Cakes are always professionally done. They make sure their customers are highly satisfied. Been a customer for 5 yrs now and will keep going there for as long as they're still in business.
Amy Druck
We ordered cupcakes with “popcorn” icing and cake balls for my granddaughter’s first birthday party. They looked amazing and were delicious! We also were surprised that a beautiful smash cake was included free of charge!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brianna Bowermaster
Amy is truly amazing!! I hired Amy's Custom Cakery for our wedding this past weekend and let me tell you, it was the best decision. We had a dessert bar rather than a cake for everyone. We had cupcakes, dessert cups, cookies, and a small cake for the newly Weds. We also had extra desserts made for guests to take home. Everything was delicious, fresh, and beautiful! Amy was a pleasure to work with and made things very easy for us as far as planning. We loved working with a vendor that had such passion for her work and got so excited for our vision. If you need a baker for your wedding, stop here and call Amy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cakes Cupcakes Cookies Candy and More
GENE BAILIFF
I mostly buy cupcakes when I meet the grandkids in Hanover PA. But I have ordered a couple cakes and we’re very satisfied with both of them. I love the service very friendly and helpful. I’m a dude so I really don’t know how to order very well When it comes to cakes and stuff like that.cakes.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mary Humphreys
I purchased the chocolate chip cupcakes with chocolate fudge icing and a variety of cake pops. I would highly recommend both. Oh my goodness, what a treat. Purchased for a birthday party, and they were a great hit. If you haven't tried Amy's you are missing out. Thank You for the tasty treats and the customer service.
Maddie Gyenes
I ordered the cake for my 18th birthday from here and they delivered 10 fold. I didnt know what to expect when i asked for my favorite band, Waterparks, as the theme for my cake but the delivered in ways i couldnt even imagine! I’m so happy with how this turned out and its literally the best cake ive ever had, words cany describe the happiness i got from seeing this cake
janet short
I ordered a Black Forest cake for my husbands birthday. It was fabulous!! I highly recommend this baker!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cristine Altieri
I ordered this cake for my cousin who is a quilter. I sent a picture of the cake. I was hoping the sewing machine could also have been cake, however, it could not be done. The cake was beautiful and the details were all there. The attached sewing machine piece broke as you can see in the picture. I was unable to be with her, therefore, I could not taste the cake. My cousin was so happy with the design. She said the cake was delicious! As long as this made my cousin happy then it’s good in my book. I will certainly go back to Amy’s if I’m in need of another cake.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Meridith Ranck
Thank you so much for the Michael Jackson birthday cake and for making it happen for us!
Nicole Shank
I ordered a custom cake for my dad's 60th birthday, and they more than delivered. I didn't even know making a cake like this was possible, let alone at the price they offered. My only complaint was that I also ordered gluten free cupcakes for some family members, and I remember requesting filling for them, but they did not come with filling. However, it's hard to even complain about that because my sister ate one, said it was delicious, and said they didn't even have that gluten free texture/taste. Then she took the rest home with her! (Edit: I ate one of the cupcakes myself, and there was filling in mine, so maybe she was mistaken, or maybe the filling was just missed for that one; but again, I can't complain because of the sheer deliciousness!) We also bought a dozen cake balls on the day we went to pick up the cake, and again, supremely fantastic flavor, texture, price, everything. I know where I'll be going for all future baking needs.
They did great on are wedding cake and easy to deal with.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Trayer
We’ve gotten three birthday cakes from Amy’s and each one has been beautiful, delicious and easy to order. This is our go-to bakery now for bday cakes! You can’t go wrong here.
Catherine Johnston
I order all my cakes from Amy and the team and I’m amazed every time, but especially impressed with my last two cakes I had to come on and leave another review to show them off my 82 year-old father-in-law loves old-fashioned western tv shows so we knew we had to get him a western cake and me and my husband always watch true crime together so we did a true crime inspired cake and she did amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Bucher
We picked up some delicious desserts at the York home show. Absolutely amazing and very fair prices.
