Bennys II

2660 PA-115, Effort
(570) 730-4343

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

Chicken Parmigiana

Mozzarella Sticks

Calamari Marinara

Garlic Knots

Cheese Steak

Garlic Bread

Calamari

Sausage

Wings

Photos

+11 photos

+10 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Great experience. We ate there. My husband had a meatball parm sub. He loved it. Toasted with melted cheese. Prefect. I had a cheese steak with provolone and bacon. It was also toasted. This was the best steak sandwich I have had in years. They had slices ready to be heated that looked amazing. I will absolutely be back.

February 2026

I had ordered 2 plain slices. The cook said he had to make a fresh pie and askd if I can wait about 6-7 mins. I sure did. When I got my slices in less than 7 mins. The cook gave me an extra cheese on one of my slices. For free!The slices were awesome!! So good and it was around dinner time. The best pizza I ever had! 5 stars for this place. I will be back again.

January 2026

Have to shout out, we ordered Sunday, spicy calamari,smash burger and fries, and an Italian hoagie. Probably the best calamari around!! My wife thought the smash burger was the best burger she’s had in this area,ever, and the order of fries was enormous! The Italian hoagie was missing L/T/O but I added it at home and was awesome! I believe the missing L/T/O was purely a misunderstanding and thought I said no L/T/O when I said add L/T/O,no worries there. Can’t wait to try their...

November 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Effort, PA

Bennys II

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Bennys II