Wyndridge Farm

885 S Pleasant Ave, Dallastown
(717) 244-9900

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Emily Morgan

We had an absolutely fantastic dinner and stay at Wyndridge! The staff was extremely friendly and accommodating, would absolutely recommend

Lyn

I live nearby and have thought about trying this place for a while. An occasion finally arose, so we went for a two-person birthday dinner. The first thing I noticed was the acoustics were terrible. The restaurant was quite full at 5:30 pm on a Friday, and it was very hard to have a conversation. Their appetizer selection was odd and limited. Most of it seemed more like shareable sides than appetizers. The cream of crab soup was watery and lacked flavor, and the other shareable we ordered came out first, although we requested that it come with the meal - I didn't want to fill up on fries before my meal came - but they came early. The fries were nice and crispy, and the jalapeno aioli was quite good. The crabcake sandwich was mediocre, again lacking in flavor. I had the pit beef sandwich on a pretzel roll. This might've been a good sandwich, but it was drowned in American cheese sauce, so that was all you could taste. I had a raspberry lemon crush that was decent. My friend ordered a Captain and Coke and was given something other than Captain Morgan. I'm not sure if it was a mistake or an assumption that it wouldn't be noticed, but if they are going to substitute a different liquor than what you specifically ask for, they should warn you. All in all, it was an okay meal, but not something I would return for. W

Sarah Adams Shaffer

We were just there for Mother’s Day and it was terrible! Such a shame the building is beautiful, but the food and service was just awful! We won’t be back!

LaurenW

We made a reservation but when we arrived there was absolute chaos in the lobby and the hostess working said “let me guess, you have a reservation?” When we approached the stand to check in. She wouldn't explain what was going on and said she “had to remain politically correct” and ultimately said she could take our names but didn't know how long our wait would be. I asked if their system was down and she said “that sounds good, let's go with that.” It was the most bizarre experience ever. Needless to say, we left and went somewhere else.

michelle

The restaurant was completely overbooked. We waited an hour for our reservation crammed in an overcrowded lobby. Some in our party tried to get a drink at the bar but waited 25 minutes to get served.The restaurant didn't do anything to address the wait time issue. Half of our food was served and the waitress went to get orders from another table. Most in our party thought the food was pretty good. I hope this was just a bad day, but their lack of response doesn't excite us about returning.

GARRY

The crab cake sandwich was delicious. The flights of cider were flavorful, and refreshing.

Kim

We love this place! Beautiful surroundings and great food. We went for brunch on this occasion and ate outside. Windy day so there was tent noise but very manageable. Food was great and came quickly but from there it was hard to get follow up drinks, dessert and bill.

Gill

Food was very average and not what I recall from two years ago. The menu has changed and food quality not what I remember nor worth returning for. Crab dip was decent and service was good. During our visit, the farm was hosting a wedding reception which may have contributed to our lackluster experience. The dining room may have had some seating added for this event as the place was packed and navigating through the tables was very tight. My opinion here was a consensus of my party of eight. Something has changed at this venue, perhaps they had a change in ownership or philosophy, but I doubt we return.

Leah

Wyndridge is one of our favorite spots! We were a little disappointed in the food this latest time, but we won't let that stop us from coming back. Their pretzel with cheese is one of our favorites- however the last time we went, it was a bit dry and almost stale-tasting. It's usually buttery, warm, and perfect! My husband was also disappointed in his cocktail, which was overly syrupy. But I always love the flights of cider to try the newer ones on tap that you can't get in a can! The burger was delicious - it's usually my go-to!

robert

Very enjoyable lunch experience. Great brew selection. Food very tasty and well presented. Perfect friendly and attentive server.

Korie Metzger Snyder

We went for Valentine’s Day and the food made both of us sick afterwards. My husband’s medium steak came out still mooing, he sent it back and a brand new steak came out also medium rare. My vegetables and mashed potatoes were cold. A Marylander needs to teach the kitchen staff how to make a crab cake. The prickly pear drink, however, was amazing!

Matthew

Food was delicious, drinks were great, however... they clearly overbooked for Valentine's Day, it was extremely loud and packed. The tables were all mixed and matched, some just a wood top and some with a black table cloth like a cocktail table. Floor was dirty, trash and food all over, chairs and table had some grime on it. There was some party happening down the hall that had all sorts of folks just wondering around in the middle of dinner. If you're going to have a Valentine's Day menu and try to draw couples in for a nice romantic dinner maybe don't have the lights at tanning level 10 and space out the tables a bit more so you aren't nuts to butts. I will say they did accommodate our preschooler who we had to add last night because his sitter had the flu.

Pam

Ambiance is great! Ciders and beers are good as well. We will go again but only for wood fire pizza and cider or possibly the tacos. They are weak on “fancy” entrees. I ordered the rib eye and was surprised by the substitution of a sirloin strip steak, which was tough. My dinning companion had a nice chicken Maryland entree but the risotto was undercooked. Our carrot cake was either overcooked or slightly stale. Recommend stick to the tacos and pizza (which next table over recommended) and enjoy the ambiance and drinks!

Genevia

The service was absolutely exceptional! Our waitress was extremely knowledgeable and genuinely loves her job! We will be back!

Lisa Kristine

My family and I came to the Princess event today and had a wonderful time. We then ate dinner afterwards in the restaurant, which we've done many times before, and had the worst experience. Every other time we've been here we've had wonderful food and service but tonight the service was horrible, our food came out dry and all at different times and we had to repeatedly ask for it. The server was slow and forgot about our food and requests. I ordered pineapple habanero wings and got buffalo wings instead and they refused to switch them for me. This was extremely disappointing considering how many other times we've had great meals here. The only good thing tonight was the drinks. We definitely won't be back any time soon of at all.

Loading...