Hailey Baker
Loved how our cakes turned out. Absolutely identical to the reference photo I sent. Tasted amazing!
Cakes are always professionally done. They make sure their customers are highly satisfied. Been a customer for 5 yrs now and will keep going there for as long as they're still in business.
We ordered cupcakes with “popcorn” icing and cake balls for my granddaughter’s first birthday party. They looked amazing and were delicious! We also were surprised that a beautiful smash cake was included free of charge!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy is truly amazing!! I hired Amy's Custom Cakery for our wedding this past weekend and let me tell you, it was the best decision. We had a dessert bar rather than a cake for everyone. We had cupcakes, dessert cups, cookies, and a small cake for the newly Weds. We also had extra desserts made for guests to take home. Everything was delicious, fresh, and beautiful! Amy was a pleasure to work with and made things very easy for us as far as planning. We loved working with a vendor that had such passion for her work and got so excited for our vision. If you need a baker for your wedding, stop here and call Amy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Cakes Cupcakes Cookies Candy and More
I mostly buy cupcakes when I meet the grandkids in Hanover PA. But I have ordered a couple cakes and we’re very satisfied with both of them. I love the service very friendly and helpful. I’m a dude so I really don’t know how to order very well When it comes to cakes and stuff like that.cakes.
Food: 4
Service: 5
I purchased the chocolate chip cupcakes with chocolate fudge icing and a variety of cake pops. I would highly recommend both. Oh my goodness, what a treat. Purchased for a birthday party, and they were a great hit. If you haven't tried Amy's you are missing out. Thank You for the tasty treats and the customer service.
I ordered the cake for my 18th birthday from here and they delivered 10 fold. I didnt know what to expect when i asked for my favorite band, Waterparks, as the theme for my cake but the delivered in ways i couldnt even imagine! I’m so happy with how this turned out and its literally the best cake ive ever had, words cany describe the happiness i got from seeing this cake
I ordered a Black Forest cake for my husbands birthday. It was fabulous!! I highly recommend this baker!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered this cake for my cousin who is a quilter. I sent a picture of the cake. I was hoping the sewing machine could also have been cake, however, it could not be done. The cake was beautiful and the details were all there. The attached sewing machine piece broke as you can see in the picture. I was unable to be with her, therefore, I could not taste the cake. My cousin was so happy with the design. She said the cake was delicious! As long as this made my cousin happy then it’s good in my book. I will certainly go back to Amy’s if I’m in need of another cake.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Thank you so much for the Michael Jackson birthday cake and for making it happen for us!
I ordered a custom cake for my dad's 60th birthday, and they more than delivered. I didn't even know making a cake like this was possible, let alone at the price they offered. My only complaint was that I also ordered gluten free cupcakes for some family members, and I remember requesting filling for them, but they did not come with filling. However, it's hard to even complain about that because my sister ate one, said it was delicious, and said they didn't even have that gluten free texture/taste. Then she took the rest home with her! (Edit: I ate one of the cupcakes myself, and there was filling in mine, so maybe she was mistaken, or maybe the filling was just missed for that one; but again, I can't complain because of the sheer deliciousness!) We also bought a dozen cake balls on the day we went to pick up the cake, and again, supremely fantastic flavor, texture, price, everything. I know where I'll be going for all future baking needs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
They did great on are wedding cake and easy to deal with.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We’ve gotten three birthday cakes from Amy’s and each one has been beautiful, delicious and easy to order. This is our go-to bakery now for bday cakes! You can’t go wrong here.
I order all my cakes from Amy and the team and I’m amazed every time, but especially impressed with my last two cakes I had to come on and leave another review to show them off my 82 year-old father-in-law loves old-fashioned western tv shows so we knew we had to get him a western cake and me and my husband always watch true crime together so we did a true crime inspired cake and she did amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We picked up some delicious desserts at the York home show. Absolutely amazing and very fair prices.
Loved how our cakes turned out. Absolutely identical to the reference photo I sent. Tasted amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...