! We always stop in when we visit for stargazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Lee Jones
The pizza is excellent. Everything else is the worst imaginable.We are long time residents of the area. We've tried this restaurant 3 times in the last 10 years hoping for the best. Each time has been worse. The atmosphere is dull and dingy. The staff, management are inattentive and sometimes nasty. The owner manager is one of the most obnoxious combative ignoramuses I've ever encountered. No other restaurant I've ever been in could you expect to get into a fight or argument trying to place an order or inquire why you are waiting sooo long for service and your meal.The eggplant ? Parmigianino is overcooked zucchini buried under a mound of overcooked spaghetti. TERRIBLE. The chicken parmigiano is chicken nuggets burried under overcooked spaghetti. TERRIBLE.I've traveled extensively and eaten in all types of restaurants, good and bad. The bad you usually just write off as a bad experience. This one is so bad that I consider it the worst in my experience. It's the only place where you can actually get into a fight with the manager \ owner outside of a Biker Bar.As far as I know, the only people who eat there have no options or don't know any better.Your worst dining option in this area is better than this one for sure
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tomi Davis
Relaxed, friendly environment serving the best pizza I've ever tasted, not kidding. Fresh made, hand tossed dough with fresh toppings. Salads were very fresh. Recommended by locals, glad we decided to check it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Walden
This is a small Stromboli! Would love to see a large but don’t want to chance wasting most of it! This one is 3/4 meals for me. Here’s a pepperoni pizza lg. we used to get take out at Foxes den but family member stated their pizzas are Not consistent. One time good next time not so good. So we tried OIP in Couldersport pa. And I was sent back the next day to get another Pizza!!! Yep that’s how good it was! We can not wait to try everything they have on our next orders!
I’ve eaten there for a long time. My wife and I go twice while we are there for the two days and never have been disappointed. Yes one night we had to wait a bit because we both ordered chicken parmigiana and were told it would be a wait. That was because the chicken was made fresh and was super!! I think they do there best!! Vincent Scarpino
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Impressed with the new upgrades with the restaurant, especially now being able to order online without having to call in. The new online website is very easy to use and quite expansive on the variety of food this restaurant has to offer.The food is always good and well prepared, over the yrs ordering food from this place. The quality of the food has always stayed consistent and delicious. Never faltering from those traditional Italian dishes we all know and love! An one thing which always caught my taste buds: is that the food always tastes FRESH!!! Like most other restaurants you can tell if the food is fresh or not. You can always tell the difference between frozen processed food to well cooked fresh food.The pricing for their dishes: in my humble opinion is pretty fair considering the taste, freshness, how it's prepared and packaged for you an your delivery service needs!I'd give this restaurant 8 out 10.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Pizza, Steak Stromboli
I picked up a order for myself and another person one order was 2 large pizzas one Supreme one cheese there's were perfect OURS on the other hand was a simple half pepperoni half sausage with sinaknots excluding the already crazy price and weird atmosphere I'm astounded how they absolutely burned our pizza on the bottom but managed to make our other parties perfectly on top of the sinaknots not having much of any cinnamon I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The other reviews and the responses from this establishment should explain everything...wish I checked before I went. Won't be going back money better spent else where.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Menu says one price and get charged 3.00 more per
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
If I could give 0 stars I would. We came in and seated ourselves as the sign says and waited 15-20 minutes for someone to come out to take our order. I ordered a small pizza for my son and a pizza sub for myself and our 2 drinks. I watched her pour our drinks and set them on the counter and walk away, by time we got them they were so watered down from the ice melting. But we didn’t say anything. After what seemed like forever we finally got our food, when I asked for a plate for my 3 year old son she rolled her eyes and said we just use this as the plate (referring to the piping hot pizza tray she just set in front of my 3 year old. The pizza was alright but the pizza sub I ordered was awful, most definitely wasn’t a sub wasn’t even on a sub roll or anything. Overall terrible experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
We stayed at a local air BNB and ordered an XL pizza and breaded mushrooms. Our bill was $54.52 for these 2 items. I would not recommend or give them my business again. Pizza was mediocre at best.The so called out of town delivery fee should definitely be mentioned when ordering so this is not a SURPRISE. We definitely would have driven the 5 miles to get our food.
Food: 2
Service: 2
It's good pizza if they let you order it. They can be hostile to takeout orders. For what reason? Heaven only knows.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ate here today for the first time. Got carry out. I was a little late picking up pizza but we thought it was still very good. We would get pizza / something else here again. Desert portions are pretty small so probably wouldn’t do deserts again, however I will say that I did enjoy the Tiramisu.Read a good bit of reviews that said the lady was not friendly. Not sure which lady the reviews are referring to. The lady that helped tonight didn’t seem all that friendly but everyone has a different personality. An establishment like this, you are going to for the food. You are not going to a $500 a plate dinner for the “experience”.People need to have thicker skin and stop being so soft.Have purchased quite a few pies from here and am still very happy with the food!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Another great place hidden in this county of Potter. I ordered the Stromboli (small) and absolutely HUGE! Also got the jalapeño poppers! I was very satisfied, a delicious PA Stromboli. Sadly, it’s hard to find one outside of PA! Bummer. The waitress was very kind as well, establishment was clean too. Great downtown spot to dine in!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food. Loved their pizza & Stromboli.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Great pizza! We always stop in when we visit for stargazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
The pizza is excellent. Everything else is the worst imaginable.We are long time residents of the area. We've tried this restaurant 3 times in the last 10 years hoping for the best. Each time has been worse. The atmosphere is dull and dingy. The staff, management are inattentive and sometimes nasty. The owner manager is one of the most obnoxious combative ignoramuses I've ever encountered. No other restaurant I've ever been in could you expect to get into a fight or argument trying to place an order or inquire why you are waiting sooo long for service and your meal.The eggplant ? Parmigianino is overcooked zucchini buried under a mound of overcooked spaghetti. TERRIBLE. The chicken parmigiano is chicken nuggets burried under overcooked spaghetti. TERRIBLE.I've traveled extensively and eaten in all types of restaurants, good and bad. The bad you usually just write off as a bad experience. This one is so bad that I consider it the worst in my experience. It's the only place where you can actually get into a fight with the manager \ owner outside of a Biker Bar.As far as I know, the only people who eat there have no options or don't know any better.Your worst dining option in this area is better than this one for sure
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Relaxed, friendly environment serving the best pizza I've ever tasted, not kidding. Fresh made, hand tossed dough with fresh toppings. Salads were very fresh. Recommended by locals, glad we decided to check it out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a small Stromboli! Would love to see a large but don’t want to chance wasting most of it! This one is 3/4 meals for me. Here’s a pepperoni pizza lg. we used to get take out at Foxes den but family member stated their pizzas are Not consistent. One time good next time not so good. So we tried OIP in Couldersport pa. And I was sent back the next day to get another Pizza!!! Yep that’s how good it was! We can not wait to try everything they have on our next orders!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5