Had a tiramisu milkshake, had a transcendent culinary experience, 11 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Sauter
If I am in the area, I always stop at Sarah's Creamery. My son graduated from Penn State, and we got hooked on Penn State Ice Cream. Sarah's is the only place I know that has Penn State Ice Cream other than Penn State! My favorite is "Peachy Paterno"! I stopped in Sarah's Creamery today and got my Peachy Paterno Ice cream cone. It's the best treat ever! If you are ever in the area, you must stop in Sarah's Creamery and try the Penn State Ice Cream!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zoe Hagarman
The best ice cream ever there! I would recommend Penn State Grilled Stickies and chocolate lava cake. They also have vegan and sugar free ice cream! The staff and owner are very friendly! Would definitely recommend if you have kids!
Definitely recommend Sarah’s, and especially recommend the monkey business . The staff is super nice and helpful. Especially when it came to dietary restrictions. My mom has restrictions on gluten and dairy items and the staff was very helpful on picking out what she can have and it was still delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samantha Federo
Sarah's Creamery Ice Cream Truck was a hit for our wedding in August! As an alternative to cake, we decided to hire Sarah's Creamery for a refreshing twist on wedding dessert. My guests absolutely LOVED it.
Communication and coordination was prompt and professional. We opted for their Premium package which included 15 flavors of ice cream, Italian ice, waffle cones, MTO chocolate chunk cookie sandwiches, root beer floats, brownie Sundaes, Ice cream sundaes and toppings. They even had a No Sugar added and dairy free/vegan option available. The best part was that it was an "open bar" system where guests could come up and order as much as they would like!
The server on our wedding day was professional and did an excellent job with a smile on his face.
I highly recommend booking Sarah's Ice Cream Truck for your event!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
20AI AI20
If I could give five stars for the poor girl who had been working there by herself for three days in a row during Labor Day weekend, I would, but as a business manager in Washington DC, utilizing business tactics practiced nationwide on our youth should be avoided. It is no secret everywhere is understaffed but local businesses that employee the youth that are going to shape our future need to be in there working themselves so they don’t have one employee working all weekend long since it’s no skin off there neck if she quits or not. I commend that girl because she stuck it out and served hundreds maybe over 1000 customers over the course of a three day weekend when companies like this will be the first ones to replace that same worker with a robotic arm that can scoop ice cream and take orders by Digital interface.
Grew up in this town, then went on to work in the very industry I spoke of and I’m hopeful in the coming years communities like the one we grew up in will be able to thrive with access to technology like this
Richie Chilingirian
Always fast. Always smiling. Always great. Forget bill macks ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sheldon Grasley
We bought from the truck. It was outstanding.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christene Bohns
New owner not professional with her staff. Needs to improve her people skills and learn respecting your staff only benefits you.
The store and restroom was clean and nice. The service was great and the ice cream was very yummy and moderately priced. Not on our side of town but we will return if we are in the neighborhood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Frey
Penn State Creamery Ice Cream!!!! Enough said. This place is great! The ice cream that they make on site is delicious, as well.
Parking: Careful pulling in and out of here, the entrance is steep and some cars inevitably bottom out. When in doubt, turn right and just go around the block.
Kid-friendliness: Great place for kids! The theming of this ice cream place is whimsical, and the yard games and GIANT chairs keep us coming back with every guest that comes to visit us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Death by Chocolate with Toppings, State Coffee Break, Death by Chocolate, Pre Packed Vegan Ice Cream
MycalaKembring
After reading the 5 star reviews, we went in, looking forward to ice cream cones. We waited in line and then we were informed that the vegan flavors were in the freezer case. I asked if we could have it put on a cone. The person behind the counter said no but she could give us a cone. We looked at the case and there were small servings of vanilla or some berry in vanilla. I prefer chocolate based, so we left. Disappointing experience. Perhaps we'll try again at some point.
Steve Turner, REALTOR
One of the best Ice Cream Shops in York Co! Sarah's Creamery has both inside and outside seating and by far the largest selection of flavors around. The staff is friendly and does a great job taking care of customers. Is it the best ice cream in the State? Maybe. I would say Sarah's and Handles are tied for the best, but Sarah's does have the advantage of being able to sit down inside with family. (also being next to the Burger Garage, makes for a great location for both a meal and dessert!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Death by Chocolate with Toppings, Waffle
Jamie Von Diez
It smells so good in this shop!! The milkshakes were great and I love that you can combine flavors.
