So disappointed with our bagels. They are not cooked enough. Need to have that beautiful brown crust with the soft chewy bread inside.
Thomas McDermid
I purchased two cookies from this establishment they were literally the driest cookies I have ever had in my life. The bagels are good though.
Karen knellinger
My first time here, the bagel was fresh, however, there were none in the large empty case to view. Sight is a selling point. 930am on a Saturday & no desserts, donuts, etc. A few cookies, that's it. The sandwich costs 8.50, for a bagel, bacon, egg & cheese. 1 egg, 1.5 pieces of bacon & no cheese to be found. Not worth the price.
Ronald Johnson
Bagel was fine, and veggie cream cheese had great flavor, bit it seems odd to pay nearly twice as much for the cream cheese on a bagel as you pay for the bagel itself. Lemon poppyseed scone was good. Not a great value overall.
Johnny Rose
Bagel good
Cindy Heiner
We ordered a dozen bagels, all different and they placed them in one bag so now they all smell/taste like onion and garlic. So disappointing.
Thomas Pastucha
Smoothie was warm, out of garlic bagels at 9 am on a saturday, employees are nice, but just not good enough for the amount of money I paid
Sierra Zoe Gratti
The staff is hands down so friendly and were amazing to my dog and me ❤️ Food was great too! Highly recommend this place!! ❤️❤️
Annabella Mucciolo
Love love love this place. Never had a bad food item that I didn’t love.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly Isenhour
I just LOVE pretty coffee ☕️…it just tastes better somehow!! 😆 Check out this Chocolate Covered Pretzel Iced Latte (chocolate and toffee nut with salted caramel cold foam). The staff is so nice!!! They gave recommendations when I asked and were super helpful and friendly!! What a great spot for breakfast or lunch!!! The ambience is adorable!!!
Great place and even better food!! I got the chicken salad on a croissant with lettuce & tomato. If I put it on my forehead my tongue probably would have beat the shit out of me trying to get to it!! Bone apple teeth 🤌🤌🤌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
McKenzie Apaliski
Kayla is such a happy and energetic person in the morning that it rubs off onto customers and helps make my mornings great. She gets to know her regular customers orders by heart and knows what I want before me. Always smiling and creating a happy environment :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Noel Fullman
I am from New Jersey so I am VERY picky about my bagels. I had a BEC with avocado on a plain bagel and it is hands down the best I’ve ever had away from home… potentially even better than places in NJ/NY. To the owner, I’m a student at Bucknell University and I’m telling you, you’d do incredibly well if you opened a location in Lewisburg. 10/10👏🥯
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olivia Smithson
My boyfriend and I are from NJ so we take our bagels pretty seriously. Every time we've ordered from Old City Bagel Co, we've been very satisfied with the quality and service. The girls who work up front are super friendly and hardworking, and the pork roll, egg, & cheese bagels literally taste like home. Excited to bring family here when they come to visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Muhammad Ali
Decent bagels, good coffee, nice service. Way too expensive!
So disappointed with our bagels. They are not cooked enough. Need to have that beautiful brown crust with the soft chewy bread inside.
I purchased two cookies from this establishment they were literally the driest cookies I have ever had in my life. The bagels are good though.
My first time here, the bagel was fresh, however, there were none in the large empty case to view. Sight is a selling point. 930am on a Saturday & no desserts, donuts, etc. A few cookies, that's it. The sandwich costs 8.50, for a bagel, bacon, egg & cheese. 1 egg, 1.5 pieces of bacon & no cheese to be found. Not worth the price.
Bagel was fine, and veggie cream cheese had great flavor, bit it seems odd to pay nearly twice as much for the cream cheese on a bagel as you pay for the bagel itself. Lemon poppyseed scone was good. Not a great value overall.
Bagel good
We ordered a dozen bagels, all different and they placed them in one bag so now they all smell/taste like onion and garlic. So disappointing.
Smoothie was warm, out of garlic bagels at 9 am on a saturday, employees are nice, but just not good enough for the amount of money I paid
The staff is hands down so friendly and were amazing to my dog and me ❤️ Food was great too! Highly recommend this place!! ❤️❤️
Love love love this place. Never had a bad food item that I didn’t love.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just LOVE pretty coffee ☕️…it just tastes better somehow!! 😆 Check out this Chocolate Covered Pretzel Iced Latte (chocolate and toffee nut with salted caramel cold foam). The staff is so nice!!! They gave recommendations when I asked and were super helpful and friendly!! What a great spot for breakfast or lunch!!! The ambience is adorable!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place and even better food!! I got the chicken salad on a croissant with lettuce & tomato. If I put it on my forehead my tongue probably would have beat the shit out of me trying to get to it!! Bone apple teeth 🤌🤌🤌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla is such a happy and energetic person in the morning that it rubs off onto customers and helps make my mornings great. She gets to know her regular customers orders by heart and knows what I want before me. Always smiling and creating a happy environment :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
I am from New Jersey so I am VERY picky about my bagels. I had a BEC with avocado on a plain bagel and it is hands down the best I’ve ever had away from home… potentially even better than places in NJ/NY. To the owner, I’m a student at Bucknell University and I’m telling you, you’d do incredibly well if you opened a location in Lewisburg. 10/10👏🥯
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My boyfriend and I are from NJ so we take our bagels pretty seriously. Every time we've ordered from Old City Bagel Co, we've been very satisfied with the quality and service. The girls who work up front are super friendly and hardworking, and the pork roll, egg, & cheese bagels literally taste like home. Excited to bring family here when they come to visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent bagels, good coffee, nice service. Way too expensive!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...