Carini Pizza

1075 Turnpike Rd, Elizabethtown
(717) 689-3351

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Daniel Krope

Nice size pizza slices...good crust. Sauce is a little sweet for me.

Autumn Reed

Delicious pizza, reasonably priced, and great staff! Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Martin Hahn

Now called bellia's. Ordered classic Philly cheese steak, menu said came with onions and cheese sauce. When we got it it had no cheese, then after we sent it back came with nacho cheese sauce. When we asked they said that's how they do it. When your menu sets an expectation of a Philly cheese steak you need to understand what that is. Definitely not nacho cheese. The staff was like whatever sorry for your luck with no attempt to offer anything else.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jean Tebay

Excellent food. Great service!

Jack Mentzer

Love ordering from Carini's! Since their "reopening" and Sal has taken over, it is great. Their "ham puffs" and homemade rolls are incredible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Petrask

Best pizza ? in PA. I'm originally from NJ and it's been hard finding decent pizza out this way. I recommend the chicken bacon ranch pie or the cheese steak pie. Off the beaten path because it's in a residential neighborhood. Used to be the SPOT bar & grill years ago.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Waylon Toney

The food I had would make any Italian grandmother happy. The Stromboli was amazing. The sausage was spicy. I likea the spicy meat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Caprece

kristyn ferraro

I loved the food and it felt like I was around my Italian family

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Benjamin McCurdy

Great customer service and great food. Thanks a lot!

W8506HBsusanm

My husband placed an order for pick up at Carini's this evening. He ordered a large cheese pizza and a chicken cheesesteak. He was on his way home after my son had practice - was about 20 minutes late for the pick up. When he arrived, the owner said he sold the cheese pizza and proudly reported, while still chewing, he was eating the chicken cheesesteak right at this moment. He said, "you're going to have to wait for me to make you new food." My husband walked out. I could understand if it was 8:30 and we were no shows. This was 7 p.m. Their service and attitude stunk before they closed and it still stinks after reopening. We will drive out of way to go to the other Etown pizza shops.

Benjamin Fansler

Good foods! Decent prices and great location.

Bearded Nomad Vanlife

says online they open till 9 on a Sunday and it's 5:45 and closed .. been here before and love the food and prices ... so I'm very bummed they not open today as I was looking to get the most bang for my buck since I'm looking to spend my last few dollars on food till I get paid Friday in a week

Doris Klinger

Of all the Pizza Shopps we have around, i love their pizza! Just the right amount of cheese on a tasty sauce, thin crust with a nice little roll on the edge so the crust doesn't overpower the pie. I did try a slice of Hawaiian Pizza but was not impressed with their choice of ham and too much pineapple.

Kathryn Yordy

Antipasto Salad tasted like a cigarette and the Tuna Salad was 80% mayo. Definitely not worth almost $20 and definitely do not recommend. 0/5 ⭐️

Hunter Miller

If you order something and have a specific allergy or don't like a specific food, don't order online. The menu doesn't disclose all ingredients, shouldn't have to find out when you get home that you can't eat the food you just bought.

Loading...