Had a tiramisu milkshake, had a transcendent culinary experience, 11 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If I am in the area, I always stop at Sarah's Creamery. My son graduated from Penn State, and we got hooked on Penn State Ice Cream. Sarah's is the only place I know that has Penn State Ice Cream other than Penn State! My favorite is "Peachy Paterno"! I stopped in Sarah's Creamery today and got my Peachy Paterno Ice cream cone. It's the best treat ever! If you are ever in the area, you must stop in Sarah's Creamery and try the Penn State Ice Cream!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best ice cream ever there! I would recommend Penn State Grilled Stickies and chocolate lava cake. They also have vegan and sugar free ice cream! The staff and owner are very friendly! Would definitely recommend if you have kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Brownie Sundae, Cake
Definitely recommend Sarah’s, and especially recommend the monkey business . The staff is super nice and helpful. Especially when it came to dietary restrictions. My mom has restrictions on gluten and dairy items and the staff was very helpful on picking out what she can have and it was still delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah's Creamery Ice Cream Truck was a hit for our wedding in August! As an alternative to cake, we decided to hire Sarah's Creamery for a refreshing twist on wedding dessert. My guests absolutely LOVED it.
Communication and coordination was prompt and professional. We opted for their Premium package which included 15 flavors of ice cream, Italian ice, waffle cones, MTO chocolate chunk cookie sandwiches, root beer floats, brownie Sundaes, Ice cream sundaes and toppings. They even had a No Sugar added and dairy free/vegan option available. The best part was that it was an "open bar" system where guests could come up and order as much as they would like!
The server on our wedding day was professional and did an excellent job with a smile on his face.
I highly recommend booking Sarah's Ice Cream Truck for your event!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If I could give five stars for the poor girl who had been working there by herself for three days in a row during Labor Day weekend, I would, but as a business manager in Washington DC, utilizing business tactics practiced nationwide on our youth should be avoided. It is no secret everywhere is understaffed but local businesses that employee the youth that are going to shape our future need to be in there working themselves so they don’t have one employee working all weekend long since it’s no skin off there neck if she quits or not. I commend that girl because she stuck it out and served hundreds maybe over 1000 customers over the course of a three day weekend when companies like this will be the first ones to replace that same worker with a robotic arm that can scoop ice cream and take orders by Digital interface.
Grew up in this town, then went on to work in the very industry I spoke of and I’m hopeful in the coming years communities like the one we grew up in will be able to thrive with access to technology like this
Always fast. Always smiling. Always great. Forget bill macks ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We bought from the truck. It was outstanding.
Food: 5
Service: 5
New owner not professional with her staff. Needs to improve her people skills and learn respecting your staff only benefits you.
Service: 4
Great ice cream, fun flavors
Restaurantji Recommends
The store and restroom was clean and nice. The service was great and the ice cream was very yummy and moderately priced. Not on our side of town but we will return if we are in the neighborhood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Penn State Creamery Ice Cream!!!! Enough said. This place is great! The ice cream that they make on site is delicious, as well.
Parking: Careful pulling in and out of here, the entrance is steep and some cars inevitably bottom out. When in doubt, turn right and just go around the block.
Kid-friendliness: Great place for kids! The theming of this ice cream place is whimsical, and the yard games and GIANT chairs keep us coming back with every guest that comes to visit us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Death by Chocolate with Toppings, State Coffee Break, Death by Chocolate, Pre Packed Vegan Ice Cream
After reading the 5 star reviews, we went in, looking forward to ice cream cones. We waited in line and then we were informed that the vegan flavors were in the freezer case. I asked if we could have it put on a cone. The person behind the counter said no but she could give us a cone. We looked at the case and there were small servings of vanilla or some berry in vanilla. I prefer chocolate based, so we left. Disappointing experience. Perhaps we'll try again at some point.
One of the best Ice Cream Shops in York Co! Sarah's Creamery has both inside and outside seating and by far the largest selection of flavors around. The staff is friendly and does a great job taking care of customers.
Is it the best ice cream in the State? Maybe. I would say Sarah's and Handles are tied for the best, but Sarah's does have the advantage of being able to sit down inside with family. (also being next to the Burger Garage, makes for a great location for both a meal and dessert!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Death by Chocolate with Toppings, Waffle
It smells so good in this shop!! The milkshakes were great and I love that you can combine flavors.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...